Jab Harry Met Sejal BO/ Review Thread # 2 - DTNpg27

pallavi25 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 7 years ago
#1

Critics Reviews

ALL Critics Reviews are here:


http://www.india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=4880887&PID=143318123&#p143318123





New Review from Zee News Ritika Handoo: Aug 5

http://www.india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=4881882&PID=143354975&#p143354975


Komal Nahta's Review of movie and SRK's performance:

[YOUTUBE]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QEaWs2kSPKU[/YOUTUBE]
Edited by pallavi25 - 7 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

558

Views

41.2k

Users

99

Likes

1k

Frequent Posters

pallavi25 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 7 years ago
#2


ALL OLD REVIEWS by MEMBERS are here:


http://www.india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=4880887&PID=143318157&#p143318157


http://www.india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=4880887&PID=143318172&#p143318172


---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


New Reviews by members:

Ranbirrocks:

Watched it yesterday with a group of friends who are of various nationalities - Moroccan, German and French.
Occupancy was very good, almost all seats were occupied. Considering it is school holidays, I was surprised to see the crowd. No wonder, JHMS is doing well in overseas. People want to see SRK movie here and his stardom is beyond boundaries.


About Movie -

Thankfully it is not a dark and broody Imtiaz Ali movie. This is a happy movie, the one that makes you smile and give you that feeling which was missing from our screen for a long time.

SRK looked good !! He was playing 40 yr old and he didn't look like a miscast. I don't remember last time when SRK looked so dishy, so yeah, for SRK fans, it is paisa wasool in looks department.

Anu's character was annoying, yet loving. Anu is becoming a pro at playing flawed characters and still you end up loving her. She looked good and was OTT at some places, but overall she acted well.

I loved SRK-Anu chemistry. I think this is their best chemistry so far.

First half was breezy. For me, the European locations aren't attractive coz I have been to those places many times and some are my weekend getaway, but for many people, Europe darshan will be added advantage.

Second half could have been tighter. I don't understand how people who make movie can't see glaring problem in second half? Cut a few songs, edit 20 mins and you will have a beautiful and nearly flawless movie.

Now about the question that everyone is asking - Why would a girl go around Europe to find a ring? The chances of finding it on streets are nearly zero. Well, the answer is hidden in the movie and Harry explains it to Sejal .

I asked same question to my German friend and she simply said - Ofcourse Engagement ring is very important , even I will do my best to find it. It is a bad omen to lose your engagement / wedding ring - That's a firangi's answer and she didn't find anything odd in the premise of movie.

My rating 3.5/5 - A feel good movie, watch it for SRK-Anu and Europe
I left with a smile on my face and everyone with me also felt it was a good movie.

ETA - I was disappointed in Music of the movie. This is Imtiaz's movie, so the expectations of Music is very high. Songs are good, but they are not IA movie level good. His movie Album is always a clear choice of Music album of the year. This time, it sounds repetitive.

Placement of songs was also not good.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Review by Sri-R

I just loved the movie..it's a happy movie ..it brought smile on my face. This is SRK best chemistry with Anu, though my heart broke watching SRK kiss Anu. Second half is little dragged , could have done better. Kudos to SRK and Anu for making thus movie watchable. Srk looked dreamy ( at least for me) and looking great. I liked most of the songs...Except butterfly song. Anu wasn't loud to me..she did perfect job and looking sexy n beautiful. I give 4.5 star to movie . To SRK and Anushka 5/5
Btw the occupancy is 90%

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


Review by anumz_31
http://www.india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=4881882&PID=143417876&#p143417876

I saw the movie yesterday and I really enjoyed it! Around January, the theater that used to play bollywood movies near my house was taken over by amc and they stopped playing bolly movies. They did play Raess and after that now JHMS (don't have a clue why only these two). For all other bollywood movies we have to go to the amc almost an hour away.

The beginning of the movie was a bit slow for me but once I got into it I liked it. I don't understand the negativity around this movie, it really isn't bad at all. My sister usually doesn't like bollywood movies and even she said it wasn't bad lol.

I was talking to my mom after the movie and I was like I loved humpty sharma ki dulhanniya, love aaj kal etc but none of those actors (although I like Varun Dhawan) can make me feel the way Shahrukh Khan can. I don't know how to explain it but he makes you feel that love waali feeling which no one else can. Shahrukh looked great, anushka was fine and they had great chemistry. Songs were okay, was expecting a better album since imtiaz ali movies usually have really good songs. But I'm in love with hawaayein! The movie had some really nice moments and the way SRK expresses with his eyes, ufff amazing! I really miss seeing Shahrukh Khan in romantic movies, no one does romance better than him. So ya, overall a nice love story.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------



Edited by pallavi25 - 7 years ago
pallavi25 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 7 years ago
#3


NEW Reviews by Members posted in this thread:


Review by Hippopotamus: pg 1

http://www.india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=4881882&PID=143353890&#p143353890


-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Review by Justmoi : pg 2

http://www.india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=4881882&PID=143353951&#p143353951


------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

nishu786 Review: pg 3

http://www.india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=4881882&PID=143354445&#p143354445

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Review by Anachronist:

I watched the movie yesterday and now I will give my detailed review
Story:- Story is of a man called harvinder nehra who is a tour guide in the netherlands, however it is shown in the opening song( safar) that he is not happy. After a strenuous month in which he accompanied a gujrati family , he is flabbergasted to find that the young daughter sejal has stayed back and wants to search for her engagement ring instead . He is forced to be with her and they form an unlikely friendship . Now if they find the ring or not and what happens to their friendship forms the crux of the story.

Acting :- Shahrukh Khan is back to his best form (he is lovely here). Anushka sharma is bit loud in parts but overall she is okay.

ediitng :- done by aarti bajaj , always been fan of her , she has done decent job.

screenplay :- good

directing :- decent

music :- could have been better , radha and butterfly are my favourites.

Overall I found the movie enjoyable and there was little or no dull moment for me . As a romantic movie fan , I loved it and was satisfied with the experience.

My rating:- 4 stars ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Review by Ranbirrocks:

http://www.india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=4881882&PID=143357652&#p143357652



-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Review by anitarani:

Just saw the movie...liked it...light happy movie...
and loved SRK all through...good for a one time
watch..Family too was cool with the movie...so
SRK charm did work..

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Review by sujairohit

Watched the movie today with family.In fact I had already told them its slow and many have not liked it.But to my surprise we all loved it.We liked it more than Raees.Both Shahrukh and Anushka have acted very well.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Review by mnmj

watched it with my parents
big srk fan
family found it ok
i hated it
srk charm made it manageable
acting by both srk and anushka was extremly good though

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Sujal's Review:

http://www.india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=4881882&PID=143379542&#p143379542


----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Review by Member KhanYouGoAway:


The film was packed for a Tuesday. Srk ki stardom in the UK is untouchable.

Now onto the film.. I don't even know what to say. Srk is my favourite star and I watch every film of his regardless of reviews so I was going to watch this regardless, but pre release I wasn't excited for this l, like at all. Compare it to January 25th 2017. I had been looking forward and counting down for days for the release of Raees. JHMS is probably the latest I've been to see a srk film in cinema.

Anyway. The film.. wow, possibly the worst srk film I've seen since.. I don't even know. Srks 'bad films' in recent years like Ra one and Happy new year are master pieces compare to this.

The best thing about the film was SRk, I found the story boring and Anushka annoying.

I was so bored, like really bored. I've never experienced this in any of srk films, I was waiting for the ending credits to appear that's how bored I was.

I don't want to give the story (the little of it) away but damn, How he even chose a script like this is beyond belief.

Please shah. Don't make or choose a film script like this again. Unbelievable how annoyed and disappointed I am after watching this.

Please Continue to do films like Raees and Fan.

This is all on imtiaz ali. Awful director.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Review by Member JustMySelf: pg 50

http://www.india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=4881882&PID=143406509&#p143406509


-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


Review by pallavi25 : pg 63
http://www.india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=4881882&PID=143425363&#p143425363


----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------











Edited by pallavi25 - 7 years ago
pallavi25 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 7 years ago
#4


Jab Harry Met Sejal Day Two Business Estimate
Saturday 05 August 2017 23.30 IST
Box Office India Trade Network

Jab Harry Met Sejal struggled for growth on its second as collections outside the big cities fell. The film will collect around the 14-14.50 crore nett range on its second day and take its business to around 29.50 crore nett in two days.

The film could get close to its day one figures when final figures come in but there is little chance of a higher second day than the first day. This was always likely as films with limited appeal will find it tough to hold numbers at the level it collected on day one.

Jab Harry Met Sejal is trending very similar to Tubelight but at a lower level. That film also face a similar drop on day two and gain it was a case of an initial which just could not be held as the film did not hold appeal for the wider audience. Here it was sort of expected as the director Imtiaz Ali has a poor track record but with Tubelight the director had a Bajrangi Bhaijaan and Ek Tha Tiger behind him but went to the cinema he made before these films.

There is a partial holiday on Monday which will help collections on Monday and on Sunday evening but the film cant really survive in the long run at these levels with this second day trend.


Edited by pallavi25 - 7 years ago
pallavi25 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 7 years ago
#5

BOX OFFICE UPDATES

BOI:

Day 1 Friday: 15.5 crores

Day 2 Saturday: 14.25 crores

Day 3 Sunday: 14.75 crores

Day 4 Monday: 6.25 crores

Day 5 Tuesday: 3 crores

Total: 53.75 crores



OVERSEAS 1st Weekend: $7 Million Total



-----------------------------------------------------------------

Taran Adarsh:

Fri 15.25 crores

Sat 15 crores

Sunday: 15.50 crores

Monday: 7 crores

Tuesday: 3 crores

TOTAL : 55. 90 crores


WORLDWIDE: 110 crores
Edited by pallavi25 - 7 years ago
1011128 thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#6
I have mixed feelings.

1. Positives.

a. Shahrukh. He is looking amazing..he acted amazing. He was definitely looking 40 in this movie. He is just a super super star and magician.

b. Anushka. No words are enough to praise her. How can one be so beautiful and yet do justice to her role. I knew some were saying her gujrati accent was a put off. Though I am not an expert on Gujrati but to me she looked cute and funny. Actually audience laughed at her role the most. She just carried the role perfectly. She is at peak of her career where she is not making one mistake.

c. Locations. I liked the locations but I am not that big fan of seeing Europe etc but still it was good.

d. Songs were not bad. There was some song in between which i had not heard..it was the best one.

2. Negatives

a. The concept of the movie. I dont think anyone even the richest of them all would do all this for a ring. It was just a bad start and movie never recovered. a good movie cannot be made on a weak foundation. it crumbles at some point

b. Screenplay. It was not in good flow. It did not captivate me. Mubarkan on the other hand made me watch the screen all the time

c. second half. well it was a pain. it felt like it was going on and on. i msged from cinema that i fear punjab visit is still to come and guess what it came. lol. there was no need for that Qureshi angle..there was no need for mayank wedding. and ending was just so typical.

d. It felt like Imtiaz was trying to mix many movies into one...jab we met type story, punjab setting of every second movie these days, dil waale style trips all over europe..some needless...and then of course pyaar to hona hi tha style visit back home. hero was a kabira from yeh jawani deewani movie. Overall it lacked novelty...something new

e. I never understood what sejal wanted. her character was not clear. she was sanskari but very blunt and forward at the same time. it was just a lost character. SRk did sort of summarize her in the end when he said maybe u were not seeking the ring..u were seeking something else. he meant seeking some emptiness in srk. i say she was subconsciously not ready to marriage. in either case her role was not clear.

3. Conclusion

Hippo is a fair person in the end. Despite my liking for Anushka I wont give it fake rating. However it was not as bad as people were making it to be. It was quite watchable..first half was funny and good. the drawback if anything was second half and how it was dragged and that too with lame old ideas. SRK did an amazing job. Brilliant actor. Let me tell you Anushak indeed looked pristine and all the dances were hot and sizzling...her gujrati character came out as cute and made people laugh

In summary I will give it 3/5. I dont go over 4 usually. So my 3 is a good movie. I think it is not great but definitely not terrible like Tubelight. My family members are giving the same review. That is it is a lot better than Tubelight and should not be equated. Here the fault lies with story and Imtiaz.

Thanks

pallavi25 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 7 years ago
#7

Jab Harry Met Sejal First Day Business
Saturday 05 August 2017 10.30 IST
Box Office India Trade Network

Jab Harry Met Sejal had a reasonable first day as it grossed 15.50 crore nett apprx on the first day. The film has only really managed to collect in metros with collections outside the five metros coming out low. A huge chunk of the collections have come in Mumbai, Delhi NCR, Bangalore, Pune and Bangalore while the rest have hardly contributed. Even Punjab where there are big multiplexes is well below the mark outside Gurgaon which is basically NCR. The performance is very much like Tubelight with the opening day collections much higher than the appeal of the content and that film did not grow over the wekend and it could be same case here unless metros really push higher.

>

The film is the lowest Shahrukh Khan opener of recent times as if we account for the holiday factor of Fan then the collections come out similar to that film. Just like with Salman Khan with Tubelight, these big stars can't do films which have limited reach as when it comes to numbers you are depending on just star power and that is just a first day thing and even that will not be as it should. A Raees crossed 20 crore nett plus with a clash even though its was a poor film because it had reach. This does not have the reach which looked likely before the release as the director has a record of films which have limited reach and appreciation Now its about how or if the film can grow on Saturday as it will be its best chance because the film is only collecting in metros and thats a Saturday audience. Outside metros there is a good chance of drops of in many places.


Edited by pallavi25 - 7 years ago
EAST9 thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#8
I must say, SRK is a good actor because he look better than Anu in JHMS (as how Deepika look better in TAMASHA than Ranbir).

Anu is overacting AF and OTT.

Now, I think I know IF "good acting" standard = overacting+OTT.

LOLOLOLOL!

But, I must say to SRK, karma came to you because of your "dirty". He need to clean everything..
Edited by donnygirlly - 7 years ago
Justmoi thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#9
Here's my review.
My parents used movies not just for entertainment but to relate to India and it's culture, learn language and showcase so many aspects of it. Despite those lofty goals, my dad's favorite actor is Thalaiva. I would repeatedly ask him how he could like Thalaiva when there are so many better actors around and he would say because he was happy watching a Thalaiva movie. And there was value in that.

I am boring people with this story because going to an SRK movie is like that. Watching him onscreen makes me happy and as long as he makes a movie I will go. So I got paisa vasool like that.

But there is this other part of me that sits on message boards and analyzes movies, that blasts actors who I think deserve it and it would be very hypocritical of me if I did not do it to my favorite actor.

What the hell was the script and what was Shah on when he chose it ? There was no sort of engagement at all, well not on the level that caused me to like this man from childhood. Who made crap scripts like KKHH make sense because he was in it. Who made Raj such an iconic character. Where is that SRK ? It really is appalling that with each passing movie that actor is buried deeper and deeper. It actually hurts to see this because I know what this man is capable of.

Speaking of crap scripts, I have mocked KJO numerous times for his scripts. After this, I will not cause I have a new target. Imtiaz. what the hell was Imtiaz on when he came up with this ? How can a man who made Socha Na Tha come up with this crap ? Is it on purpose, hubris because he knows Imitiaz the name has a certain cachet.

Anu tried valiantly. But she is no Kajol to make crap like KKHH shine despite the script and she had no help from Shah. Europe was pretty, but BTDT.

Shah really, really, really needs to evaluate what kind of an actor he wants to be. I want to go to a Shah movie because the movie excites me not seeing him on screen makes me happy. I hope he will soon find that actor buried deep cause I miss him so much.

I can't rate a Shah movie so no rating, only ranting. 😳
Stone-Cold thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 7 years ago
#10
How much so far guys?

I'm going tomorrow. My family went on Friday and said it was houseful. Queues after queues. They enjoyed it. Said it was a good time pass.

Related Topics

Bollywood Thumbnail

Posted by: priya185

3 months ago

Celebrities at the MET Gala- Shah Rukh, Kiara, Priyanka, Diljit (new) Celebrities at the MET Gala- Shah Rukh, Kiara, Priyanka, Diljit (new)

Celebrities at the MET Gala 2025 Here you go you2 https://www.instagram.com/p/DJSptl7Sr5q/?igsh=MTRqdzRnZ2p5ZWxiZQ==...

Expand ▼
Bollywood Thumbnail

Posted by: priya185

2 months ago

Is Uorfi’s outfit here better than other Met Gala/ Cannes outfit

Is Uorfi’s outfit here better than other Met Gala/ Cannes outfit Discuss https://www.instagram.com/reel/DJt71CHy86N/?igsh=bXZ6YXdsZ2J0dXl0

Expand ▼
Bollywood Thumbnail

Posted by: elim

2 months ago

MET Gala power ranking Men - SRK tops

https://www.instagram.com/p/DJkl_CJM_u5/?img_index=4 igsh=MWw1dnc2Ymw1bG44OA==

https://www.instagram.com/p/DJkl_CJM_u5/?img_index=4
Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".