Who was a bigger superstar at her prime: Madhuri or Katrina?

Madhuri is said to be one of the first female superstars. Katrina was said to have great box office success too. But who was the bigger female superstar at their peak - Madhuri Dixit or Katrina Kaif?

Madhuri. Katrina could never have made a film like Raja a massive hit. I think it was a blockbuster.

Madhuri became a part of the culture.. Everyone use to sing "Dhak Dhak" and "Ek do teen." I dont think Katrina had that effect. Madhuri was def more applauded for her acting abilities too. Let me be clear. I never thought much of Mahuri as an actress. She is def better than Kat. But I would still rank her as an average actress and not great one. Sridevi was a great actress in my book. But she was a bigger star in her prime than Kat. But her stardom faded away and she wasnt able to maintain it. She does reality tv now. Meanwhile Aish, and Kajol still do films?😕Interesting scenario !

^^You are right about Madhuri becoming a part of popular culture.

Madhuri was a generation ahead of Aish and Kajol in the industry..her contemporaries were the likes of meenakshi sheshadri, Shilpa Shirodkar, Kimi Katkar etc. Where r they now?

Inorder to be called a complete superstar u also need to command respect for ur acting abilities.Madhuri was highly ranked by her costars,critics,directors and actors who came after her.Her fame is timeless.Won numerous awards and has essayed characters which would live in ppl memory forever

Kat was never honored for her acting abilities.She might have got comments like achchi maal hai but never the achchi actress after ppl come out of theater😆.She had a hit streak for 2-3 years but her fame will be short lived.In future too,she would be known for her dance rather than legendary roles/movies

ofcourse madhuri.madhuri was the only felmale superstar in the bollywood.madhuri is the great actress.dont think sridevi is better than her.sridevi is overrated.madhuri was great in acting even in tezaab.

Madhuri has more HGOTY and also has the biggest hit of all time, so obviously her.

Madhuri... She could carry a movie on her shoulders.. Don't think Kat ever did that