My thoughts on IPKKND3 - Page 5

Created

Last reply

Replies

48

Views

8.6k

Users

19

Likes

205

Frequent Posters

mira thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#41

Originally posted by: CDlove


While I agree with you that I cannot possibly state how her character will etch in the story, I don't think there is any harm in assuming how a character will develop since this is after all a fictional show. I came up to a vague, tentative conclusion from whatever I have read so far that she seems like a typical run of the mill, meek starplus heroine. That's all 😆

Now I was not aware of Chandni to be an acid attack victim until now and even so I don't believe an acid attack victim necessarily needs to mop and be depressed. Is she actually going to suffering from anxiety disorder? Was that said anywhere? There is nothing on the books that state that such a person will be stuck in melancholy and sadness. And I don't think it's right that the rest of the society is going to assume or judge that such a person should be depressed and anxious her whole life. Sympathize with them, help them but not pity them.

Different people react differently to situations based on their personalities and life experiences. I am in no way saying a person has to behave in a certain way and I don't think it's right for anyone to assume that Chandni is to be depressed and suffer from a mental breakdown.



Ok so we are talking about Chandini right? Let me bring you up to speed... Gul said this is story of an acid attack victim and her struggles... And we had articles informing us that Chandini gets anxiety attacks...and Shivani herself said that the girl had been through a lot in life. So we assumed her to be a less cheerful girl which might not be the case at all

Your question is valid. Its not in books that such ppl gets into depression ... completely agreed. But doesnt such ppl have tendency to be scared of world around? Why do we expect each and every heroine to be super humans who somehow learns to smile in spite of tragedy? shouldnt we also see a character who is struggling to come in terms with past? No one said Chandini is meek ... just sad and soft spoken. There is a difference. Ppl can be loud and smart but they can lack inner strength. Doesn't make one boring and other interesting.

Also there is a difference in what ppl see based on their own maturity and age. What you find meek and typical at this age might appeal to someone who has seen life differently. At some age you find bubbly characters fun... partying fun...bollywood fun ... and then at some other time a nice book and a coffee on a rainy day is fun. So when you find Chandini bland now, I might find her silly if she dance around and keep smiling all the time. So yah its all perspective too.
Edited by mira - 8 years ago
2filmy thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail Commentator Level 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#42



She looks exquisite like a diva
The black and white suits her so well
Fairy_KimBokJoo thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#43

Originally posted by: advay_chandnii

It is fine when fans of previous seasons talk with constructive criticism but how is "Chandni is bland because she is not like Khushi" anything good? And forum rules are that previous lead and previous show is not to be compared.


Also seeing the amount of bashing that has happened of this season, I have lost tolerance as I've seen even you bashing this show on the bollywood forum. It just does not come across as something genuine IMO but another "Khushi rocks, IPK season one rocks, boycott everything else"


We were happy to leave the IPK forum because we thought we finally got a place where we can discuss Chandni, Advay and IPK3 in peace but all this came here too and I am sure if mods came they would close down any stuff about the previous season.




Look, the people with agendas on this post are quite obvious stans of the ex chick and would say whatever nonsense to justify their agendas. We all know comparison is against the rules, so just report these concern trolls and keep it moving. We have better things to do than worry about people who have nothing else to do but fulfil their agendas. Just report and keep it moving, imho. The distinction between constructive criticism and obvious agenda is pretty visible so just ignore them. They will multiply once the show starts, the best thing is to not engage with the concern trolls.
Edited by Fairy_KimBokJoo - 8 years ago
cxttoncandy thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#44

Originally posted by: neeli123

what is KKGSR serisl?


The serial was called Iss pyaar ko kya naam doon 1
cxttoncandy thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#45

Originally posted by: Papayapie

cxttoncandy, don't feel like you're alone! While I'm actually looking forward to a calmer and more serious FL, I also loooved Khushi (even though she could be annoying sometimes, lol). So, I understand why you'd feel apprehensive about the difference!


Ahhh, I am so glad to hear that someone agrees with me ❤️
cxttoncandy thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#46

Originally posted by: advay_chandnii

It is fine when fans of previous seasons talk with constructive criticism but how is "Chandni is bland because she is not like Khushi" anything good? And forum rules are that previous lead and previous show is not to be compared.


Also seeing the amount of bashing that has happened of this season, I have lost tolerance as I've seen even you bashing this show on the bollywood forum. It just does not come across as something genuine IMO but another "Khushi rocks, IPK season one rocks, boycott everything else"


We were happy to leave the IPK forum because we thought we finally got a place where we can discuss Chandni, Advay and IPK3 in peace but all this came here too and I am sure if mods came they would close down any stuff about the previous season.


We are not boycotting Ipk3 and we dont have a problem with it. Of coarse we r going to give it a chance but we have the right to express our opinions on ipkknd! not ipkknd 1 or 3 just ipkknd whether it is khushi or chandni. I get that you people dont want to bring in khushi but we are just expression our opinion so if you dont agree with it why not be polite with your opion or just not reply because there is no other place where we can talk about ipkknd (not ipk1 or ipk3) and yes, we have the right to talk about it but if you guys get irritated that we r talking about khushi then where do we even go to express our opinions?
cxttoncandy thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#47

Originally posted by: Fairy_KimBokJoo




Look, the people with agendas on this post are quite obvious stans of the ex chick and would say whatever nonsense to justify their agendas. We all know comparison is against the rules, so just report these concern trolls and keep it moving. We have better things to do than worry about people who have nothing else to do but fulfil their agendas. Just report and keep it moving, imho. The distinction between constructive criticism and obvious agenda is pretty visible so just ignore them. They will multiply once the show starts, the best thing is to not engage with the concern trolls.


I dont get what agenda you are talking about but what I know is that your comment is so rude! Just tell me, would anyone compare ipk3 with ipk1 if it didnt have the same name? Atleast I wouldnt. I m only expressing my opinion on the show/ comparing because I m attached to ipk1. Honestly if you guys cant get that fact clear and just blame us for comparing, its better you actually go report instead of stay here and badmouth someones "Opinion"
stg1 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 3 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#48
i totally get some peoples doubts and reservations and that's their perspective, i guess i'm one of the excited fans of the original season who cant wait to see what happens in this intriguing version 😃

last time around i really didn't spend so much time analysing everything i saw and enjoyed, wondering who wrote, who directed, who styled, everything just clicked perfectly. and i'm expecting and hoping for the same this time too, for the general audience and for myself ⭐️

but personally i'm happy with the casting, happy with the character sketches that have been revealed so far, happy with the writer, definitely happy with Gorky directing, happy with the set, happy with the rabba ve remix, and extremely extremely happy and excited to get Barun back on my screen again

if i miss it i have the original version to watch on hotstar and for something equally entertaining i'll now have this new version - a darker tale, a dark almost-evil hero, mystery laden, intriguing love story, more intense and painful scenario's that might have moments of light relief mixed in with utter despair and angst, and did i mention Barun - cant wait! ❤️

stg1 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 3 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#49

Originally posted by: 2filmy




She looks exquisite like a diva
The black and white suits her so well



ohhh what a beautiful pic, this looks like a still from an old black and white movie ❤️ i love the melancholy in her eyes and the stillness of her face, i want to know her story...

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".