Picture abhi baki hain, mere dost!! - Page 2

Originally posted by: sanfan

U know Soup...when I look at the serial at what it has shown so far...it hasnt shown Naina having any real understanding of Sameer's circumstances...apart from the poverty of plenty that the not-so-affluent see the affluent having...When Sameer has a breakdown on the hilltop...I dont think Naina has reacted to any aspect of how it all came about...this is what most viewers have missed in the narrative...Naina has no idea how Sameer has a chip on his shoulder on that matter except in some passing phrases...unless my memory is failing me here..She knows the guy has some issues...but I don't think she has reflected much on how it has affected Sameer's way of thinking. In fact, even Sameer will have a better understanding of Naina's circumstances now. Naina's reaction on that hill top was of a heart filled with love wanting to comfort a friend. However, in the aftermath of what followed...she sees it all as tainted. She is unlikely to see it as anything else until she has an ability to see beyond herself at the moment. She has kept her grief a central theme for now...

Originally posted by: Infofan

Lovely post Rekha. Even better that it brought Soupster out of the woodwok😆

Well...I had to engineer it, you know...😆😆 Soup and I go back a long way!!😊

I am just able to HHBB for now.

This might come up if & when Arjun sees Sameer is making genuine efforts to mend things & repenting for his actions but again Naina & Arjun have not connected the paper stealing issue as the cause of the incidents that followed and lead up to the bet. The loving protective brother will find it more challenging to forgive Sameer for hurting his sis and might hold grudges longer & harder than Naina herself. IF Arjun gets to know the effects of his paper stealing on the lives of other people he will be the next one going into a guilt mode😆 If, when & How to reveal the paper stealing is upto the CVs. I would like to say the team ties all the loose ends & the show doesnt have many loopholes but after conveniently forgetting about the thrashing Sameer got in Mt Abu, who knows 😆

I don't doubt their intention about going back to that aspect..(unless the vagaries of this medium start to make their presence felt more deeply😆.) In my books I see them as two separate events (even if I see one as a precipitating event for the other) because if one rationalises...Sameer may have made the bet because he felt that Naina wilfully accused him of wrongdoing but as he went on a journey of discovery, he actually fell in love with her despite that aspect. So, for somewhere that aspect has ceased to matter to him. He seems to have taken that matter in stride or a matter of misjudgement on Naina's part. Yet the truth is Naina's action of accusing Sameer was a honest mistake at that time but a sin of omission after knowing Sameer is not at fault. She came clean in an opaque manner to Sameer but without addressing the justice in the matter. So this is an intentional hole to be revisited at some stage but how will it be addressed will depend on flow of the narrative at that time. They can make it dramatic or make circumstances the culprit!!😆

About Arjun's role in this repentence...hmmm I can't really say. In that the dynamics between Shefali and Arjun come into play. So far I have seen Arjun reacting to Shefali the most. He seems to be in her thrall.😉..she has the maximum ability to influence. Shefali is a wonderfully written character. In the scene where she senses Arjun being pressurised by Rakesh, she is able to empathise with Arjun but at the same time, she is able to tell Arjun where to get off on the guilt train when he begins to pontificate on the importance of it all. 😆 So I see Shefali playing a role with respect to the Arjun realisation. How it affects this story or their story ...remains to be seen!!

Rest you have already covered everything!

Originally posted by: DivyaDivI10

hii sanfan.. I'm your fan by EDKV time too.. love reading your thoughts.. you put it very well

I with Naina as always she may wrong to hiding the big thing but that was not her fault.. She always said Sam that he not done this that she no.. but the time will come and I'm sure she going to say the truth if the truth come by Arjun itself I will be more happy.. btw I request you

can you make a post about Sameer love for Naina ie were everyone missing something that Sam in love yes I agree CV should show some glimpse of Sam remembering Naina in his thoughts an how the way Naina fallen been shown not in Sameer's I no you may also feel the deconect do you ?

Originally posted by: Infofan

Lovely post Rekha. Even better that it brought Soupster out of the woodwok😆

I am just able to HHBB for now.

This might come up if & when Arjun sees Sameer is making genuine efforts to mend things & repenting for his actions but again Naina & Arjun have not connected the paper stealing issue as the cause of the incidents that followed and lead up to the bet. The loving protective brother will find it more challenging to forgive Sameer for hurting his sis and might hold grudges longer & harder than Naina herself. IF Arjun gets to know the effects of his paper stealing on the lives of other people he will be the next one going into a guilt mode😆 If, when & How to reveal the paper stealing is upto the CVs. I would like to say the team ties all the loose ends & the show doesnt have many loopholes but after conveniently forgetting about the thrashing Sameer got in Mt Abu, who knows 😆

Rest you have already covered everything!

Originally posted by: sanfan

Thank you for your kind words...EDKV was indeed something despite all the pain in the end...wasnt it?😊

@Bold...Divya, As of now I would put it more to the circumstances in which he has fallen in love rather than any other thing.

Naina...and Sameer's journey in love has been different. In Naina's case...she has sought out this love..she has fallen with the idea of love as much as falling in love with Sameer, so it was expected that Naina's journey would a bit more dramatic than Sameer...who has found love more like a prayer..before he can celebrate it...he was forced to come to terms with the issues surrounding it. If we rewind a bit...when he confided in Nanaji...there was that dramatic song ( in his dreams ofc😆) and he was all agog to pursue Naina with earnestness...but all hell broke loose...so he has been pushed to a corner suddenly until Nanu gave him that hope again. I am not a huge fan of monologues in the narrative as I feel it tends to look out of place when it looks inserted for the viewers rather than for the character..ofc this is my just personal view and viewers may think differently...

As a viewer, you need to ask the question. Are you in doubt that Sameer loves Naina? If yes, why? due to the lack of verbalising or monologues? All I can say is...aren't his actions a clear indication that he is ready to do things the old Sameer may have baulked at? For instance, the Sameer of yore may not have stood to let someone know he is taking leave...today that guy was literally begging for her acknowledgement...if only to be shouted at!! His merriment when his friends tease...the old Sameer would have swatted them off for their drama...today that Sameer revels in it. He is quick to acknowledge that he is the Salim who will rebel to have a glimpse of his Anarkali...Are you still in doubt?😆😆who knows some more madness is in store...and I am sure this guy will leave Naina behind in his antics😉😉

Originally posted by: sanfan

Thank you for your kind words...EDKV was indeed something despite all the pain in the end...wasnt it?😊

@Bold...Divya, As of now I would put it more to the circumstances in which he has fallen in love rather than any other thing.

Naina...and Sameer's journey in love has been different. In Naina's case...she has sought out this love..she has fallen with the idea of love as much as falling in love with Sameer, so it was expected that Naina's journey would a bit more dramatic than Sameer...who has found love more like a prayer..before he can celebrate it...he was forced to come to terms with the issues surrounding it. If we rewind a bit...when he confided in Nanaji...there was that dramatic song ( in his dreams ofc😆) and he was all agog to pursue Naina with earnestness...but all hell broke loose...so he has been pushed to a corner suddenly until Nanu gave him that hope again. I am not a huge fan of monologues in the narrative as I feel it tends to look out of place when it looks inserted for the viewers rather than for the character..ofc this is my just personal view and viewers may think differently...

As a viewer, you need to ask the question. Are you in doubt that Sameer loves Naina? If yes, why? due to the lack of verbalising or monologues? All I can say is...aren't his actions a clear indication that he is ready to do things the old Sameer may have baulked at? For instance, the Sameer of yore may not have stood to let someone know he is taking leave...today that guy was literally begging for her acknowledgement...if only to be shouted at!! His merriment when his friends tease...the old Sameer would have swatted them off for their drama...today that Sameer revels in it. He is quick to acknowledge that he is the Salim who will rebel to have a glimpse of his Anarkali...Are you still in doubt?😆😆who knows some more madness is in store...and I am sure this guy will leave Naina behind in his antics😉😉