cxttoncandy thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#1
I think I am not too late in posting my thoughts on IPKKND3. I was trying to stop myself from posting anything but now I am eager to know if anyone agrees with me. So honestly I am very excited for IPKKND3 and it looks great but i am trying to keep my expectations low because I dont think it will match up IPKKND1. I dont have a problem with Shivani in fact I very much ship Adhvay and Chandni but I know that the kind of role she is playing is very different from khushi's which was one of the biggest things that made IPKKND1 what it is now!
I am going to give the first episode a try and see if I like it but again I dont think it will be the same because the story seems like just a intense love story not a comedic intense love story which is one of the elements that IPKKND needsss!!!! to be a hit!
Please tell me if anyone agrees with this!

Apart from that I hate the fact that Gul is producing it under the name of IPKKND which I am pretty sure is just so it gets a boost when going on air. I think I would have had way less expectations if she hadnt named it IPKKND but I would have still gave the 1st episode a shot because of Barun.

Another thing is that honestly I LOVE the new rabba ve the remix is amazing!! but I hate her for using it on another character I mean I didnt expect Gul to use Rabba ve which is only for arnav and khushi for a different jodi!

I also think if they got teh same screenplay writer which was Gautam Hedge from IPKKND1 he could make their love story even more better.

Hopefully Gul doesnt disappoint me again after Ishqbaaz and DBO!!
Please share your opinions I would love to listen and I m not bashing anyone :)

Created

Last reply

Replies

48

Views

8.6k

Users

19

Likes

205

Frequent Posters

.JokerHarley. thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#2
Nope. I don't agree with you about something here. For me the character that actually brought intrigue to IPKKND was ASR and the layers of his character. His transition throughout the show was what kept me glued. I didn't find Khushi relatable or real. In fact she was a major turn off factor at the end with her over the top reactions. Sure ASR and Khushi made a good looking couple but I personally did not like Khushi individually.
Back to IPKKND 3, Chandni however seems quite different from the usual heroines till now. Her reaction to Advay's "beautiful" in the Dussehra promo was impressive for me at least. There's this depth and maturity with these two that makes it far more appealing for me.

I don't want to denigrate the current screenplay writer by comparing her with GH. Let's see what she has to offer instead of wondering how the show would have been if GH had been writing it? I'm sure she has her own unique set of good ideas.
cxttoncandy thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: .JokerHarley.

Nope. I don't agree with you about something here. For me the character that actually brought intrigue to IPKKND was ASR and the layers of his character. His transition throughout the show was what kept me glued. I didn't find Khushi relatable or real. In fact she was a major turn off factor at the end with her over the top reactions. Sure ASR and Khushi made a good looking couple but I personally did not like Khushi individually.

Back to IPKKND 3, Chandni however seems quite different from the usual heroines till now. Her reaction to Advay's "beautiful" in the Dussehra promo was impressive for me at least. There's this depth and maturity with these two that makes it far more appealing for me.

I don't want to denigrate the current screenplay writer by comparing her with GH. Let's see what she has to offer instead of wondering how the show would have been if GH had been writing it? I'm sure she has her own unique set of good ideas.


I totally understand your point of view and thank you so much for sharing it 😊
I agree it wasnt just khushi but also ASR which made IPKKND superbbb! I love them both equally and yes you are right she became less and less relatable as the serial went which is why I love the start of the serial more than the last but what I meant to say was that the comedic relief she brought to the show was so fresh and new to indian television and I think apart from their chemistry that is one of the things that made IPKKND what it is now.

Chandni does seem mature and I am sure she will have many layers to her character as well but I personally dont know if I will like her character or not because to me she seems very innocent and common but at the same those characteristics can benefit the intense love story a lot so I think I should base my opinion on her after watching the first few episodes.

Also about the writer Ididnt mena to say he should replace Gul because Gul is the Director and the screenplay writer is a different member in the team who worked along with Gul on IPKKND1:)
Thanks for your opinion again😊
hina11 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
#4
Their will be comic relief here as well and I guess ved raj was main writer of ipk yes gautam was also there but main one was ved.
neeli123 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: cxttoncandy

I think I am not too late in posting my thoughts on IPKKND3. I was trying to stop myself from posting anything but now I am eager to know if anyone agrees with me. So honestly I am very excited for IPKKND3 and it looks great but i am trying to keep my expectations low because I dont think it will match up IPKKND1. I dont have a problem with Shivani in fact I very much ship Adhvay and Chandni but I know that the kind of role she is playing is very different from khushi's which was one of the biggest things that made IPKKND1 what it is now!

I am going to give the first episode a try and see if I like it but again I dont think it will be the same because the story seems like just a intense love story not a comedic intense love story which is one of the elements that IPKKND needsss!!!! to be a hit!
Please tell me if anyone agrees with this!

Apart from that I hate the fact that Gul is producing it under the name of IPKKND which I am pretty sure is just so it gets a boost when going on air. I think I would have had way less expectations if she hadnt named it IPKKND but I would have still gave the 1st episode a shot because of Barun.

Another thing is that honestly I LOVE the new rabba ve the remix is amazing!! but I hate her for using it on another character I mean I didnt expect Gul to use Rabba ve which is only for arnav and khushi for a different jodi!

I also think if they got teh same screenplay writer which was Gautam Hedge from IPKKND1 he could make their love story even more better.

Hopefully Gul doesnt disappoint me again after Ishqbaaz and DBO!!
Please share your opinions I would love to listen and I m not bashing anyone :)



Well my point of view is if the love story is good and decent and if the show runs on the leads as intial IPPKND was, it would be good... I am expecting comedy elements... i want it to be serial in macth with the season 1, story change is accepted but, i dont want gul to turn it in to saas bahu drama's as she is doing with her current IB show.

@bold i agree a lot with that... The only disappointment and worry for me in big way is Harneet is the story writer, she is very hap hazard, starts story well but she gets lost very soon, leaves tracks haphazard, she is not a good writer, i wish very much Gul got the old writers back...

and next worry for me the costume designer...she is a disaster...I meant about Shivani ...to get an idea you can watch any function episodes of IB or DBo you would not( she makes costumes of Jungle theme, for curtains and what not)

I wish Gul does good job as she did for season one, rather than turning this show as her disasters QH or else IB( i meant the current track)


cxttoncandy thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: matosarah


I absolutely agree with you. I am in the same boat here, where at one end I am eager to watch Barun and Shivani in this intense Drama, this other end is making me feel restless also, as if those lovely moments of IPKKND1 would be marred or shadowed by this IPKKND 3.

For me IPKKND is and would always be synonymous with Arnav and Khushi's saga and I do wish this new one was named something else. And no I don't want Barun and Sanaya to cast together again since it would be a very tall order for them to recreate that chemistry once again. I have seen it before with this other couple who was repeated repeatedly because of their on screen chemistry from their first show, but to me they could never recreate that magic again and this couple is married in real life yet they couldn't create the same effect, so to expect from Sanaya and Barun to create the same magic won't be fair.

My biggest disappointment with TV shows these days is that such promising storylines also get spoiled and go off track so abruptly.I don't know why, since there is an abundance of creative talent in the country, yet these TV shows can't maintain a consistency in the storyline and soon go heywire. I recently started watching Ishqbaaz and just when I was getting into it, they have lost it completely with new angle. As of yesterday, they lost me as a viewer.

This new IPKKND, although I wished was named something else, but hey as people on this forum keep on harping that, it is their franchise , so who am I to complain😆, so yes the intended storyline of this new IPKKND is pretty intense which needs maturity to bring forth this idea on the screen, but dunno why, I highly doubt Gul/bull/ shul of this world would be able to do justice to it. But it is not her fault either, it is viewers these days who always demand nonsense like MIL, SIL sati savtri bahu types drama and if you try something new those shows are shut down pretty quickly due to low TRP. Hence, Guls of the world ends up giving bull crap to the viewers. Good romantic dramas are difficult to sustain on television without idiotic family melodrama.

Visually cinematographically this one is looking far superior to other shows but their costumes would be just too painful to watch day in and day out. Gosh those are one ugly clothes they have given to the cast.
Shivani is a very pretty girl, I had seen her in few episodes of Kasam and was going to follow it at the time, but when they chucked her out, I stopped watching that serial. Well Advey and Chandini are looking amazing even in those atrocious costumes. Wish I could design their clothes. Ah!

So yes, I am feeling sad to see how people divided on IPKKND forum and wrote rude stuff to demean the actors who had done nothing but entertained us through their craft.

For me, the meanest thing that, I did was I made Gul a Raizada and Arnav and Adhvey Singh Raizada's mother in my Sims4 game. At least somewhere I have an ultimate power where I get to play God with their characters...That is MY script and nobody spoils it.😆😉

Looking forward to embrace this new saga now. Have a blessed day guys! 🤗


AHAHHAAHA OMG THE SIMS PART KILLED ME👏😆😆 I m so happyyy you commented because our views are so alike! It is like we are stuck and confused between IPKKND which I am pretty sure could have been solved if they had different names but we both will still give the new one a try and think of it as a different show all together.

Yesss!! The cinematography looksss great!! and i know right people are not ready to try some other shows other than the same saas bahu crap. and omgg YESS THE OUTFITS ARE A PAIN TO WATCHH! for me Advay still looks good but Shivani's outfit is sooo extraaa even though she is so pretty like if they did a simple sari or suit it wouldnt be a pain to watch!

As far as the actors, I love all the actors even Shivani! She is so beautiful and I didnt have a problem with her from the start but IPKKND with a different story and different actors is injustice (in my opinion)

cxttoncandy thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: hina11

Their will be comic relief here as well and I guess ved raj was main writer of ipk yes gautam was also there but main one was ved.


I am happy that ved is there and yes hopefully there will be a lot of comedic relief😊
cxttoncandy thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: neeli123



Well my point of view is if the love story is good and decent and if the show runs on the leads as intial IPPKND was, it would be good... I am expecting comedy elements... i want it to be serial in macth with the season 1, story change is accepted but, i dont want gul to turn it in to saas bahu drama's as she is doing with her current IB show.

@bold i agree a lot with that... The only disappointment and worry for me in big way is Harneet is the story writer, she is very hap hazard, starts story well but she gets lost very soon, leaves tracks haphazard, she is not a good writer, i wish very much Gul got the old writers back...

and next worry for me the costume designer...she is a disaster...I meant about Shivani ...to get an idea you can watch any function episodes of IB or DBo you would not( she makes costumes of Jungle theme, for curtains and what not)

I wish Gul does good job as she did for season one, rather than turning this show as her disasters QH or else IB( i meant the current track)



Yes, I think the main reason why they named it IPKKND is because it is a love story and "nafrat door jaane na de, mohabbat paas aane na de" so based on that I m expecting a good romance from Gul! same with comedic relief and comedic characters but lets see what she does...

Exactly my point! I dont want it to become one of those saas bahu sagas like she did with QH, DBO, IB. and yes thats what U meant by the screenwriter because even I have heard that Harneet gets off track and destroys the story so I wanted Gautam to be back😕

YESS THE COSTUMES ARE A PAIN TO WATH. SHIVANI IS SO BEAUTIFUK BUT HER OUTFIT IS VERY EXTRA!!!! AHH we all hope Gul doesnt destroy the storyline of this one and hopefully it is a finite series!
CDlove thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 8 years ago
#9
I haven't posted in this forum yet but couldn't help but post when I saw your topic. IPK was one of my all time favorite shows for many reasons. The first few months of the show was sheer brilliance, be it the back ground scores, cinematography, screen play or direction. But the most illuminating factor was the leads and their stark difference in personalities.

ASR and his rough and tough exterior was a sharp contrast to Khushi's bubbly fun persona. I feel this was the main USP of the show. I loved both characters, cried with both of them and personally resonated with Khushi's layers of the personality because I'm kind of a goofball myself with that underlying emotional depth we saw in her character. Arnav and Khushi are so very different with equally strong personalities and are both forces to reckon with. I have also criticized both characters, especially when Arnav lash out for no particular reason and when Khushi went into comical clown modes. But at the end I still loved them so very much and their differences are the main reason the show was such a hit for me.

The new IPK, as splendidly shot as it is, seems a little bland from the female lead's perspective. She seems like the run of the mill, sanskari, timid girls star plus is used to. Now, I'm saying this, judging by the little titbits I have seen in promotions so far and I am absolutely going to give the show a chance. I really hope they can weave an equally compelling story as they did in the IPK 1. But, the USP of the first season ain't gonna work for this if they are going to have Chandni as a timid bechari sweetheart.
Don't get me wrong, I have problems with the new ASR's character too but I will voice them out as the story progresses and if they really are going to go with the route I fear they will take.

Also using IPKKND and Rabba ve is probably just a marketing gimmick to get the old audience back and nothing else honestly. The fact that they used these for the new show doesn't really bother me. I am personally very attached to the first season so as long as they don't hamper with my memory of the first season, I'm good 😆

Edited by CDlove - 8 years ago
CDlove thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 8 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: matosarah


So true, my sentiments exactly. I said it elsewhere, I am not feeling Chandini's character. I am bit afraid to voice my opinion on this forum, because a few strong ones would go on their bashing rant and would call my opinion as spreading negativity, which would never be my intention. Although in some interview they said Chandini would be a strong character, but that's not a vibe I am getting from this character yet.
Buy hey my DVR is all set, I would be watching this new one with equal enthusiasm. Finger's crossed.😉


Oh I definitely know what you mean but this is a free forum and we are here to voice our opinion. The previous IPK forum was so much more fun because there was a multitude of opinions on the characters. I'm pretty certain this forum is going to have a lot of different view points as well and pretty strong ones at that. Anyway I'm not really going to care about what others are going to say at any rate 😆

Chandni seems bland and a little too 'goodie two shoes' but then we haven't seen her side of the story at all yet so I'm going to let the story tellers establish her character a bit. Let see. 😆
Edited by CDlove - 8 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".