MOST CONTROVERSIAL DECISIONS

First Previous

Page

Poll

Most controversial decisions in challenge 2005

Frequent Posters

Alok

@music99

Inactive

Posted: 20 years ago

#11

Rajeev's green card over Debojit and Abhijeet was totally biased and wrong. Judge Sanu justifies that Rajeev tum dilse gaya. What the heck? First you got to have sur right before dil comes into play. Kumar Sanu himself being an untrained singer who got lucky murdered music with that decision. Sanu does not deserve to be a judge at this level. Such a decision at round 3 is totally unacceptable. While Abhijeet and Debojit sang very well, Rajeev along with his idol Sanu can take music lessons from Abhijeet. Even Jagjit Singh and Alka Yagnik admired Abhijeet's singing. Abhijeet's exit is a loss to music lovers.

Quote

Heera

@Heera

Beginner

Posted: 20 years ago

#12

Originally posted by: music99
Rajeev's green card over Debojit and Abhijeet was totally biased and wrong. Judge Sanu justifies that Rajeev tum dilse gaya. What the heck? First you got to have sur right before dil comes into play. Kumar Sanu himself being an untrained singer who got lucky murdered music with that decision. Sanu does not deserve to be a judge at this level. Such a decision at round 3 is totally unacceptable. While Abhijeet and Debojit sang very well, Rajeev along with his idol Sanu can take music lessons from Abhijeet. Even Jagjit Singh and Alka Yagnik admired Abhijeet's singing. Abhijeet's exit is a loss to music lovers.

Totally agree with you. I felt that Kumar Sanu was bragging about himself that he sings from the heart and that's the most important thing, more than sur. I also dont understand how the judges keep on changing their opinions every episode.. sometimes the students are asked to copy the original singer ( like Kumar Sanu told Debojit) and sometimes they are asked to maintain originality. The poor students must be confused by now.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

VeeBee

@VeeBee

Inactive

Posted: 20 years ago

#13

I agree with pmahesh in that the decision between VIshwas and Irfan was rather controversial. I just didnt agree with it...and it is rather sad that capable singers will not be voted back in because of the structure of the voting system. indeed, i would not like to see Aishwarya back; which is likely to happen since his Gharana has got many votes. BTW, do you guys know when we will find out who are the SMS call-backs?

Quote

Hmm You really dont wanna k

@FuntushTv

Inactive

Posted: 20 years ago

#14

As I mentioned in my post on other threads, the singers with real abilities are getting breaks as per their genre. Abhijeet is working with Louis Bank for Bollywood movies and album projects. This competition has given him what he needed, the exposure. Others are one hit wonders. I really miss Hrishikesh winner from earlier episodes.