Diff story but still less trp???

First Previous

Page

Poll

Differ from other but why less trp

Frequent Posters

luxmi_1029

@luxmi_1029

Navigator

Posted: 8 years ago

#31

Originally posted by: shruthiravi
Luxumi thanks for reminding Karuthama. I also like another Tamil movie Samsaram oru Minsaram. Lakshmi steals the show with her final decision.
See my point is one thing. From the discussions I have seen in the forum, I see very less mature discussions where characters, their motivations are discussed impartially. Most of the discussions are about the pairs, who will marry whom, who will stay with whom. It is about jodis and not about story.
Also the concept of strong. Maybe I have seen so many good Malayalam and Tamil movies and also the DD shows of mid to late 90s, my definition of strong differs vastly from what people define as strong.

I wont say Beyhadh is great or a master piece or something. But it is not bad. First thing the viewers have to know about the show is it is a 260 epi finite series so that means till 130 epi it is first half of the show. There will be many things which will be open at this point, we may not understand at this point.
A show like beyhadh can be criticized only after it crosses 130 and post that if it is not tying the loose ends yes it has a problem.
Before that if you shout why it is like this, why it is like that some things we have to accept it is like that for a reason.

And if time permits do watch the show Ek tha Chander Ek thi Sudha. it is 21 epi and available in hotstar. It's a beauty.

Bold: I agree. I think that is a general pblm with hindi serials. Pairings are what carries a show. Content is rarely cared for. I admit I have jumped on the bandwagon too, at times. Some shows that promote pairings do it because they are the content of the show. For example Zee TV's Yeh Vaada Raha (season 1), Star Plus' yeh hai mohabbatein and Sony TV's kuch rang pyar ke aise bhi (season 1- I stopped watching it from the leap, so can't say much about it). I can't say much about Colours' serials, i don't think I've ever watched a single show from that channel 😆

Afsar Bitiya and Sanyukt (earlier episodes) from Zee TV was one of those rare serials I have watched that I enjoyed for its content and not for its pairings 👏

I've watched some thriller dailies in other languages too. One show was called Then Nilavu (translated as honeymoon in english) I loved it. It had a balance of everything, and was carried out well throughout, although there was something about the ending that did not sit well with me (something changed behind-the-scenes and it had an effect on the ending 🤢) Another serial with a healthy dosage of thrill factor and everything else in a Tamil serial that lasted no more than 30 episodes was called Ethir Veetu Paiyan (the boy next door). Both aired on Sun TV. Tamil, Malayalam and Telugu serials have also recently taken a turn for the worse- they seem to be trying to copy methods in Hindi serials that I don't like. I especially love watching K. Balachandran's serials. They are short but way too good. I would love for a forum to be opened to discuss some of these amazing old serials. 😆

With regards to Beyhadh, I do believe Jennifer's popularity is the reason for how well it is doing in comparison to Sony's other shows. Hindi serials are rarely recognized for its content and only for the way it is packaged and marketed. I have never seen in any other Indian languages the importance given to production companies, onscreen pairings and offscreen gossip as done in the Hindi television industry. All of this ends up playing a significant role in the marketing of the end products and how they fare from their journey to being put on-air until it's end 😆

I stopped watching Beyhadh for many reasons, one being that I did not like the involvement mental illness has been having in the thrill factor. I did enjoy the Saanjh and Maya were given the opportunity to show some real emotions early on but other than that I have lost interest.

I come by to the forum for updates, and to read comments such as yours that concentrate on the content 👏

This will be my last post in this topic. I feel like I am getting carried away and taking away from the serial of this forum, sorry. 😳

Edited by luxmi_1029 - 8 years ago

Quote

CutiepieAD

@CutiepieAD

Sparkler

Posted: 8 years ago

#32

Originally posted by: shruthiravi
@aditi first thing people need to know in beyhadh is that it is Maya or perception. Perception will break only in second half, even our perception. So at this point all the perceptions are playing. So it is very annoying when perception is making you take decisions.
Coming to Chander. Yes Chander did a mistake. But where Chander is different from Devdas is that show closes with he willing to move ahead with Binti.

A girl whom the mother herself calls apashagun as her dad died immediately after birth, 2 of her marriages are broken in the mandap. In those days such a girl wont get married as she will be apashagun. But Chander honors Sudha's last wish giving life to Binti and Binti do get a good husband because of Sudha's sacrifice. That marriage also heralds the beginning of inter caste marriage as people might not oppose it as it will be touted as Sudha's death wish. Also it will be seen as Chander giving life to an unfortunate girl, while at the same time Chander gets Sudha's parchai.

Devdas drinked and died. Chander went into that phase. But BInti brings him back and Sudha forces him to move ahead with death wish.

You cant change past. But changing another life positively is equivalent to atoning your past, which Chander does with Binti.

Your take is as usual beautiful I could have never understood the difference.

I think they should have given a narration at the end abt what u said for everyone to understand..