Rise and Fall of Arundhati Nanavati Katarra

bluejalpari17 thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#1

Wanted to post this over the weekend but finding time just now.


Something that was gnawing on my mind was the speed and zeal with which Aru is pursuing her " crush" and " haq- rights on her husband" right now, I was not able to put a finger on it, but the more I thought about it..I was reminded of the the phrase "what goes up comes down with the same speed or worse" . I will not call her feelings true LOVE right now, because she is not there yet. She is not there where she can recognize her feelings, sift out the lower emotions like jealousy and possessiveness, move to the higher emotions of bonding of the souls and what that one man means to her in the universe, and why she might have been the chosen one for him. When she reaches that stage , her heart will be in peace even if he does not love her back.

But right now, as I mentioned earlier, she has a powerful "crush" on her husband, her first feelings toward a man in her life, and she is just going by the flow..she is not thinking things through. She is pursuing him how she would pursue a job , or how she chased down Gautam when he was running away from her. She will run, run, run, eventually she will come to the wall, and then accept reality with sorrow, but with her head held high.

Added to that, she has Sanvi's mystery, Rami's treachery, and her mother's and family's honour to think about. Of course she doesn't know about Rami's treachery. Sanvi's mystery is causing her to think a lot about her own role in Mukhi's life...on a permanent basis. She is not at all willing to consider that this might be a temporary relationship , so she need not care about Sanvi as long as Mukhi treats her right and sends her away with honour. NO. She wants more, she knows that.
So next question is, what does she want to be in Mukhi's life? She only knows to define this relationship by "pati-patni". Man and wife. But does she know what that would really mean? What that would really entail? Being a life partner in all good and bad, in thick and thin, to understand and know, to give and take, to always be there...to be able to sacrifice..does she know that being husband and wife entail all this? She may know some of it in her heart because she has seen her parents be the same "pati-patni"..but the journey is very individual to each person. And she is yet to give all this a deep thought. She is yet to think " Can I be a good patni to Mukhiji??".
No she is not thinking that right now, but she will have to in the future. Right now, she just wants her rights in public within both families..., Katara and Nanavati, that he is her husband and she is the wife and no one is to come in between. Thats that only thing she cares for right now, thats the only part of marriage that she has understood or wants for now. She has not gone to the depth of thinking about what being a "Patni" really entails. And this journey from crush to true love will jolt her from possessiveness to sacrifice...from demanding to giving up.And thats what I am afraid of here.


Deep inside, Aru is a woman who feels very guilty of her wrongdoings when she misbehaves or misunderstands things. We have seen many times where Aru is not at all ashamed to give her apology and accept her mistakes from the bottom of her heart. Thats a quality Mukhi came to respect about her , and learned to say "sarree" from her. The other day, after Mukhi explained that it was Sanvi's bday too and because she is a widow no one wishes her, Aru felt so so guilty of the ruckes she had raised, she actually ran away covering her face like a little child, unable to show her face to Mukhiji.
He had to go after her, and make the effort to turn her around to him and try to cheer her up all the while in perfect understanding of her guilt.
Mukhi also tells her in that scene, that "Mukhi aisa nahi hai" , as in she is not able to understand him properly. That is going to come back to bite her later.

This scene and the way the makers implemented it makes me think that once after Aru is done with all this dramebaazi of trying to keep Mukhi with her by hook or crook, and after she completely stretches herself on Saanvi matter where she might come to really wrong conclusions( thanks to Rami) ...once after she is done creating all the chaos she can, there will be a point where she will hit reality...hit it hard. The reality will be so different than what she has been thinking all along, that it will make her plummet to the bottom from the high sky she is in right now.
She will hit rock bottom...know some realities and become torn with guilt...with so so much guilt that she will not want to face Mukhi, she will not want to come in front of him. She will fall very badly in her own eyes, and unable to see the same in Mukhi's eyes she will give up on this relation. She will understand that being "Patni" is not just about wearing mangalsutra and demanding rights from husband. And she will also remember, that the one woman who told her that she knows and understands Mukhi very well is Saanvi..and will sacrifice Mukhi to Saanvi considering Saanvi to be better wife material to Mukhi. There will be that phase of downfall of Arundhati Nanavati- because in her zeal to her current "goal".- Owning Mukhiji " she will break her own rules of ethical conduct, and will lose herself completely.

And then only Mukhi will help her to rise- from the ashes of the lost Arundhari Nanavati into Arundhati Raidhan RajKattara, He will understand her guilt, her clean goals but wrong ways and the why of them, and see through her sacrifice, and he will turn her around to him, make her face him and tell her that they both have to deal with each other, and their relationship.

The journey to this point will be quite hard as I would expect in the time Aru has risen and fallen, Mukhi would just begin his own loverboy journey. He will first hurt Aru with her over zealousness for him and want to go away in order to not "tangle" things. But he will soon realize his feelings for her, want to be with her, he may also realize she is the diary woman, and would want to pursue her seriously...but by the time he comes to do so, Aru has already taken the fall against Saanvi...she would have already hit ground reality and she will no longer consider herself a good fit for Mukhi.

After Mishri's wedding, Mukhi accepts to Saanvi that Aru is right for him, but he might not be right for Aru. That will be the same statement in opposite way, I am guessing Aru will say the same thing to Saanvi, that " Mukhiji is right for me but I am not right for him". And she might request Saanvi to be with him.

Hope, Saanvi as a good friend plays cupid and lets them evolve and come together on their own.
And hope when Aru falls and doesn't know what to do with herself anymore, Mukhi is there to catch her, have her back and be a partner in her ambitions. Mukhi is a larger than life character where as Aru is playing a mature (only sometimes 😆) 22 year old with a strong sense of ethics.I really love the way both the characters are etched out and hope they help each other to come back to original self pretty soon.

And yes, the show has been serious for a few episodes would like to see some gentle lightheartedness between the two again.

The above is just my way of understanding the characters and their future, so please don't take this as a prediction. Its only my interpretation of how these two individuals might evolve.

Edited by bluejalpari17 - 8 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

8

Views

1.1k

Users

5

Likes

20

Frequent Posters

malkasub thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#2
Beautiful analysis Jalpari. Loved reading the insides of Aru's mind... such a wonderful personality, so pure and so large hearted to the extent that she herself is unaware.


She is pursuing him how she would pursue a job , or how she chased down Gautam when he was running away from her. She will run, run, run, eventually she will come to the wall, and then accept reality with sorrow, but with her head held high.

Never thought of this comparison!
She has decided to make him 'look' at her and she will go to any length to make it happen! So true.


And the other point about how she hasn't realized what it actually means to be Mukhi's wife. She hasn't given a thought as to how to be anyone's wife for that manner. She has never given marriage a thought until now. Her life was all about her dreams and ambitions. To be a partner to your husband and build your life together... all this is way off her orbit. She just suddenly realized that she likes him a lot and when Rami puts the Saanvi angle in, her only thought is that he is hers and no one else is allowed in that space... that's it. No other agenda for her there!


And also rightly said... love is very very far off at the moment!

This story has so much scope... I hope the writers will be allowed to continue at their pace!

bluejalpari17 thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: malkasub

Beautiful analysis Jalpari. Loved reading the insides of Aru's mind... such a wonderful personality, so pure and so large hearted to the extent that she herself is unaware.


She is pursuing him how she would pursue a job , or how she chased down Gautam when he was running away from her. She will run, run, run, eventually she will come to the wall, and then accept reality with sorrow, but with her head held high.

Never thought of this comparison!
She has decided to make him 'look' at her and she will go to any length to make it happen! So true.


And the other point about how she hasn't realized what it actually means to be Mukhi's wife. She hasn't given a thought as to how to be anyone's wife for that manner. She has never given marriage a thought until now. Her life was all about her dreams and ambitions. To be a partner to your husband and build your life together... all this is way off her orbit. She just suddenly realized that she likes him a lot and when Rami puts the Saanvi angle in, her only thought is that he is hers and no one else is allowed in that space... that's it. No other agenda for her there!


And also rightly said... love is very very far off at the moment!

This story has so much scope... I hope the writers will be allowed to continue at their pace!


Thanks Malkasub , you got my point exactly. She is as of now pursueing like how she goes after what she wants in life. When Mukhi had gotten her off his marriage case in earlier episodes , so that shw will not spill beans at Mishri sasural, she fought back in same way.
Aru is a fighter...to sit back, and accept what she thinks is injustice to her, is not in her spirit.

And she has already begun her downfall journey today looks like. She will keep making such mistakes, till one day feels too unworthy of Mukhi.
Meanwhile Mukhi has started his loverboy journey too..
Its possibly going to the same evolution I was talking about
..wateva.. thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#4
Beautiful Analysis!!
I concur to all the points that you have mentioned.. She is still in the phase of He is not giving me the attention..but like today she hasn't actually thought through the feelings she has for him or being a wife.

I hope the blurt out from last three episodes will make her think and bring some clarity in respect to her as being wife or a lover and the odds that may come.

-Isabel
Tshaheen thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#5
Excellent,excellent reviews my dear as always thanks really enjoyed reading it !!
bluejalpari17 thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#6
Tashneen and Isabel...yes you girls are right ..
In that Aru is acting out of reflex and not thinking the why and how of things.
She might even be in love with the "hero" image she sometimes sees in Mukhi , and not with the real Mukhi himself.
I keep saying she is still way far from true love..lets see
violette thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#7
@Blue:

Again I seriously fear writing on your post coz i see I differ on the very first point itself.

I dont agree with the idea tht True love means "bonding at a higher level." In fact these very primal emotions (jealousy, fear, guilt, anger..) makes us humans and connects us with other beings.. If we cannot connect at this level, we cannot move to the higher level of understanding a partner. Also We cannot jst "sift out" these emotions, thy r part and parcel of life, of relationships and adds a distinct flavor to a it. thy r essentially "stepping stones" to a grt bonding and cannot b jst sifted out. So being the chosen one from the universe and bonding of souls in heaven really make up for a very unrealistic idealistic romance, thy r far far away from reality of life and cannot b chosen as parameters to define true love. Bt i understand what u r trying to say here. tht thr needs to b a connect betn the two to develop tht higher level of understanding. Bt without these feelings one cannot develop tht connect. And having these flaws really doesnt make one's love any lesser. In fact, i believe tht understanding and accepting the partner with all these flaws and yet "keep loving" inspite of them "all the life" is what true love really comprises of. And tht is precisely what Mukhi is gonna do. Mukhi wudnt b able to love her the way he does, if she didnt display all these emotions. But tht really doesnt lessen the intensity of Aru's love. It's different, and both have really different views abt love.

In fact i find Aru's love very pure, coz she has nothing to hide.. like a child's love, its pure simple and its in very rustic primal form.. wer as Mukhi's love is evolved.. bcoz of his age and experience.. he knows whats the right thing to do in love.. at least till now.. bcoz right now thrs no threat or competition to his feelings.. we will see how he reacts when this phase comes.. bt we cannot guess it right now.. coz this side of Mukhi we havent seen yet.. we havent seen what he does when he is losing out, when he is helpless, when his world is shattering around him, and he wants to act selfish.. bt wud he? or wud he not? We cannot jst say tht yet.

But this side, we saw of Aru.. first coz obviously, she is young and hasty.. bt gusty, full of vitality vigor and valor, tht helps her spring back from worst of situations... thts what she has penned down in tht diary...

Bt i understand what u r trying to say here tht Aru has not yet had tht understanding.. bt not of her love being true, bt of the her own capabilities.. in chasing down her dreams and in intensely loving a person...

Bt her love is not frivolous and its definitely not jst a "crush." It stemmed out of crush, bt its base was always strong, built on solid foundations of attachments, respect, and reverence for a man close to reality.

And yet again i beg to differ in this point as well.. tht "she will accept reality with sorrow.." she will definitely accept the situation with dignity bt thr wudnt b sorrow.. she wud definitely be in a happy place knowing tht she loved a man who really is worthy of loving so much.

what i love abt Aru is.. she accepts defeats with grace, dignity and 'optimism.' Her faith never fails. (we saw tht in Gautam's case and again when losing her job and also when her sister ran away with crores of jwellery).

so no she is not the run-of-the-mill heroines.. who is going to cry buckets at the loss and do nothing abt the situations in her life. Aru is a fighter and she will easily find happiness around her. She will not let the unhappiness or the pain wither her heart. This is one quality tht Mukhi is gonna immensely love about her. He already appreciatess tht in tht diary wali girl bt he doesnt yet know tht Aru is the same girl.

Bt yes u r right tht she is not yet in tht phase to think deeply abt her current relationship and her role in Mukhi's life. Bt its a transition phase and we will see tht soon enuf. Her mind is a one way track. tho she is a multi tasker, her mind cannot think in different directions at once. Mukhi complements her in this quality and she needs to learn it from him.

And there is no "temporary" thing abt her relationships.. and not jst with Mukhi. we saw tht with Gautam, Mishri.. even Raami. and the next person in her list is gonna b Saanvi. Hence she cannot fathom tht her attachment to Mukhi can b temporary. Bt she is give-all take-all kinda person which is coming in her way while dealing with current situation.. coz she has not given a name to her relation and to demand everything from a person at this stage is quite incomprehensible for Mukhi, who sees the situation more practically.

Also i think it too early to guess abt how she views her role as a "wife" let alone to being Mukhiji's wife, bt foundations abt a strong relation r pretty clear in her mind already, which r basis of any good relationship, not jst pati-patni's. I guess its gonna b more of a practical issue rthr thn issue of fundamentals. She faltered here, bt she is learning. Next time she will trust her instincts and put faith on her understanding of relationships and act accordingly.

"Right now, she just wants her rights in public within both families" Again, i dont think you have understood the depth of Aru's love. Her attention seeking behavior is not superficial. All she wants is Mukhi's love. And no she doesnt seek his undivided attention, jst some recognition. She knows tht love is all about sharing.

And oh! we are so underestimating this girl as a wife. So is Mukhi. And you are so seeing Aru as Mukhi is seeing her right now. And u and Mukhi r both in for a pleasant shock!

And no it wudnt b sacrifice.. when she understands her own love, it wud b a devotion. She wud give away in devotion and not out of sacrifice. Sacrifice and devotion has a very thin difference betn thm while sacrifice can b negative, pessimistic, and very superficial, devotion is always positive, faith-bound, and a very deep running emotion.

And yes she realizes tht by blaming Mukhi she is also indirectly questioning his infallible character.. bt if she really did tht, wud Mukhi b able to love her as he does now? He understands its out of her innocence, naivity and immaturity tht she acts this way. Her heart is very clean and if she loses her innocence and naivity Mukhi will not b able to love her as he does now.

Also i think Mukhi wud never let her plummet to the bottom. As far as i have understood Mukhi's character.. he is one who will stand underneath her, support her and wud never let her crash down. And for tht, if she demands, he can also give in to her love. As i said earlier in one of the posts, if Mukhi is to act selfish, he wud act selfish, break all barriers of societal norms and personal inhibitions, only and only for Aru. And we know Aru is very demanding when it comes to her rights and feelings. 😆

And no he wud not make Arundhati Raidhan Raj Katara out of Arundhati Nanavati.. she wud remain Arundhati Nanavati bt Arundhati Raidhan Raj Katara wud emerge from her out of her love for Mukhi. I think Mukhi will b silent bt strong support in Aru's life bt will never b the "driver" of her life. And thts the beauty of his character. He is not someone who will b always thr to catch her bt will b one who wud tell her how not to fall or how to gather one self back if one does..

Okay i will stop here.. bcoz i think we r going too deep into guess mode here. We r discussing things which may or may not happen in the future. Lets c how the things shape up and thn we can have a better guess at how these characters wud act in certain situation. At this point i think its too early to discuss abt this.

And again i know its unfound and unrealistic.. bt i have developed a phobia abt ur posts. bcoz i differ so much, almost each and every point, tht i m really afraid to put my point across. 😆 I know its stupid bt i jst cant help it. My thinking is diametrically opposite to urs and even when i look back at this post, i see so much discord and i m unable to find a convergence point and tht really frustrates me. Plus I fear sounding too rude, which i really dont want to. And thts reason i have been avoiding reading ur posts off late.. 😆 please pardon me for tht. I will surely try and come up with a better way to address my phobia and ur posts.

Nevertheless, Luv u.
Edited by violette - 8 years ago
bluejalpari17 thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#8
@ Violette.
Forum is meant for just that, multiple opinions and pointz of view. You have yours, I have mine, and this is for a story and characters neither of us have written.
So , if you wish to read my posts always take it with a pinch of salt , that its entirely my interpretation. Thats what I said at the bottom of this post as well. Thats why when I read other writers threads, I dong go for point wise agreement or disagreement. Coz thats their opinion. I look for points where I might agree, or value or add ...and jot that for them thats it. When I disagree I dont't care enough to write about it.
So no phobias for me, I rather think more about the characters .
And even if I did have a forum member whose opinions I dobt concurr with most of the time, I dont think its worth my time to mention that..I can always skip thier posts, or read and ignore.

How ever since you have written on my thread of your phobia, I would say , don't feel pressured on any basis to read my threads. I keep saying, they are my interpretation. Absolutely feel free to avoid my threads if it helps.😊

Love you back too.
.
violette thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: bluejalpari17

@ Violette.

Forum is meant for just that, multiple opinions and pointz of view. You have yours, I have mine, and this is for a story and characters neither of us have written.
So , if you wish to read my posts always take it with a pinch of salt , that its entirely my interpretation. Thats what I said at the bottom of this post as well. Thats why when I read other writers threads, I dong go for point wise agreement or disagreement. Coz thats their opinion. I look for points where I might agree, or value or add ...and jot that for them thats it. When I disagree I dont't care enough to write about it.
So no phobias for me, I rather think more about the characters .
And even if I did have a forum member whose opinions I dobt concurr with most of the time, I dont think its worth my time to mention that..I can always skip thier posts, or read and ignore.

How ever since you have written on my thread of your phobia, I would say , don't feel pressured on any basis to read my threads. I keep saying, they are my interpretation. Absolutely feel free to avoid my threads if it helps.😊

Love you back too.
.



Thnk u soo much. Glad tht we have such mature members around the forum.

Regarding my phobia, I jst cant get my head around this problem.

And its certainly not ur doing.

and thnks for showing maturity and tolerance to my immature and ridiculous behaviour..😆

Also on I lighter note,

"Absolutely feel free to avoid my threads if it helps."

U have written this and I have seen ppl being answered.. "don't write on my thread if u don't concur with me" jumping on each other's throats and threatening to call on moderators.. 😆
Edited by violette - 8 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".