Real Munj and Mrinal in History

First Previous

Page

Frequent Posters

702755

Suspended

Posted: 8 years ago

#11

Originally posted by: -Mano-

Good that u read books
but anyways happy that wiki too said the same info😆😆
I know right they rock😉

They indeed rock. However before pritgpr vallabh I wanted them to play siblings as they played parvati and vishnu in their previous serials.😆

I first read about Munj in my history book and was devastated with the chapter that I rarely read it second time. 😊😭

Edited by Roxelana - 8 years ago

Quote

naq5

@naq5

Rocker

Posted: 8 years ago

#12

i dont think vishnu was played by ashish in devo ka dev. it was played by srj. Ashish played ram in siya ke ram but sonarika was not part of it

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

LIKEDMG

@LIKEDMG

Sparkler

Posted: 8 years ago

#13

TFS..it is sad ending..oh no!...wish if they will change it... 😭

Quote

702755

Suspended

Posted: 8 years ago

#14

Originally posted by: LIKEDMG
TFS..it is sad ending..oh no!...wish if they will change it... 😭

According to prabandha Chintamani Mrinal was an opportunist lady and she just used Munn for her pleasures. Ouch. But KM Munshi gave romantic touch to their illicit relationship. This series is fictional. They will tame the tragedy down. Mrinal and Munj are no love story in reality.

Edited by Roxelana - 8 years ago

Quote

702755

Suspended

Posted: 8 years ago

#15

Originally posted by: naq5
i dont think vishnu was played by ashish in devo ka dev. it was played by srj. Ashish played ram in siya ke ram but sonarika was not part of it

Ram is vishnu😆😆

Quote

LIKEDMG

@LIKEDMG

Sparkler

Posted: 8 years ago

#16

Originally posted by: Roxelana

According to prabandha Chintamani Mrinal was an opportunist lady and she just used Munn for her pleasures.Ouch. But KM Munshi gave romantic touch to their illicit relationship. This series is fictional. They will tame the tragedy down. Mrinal and Munj are no love story in reality.

Ouch!..Like Mastani and Bajirao... 😭 ...

Like GOT I want Fire and ICE to be together ever after... 😳

Quote

486792

Hibernated

Posted: 8 years ago

#17

Originally posted by: Roxelana

According to prabandha Chintamani Mrinal was an opportunist lady and she just used Munn for her pleasures. Ouch. But KM Munshi gave romantic touch to their illicit relationship. This series is fictional. They will tame the tragedy down. Mrinal and Munj are no love story in reality.

Excuse me?! Can you please share the link or cite the sources where it was written that Mrinal is an 'opportunistic lady who used Munj for pleasures and there was no love story?🤪

My cousin who is a Prof has done a thorough research on this entire topic as well as the Prabandha Chintamani.He said that the texts barely mention Mrinal let alone describe what kind of a relationship she shared with Vakpati Munj.

History books barely mention the Rashtrakuta dynasty let alone Munj or Prithvi Vallabh.Bhoj is the most well known ruler of this dynasty.Only those who opted for higher studies got to learn about Munj and Mrinal is simply mentioned.No text describes her personality or what kind of a woman the historical Mrinal was.

Therefore it gives the authors the liberty to interpret it in their own ways.Munshi interpreted it in his own way and so did Anirudh Pathak.

Quote

702755

Suspended

Posted: 8 years ago

#18

Originally posted by: --BlackSheep--
Excuse me?! Can you please share the link or cite the sources where it was written that Mrinal is an 'opportunistic lady who used Munj for pleasures and there was no love story?🤪
My cousin who is a Prof has done a thorough research on this entire topic as well as the Prabandha Chintamani.He said that the texts barely mention Mrinal let alone describe what kind of a relationship she shared with Vakpati Munj.

History books barely mention the Rashtrakuta dynasty let alone Munj or Prithvi Vallabh.Bhoj is the most well known ruler of this dynasty.Only those who opted for higher studies got to learn about Munj and Mrinal is simply mentioned.No text describes her personality or what kind of a woman the historical Mrinal was.
Therefore it gives the authors the liberty to interpret it in their own ways.Munshi interpreted it in his own way and so did Anirudh Pathak.

Usually shippers can't take anything negative about their beloved characters. This serial is a fictional thing and I have accepted that. II am even watching it for Sona and Ashish only. Dont believe my post , I am not forcing anyone to believe me. I wrote what I read and analyzed about her. Historians has called execution of munj as a result of political conspiracy. Believe and preach whatever you like. No one serious about history is gonna check India forums.

Edited by Roxelana - 8 years ago

Quote

486792

Hibernated

Posted: 8 years ago

#19

^^Dude,what I am asking from you is evidence.Cite the sources from where you have 'read and analysed' about her.😛

That's all I am asking.Name the book and the author who has described her character.Also share the link about the article where historians have mentioned about Munj's execution.😃

What I am saying was not the musing or belief of a 'shipper'.Rather it was what I learnt from a history scholar who has done thorough research in the topic.

Did I ever mention that Mrinal was an angel?I simply stated the fact that there are very few sources which barely mention her let alone describe her characteristics.

It's upto the interpreter's imagination.Munshi wrote what he believed and you are writing what you believe in.

Either way there is no fixed version😛You were imposing your comments as if they are accurate historical facts.

But thank you for stating that those were just your opinions and assumptions.

Oh yes!! No one serious about history checks IF.Everyone is here to discuss the show and have fun.😉And people are really enjoying the show and the actors

Edited by --BlackSheep-- - 8 years ago

Quote

1 2

Real Munj and Mrinal in History - Page 2

Related Topics

Explore Topics