702755 thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#1
I have nothing against the show. I am loving it as the story and cast is so good but munj and mrinal's story is the story of betrayl and honour killing. Wish it would have been story of munj and his ideals instead of munj's obsession for Mrinal. It will so destroy hos senses that he will reveal his plans to her and then his gruesome death.ah. For me Mrinal is an opportunistic and selfish person.
On side note is amrusha kusumvati (munj's wife)? I am liking amrusha , she and munj are very cute together.
Edited by Roxelana - 7 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

9

Views

3.4k

Users

8

Likes

61

Frequent Posters

bugsbunny12 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 7 years ago
#2
Okay first things first

Munj? 🤣🤣🤣

Secondly,

its a real story, with of course, changes done to attract audience
so obviously i wouldnt mind a love story, their chemistry is what brought me here in the 1st place
486792 thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#3
First of all the context of a historical depends on how you see it.Its not mandatory that every historical figure's life will be a sad story dedicated towards some purpose.This show deals with a phase in Prithvi Vallabh's life which is what changed his life forever.Mrinal is an integral part of his life and she can never ever be overlooked.The love story with Mrinal is the what forms the crux of Prithvi's story.



Then where is it written that Prithvi Vallabh's story is about betrayal?And where does honour killing fit over here? Mr Anirudh Pathak has mentioned umpteen number of times that this show is neither based on KM Munshi's novel nor on the old movie.Its 80% mystery and 20% history.Infact there are really few sources about Prithvi Vallabh's history.Even Munshi's novel is not entirely accurate.
This show is the star crossed love story between two individuals who are polar opposites and how they affect each other's lives.
Prithvi is certainly not 'obsessed' with Mrinal.He was looking for someone all his life and he felt connected to Mrinal.And at a point he will fall passionately in love with her coz that's what the story is about.


And Mrinal is selfish and opportunistic?She is a human being.She was clear about her goal from Day 1 and will do anything to achieve that.She is someone with a scarred past.As a child she saw her entire family getting murdered in front of eyes.So it's natural for her to turn cold and bitter.At the same time her loving side appears in front of those she cares about.
She is extremely practical and pragmatic.Prithvi needs her as much as she needs him.
And even if she is ruthless to her enemies it's not a big deal.All great kings in history possessed ruthlessness.So why can't a princess be the same? She is not cruel mind you.Neither is she a totally mahaan character. She is what I call a beautifully flawed grey shaded character.

Also I guess many people are enjoying this love story as it's different from what's usually shown on TV.The execution and characterizations are superb and the leads are impeccable actors with a superb chemistry.
jayvenk thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#4
Neatly put @Blacksheep
Most viewers are looking for the run of the mill love story, that is something PV is not going to deliver.
It is delivering on a plantain leaf , each dish on it sweet, sour, bitter spicy. They all sit next to each other, yet all different. But together they taste great. 😉
Most serials dish out a one pot meal. 😔
Sorry about the food take off
702755 thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: --BlackSheep--

First of all the context of a historical depends on how you see it.Its not mandatory that every historical figure's life will be a sad story dedicated towards some purpose.This show deals with a phase in Prithvi Vallabh's life which is what changed his life forever.Mrinal is an integral part of his life and she can never ever be overlooked.The love story with Mrinal is the what forms the crux of Prithvi's story.



Then where is it written that Prithvi Vallabh's story is about betrayal?And where does honour killing fit over here? Mr Anirudh Pathak has mentioned umpteen number of times that this show is neither based on KM Munshi's novel nor on the old movie.Its 80% mystery and 20% history.Infact there are really few sources about Prithvi Vallabh's history.Even Munshi's novel is not entirely accurate.
This show is the star crossed love story between two individuals who are polar opposites and how they affect each other's lives.
Prithvi is certainly not 'obsessed' with Mrinal.He was looking for someone all his life and he felt connected to Mrinal.And at a point he will fall passionately in love with her coz that's what the story is about.


And Mrinal is selfish and opportunistic?She is a human being.She was clear about her goal from Day 1 and will do anything to achieve that.She is someone with a scarred past.As a child she saw her entire family getting murdered in front of eyes.So it's natural for her to turn cold and bitter.At the same time her loving side appears in front of those she cares about.
She is extremely practical and pragmatic.Prithvi needs her as much as she needs him.
And even if she is ruthless to her enemies it's not a big deal.All great kings in history possessed ruthlessness.So why can't a princess be the same? She is not cruel mind you.Neither is she a totally mahaan character. She is what I call a beautifully flawed grey shaded character.

Also I guess many people are enjoying this love story as it's different from what's usually shown on TV.The execution and characterizations are superb and the leads are impeccable actors with a superb chemistry.



Very nice analysis but I was talking about real Mrinal in history. Well you took my post too seriously. I am not criticising at all. I am loving that show.
CutiepieAD thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#6
^^ I don't know much abt this part of history.
But from whatever I have heard about K M Munshi's book she was arrogant in the beginning but later she was head over heels with Prithvi. Infact she didn't want him to escape because she thought after escaping he might not love her like then as he would get busy with his Kingdom and wife. She loved the moments they were spending in prison therefore wanted him to remain in Manyakhet as a prisoner forever, in that way she'll have him forever
That's the reason she told Tailap about the escape plan. Mrinal had never even thought in her wildest dreams that Tailap will get PV killed. She remained guilt ridden throughout her life.
According to the movie she gave up her life along with Prithvi.
So at least in the novel n the movie she wasn't that cruel as selfish. She was a human character, had her own flaws yet was lovable.


In the show her character has been improved even more. She has been given a strong reason to hate PV n Malwa.
Edited by CutiepieAD - 7 years ago
anshvi thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 7 years ago
#7
I personally am okay with the love story
Mr. Aniruddh Pathak had specifically said that love story is obviously the core but he also said that he is showcasing two different ideologies

Mrinal is a complex character...She is flawed...She is blinded by revenge..Yes her actions can't be justified right now but we do know the reason behind her hatred...and as the show will progress her ideology will change once she will fall in love with Prithvi

I am glad that for a change we are getting grey characters who are very human and not saints

Now as I said it will be interesting to see how Mrinal and Prithvi will fall in love but I also want to see other characters being explored which will make the show more interesting and not get monotonous over the course of time

This show has some brilliantly written characters who are grey, flawed and very human and characters have very interesting dynamics and i hope that will get explored apart from the love story which is obviously the core of the show

So, I personally I am curious to see other bonds as well like Mrinal and Tailap , Tailap-Kosha-Jhakkala equation, Sindhu and Prithvi etc. etc. apart from PriNal

I also want to see battle sequences 😆

I am liking the show so far and i hope this will be maintained as the show will progress
Edited by anshvi - 7 years ago
Mano.M thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 7 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: CutiepieAD

^^ I don't know much abt this part of history.

But from whatever I have heard about K M Munshi's book she was arrogant in the beginning but later she was head over heels with Prithvi. Infact she didn't want him to escape because she thought after escaping he might not love her like then as he would get busy with his Kingdom and wife. She loved the moments they were spending in prison therefore wanted him to remain in Manyakhet as a prisoner forever, in that way she'll have him forever
That's the reason she told Tailap about the escape plan. Mrinal had never even thought in her wildest dreams that Tailap will get PV killed. She remained guilt ridden throughout her life.
According to the movie she gave up her life along with Prithvi.
So at least in the novel n the movie she wasn't that cruel as selfish. She was a human character, had her own flaws yet was lovable.


In the show her character has been improved even more. She has been given a strong reason to hate PV n Malwa.




Aditi to begin with there is no much History available about Mrinal
Most info are from the movie and novel
and both contradict each other(most part of them are fiction too)
that's why AP clearly said 20% and 80% Mystery
bcos there is no 100% records of History to begin with
that too specially about Mrinal😆😆
Edited by -Mano- - 7 years ago
shruthiravi thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 7 years ago
#9
Ashi you have put most of the things I wanted to put. Just wanted to add couple of things. Humans whether it is man or woman has flaws, women also feel the anger, they also have ego and that doesnt mean they are bad. Just like these qualities doesnt make a man bad. Again men also has softer emotions, they also are nurturers. The story is exploring a contrast where the expected masculine traits are in a female and the expected feminine traits are in a man.
If the roles are reversed the glory will be sung of the woman who tolerated the man, transformed him, sacrificed for him. But here when reverse happens a woman is crucified. It's time we get such stories because more than history a woman like Mrinal is a reality of the present world. Women with scarred past at various levels.
Mano.M thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 7 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: shruthiravi

Ashi you have put most of the things I wanted to put. Just wanted to add couple of things. Humans whether it is man or woman has flaws, women also feel the anger, they also have ego and that doesnt mean they are bad. Just like these qualities doesnt make a man bad. Again men also has softer emotions, they also are nurturers. The story is exploring a contrast where the expected masculine traits are in a female and the expected feminine traits are in a man.

If the roles are reversed the glory will be sung of the woman who tolerated the man, transformed him, sacrificed for him. But here when reverse happens a woman is crucified. It's time we get such stories because more than history a woman like Mrinal is a reality of the present world. Women with scarred past at various levels.


Can't be explained any better👍🏼

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".