Diff story but still less trp??? - Page 3

Poll

Differ from other but why less trp

Login To Vote

Created

Last reply

Replies

31

Views

2.5k

Users

16

Likes

39

Frequent Posters

goodhearted thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#21

Originally posted by: ishakumar

The online trp is very high which is highly regarded nowadays! It's been in the top 10 shows based on online trps...
I believe that the high online trp shows it's actual popularity amongst the youth :)
This show is not an aunty's cup of tea ;) lmfao



I completely agree with you isha. There might be many possible reasons for the less trp when it comes to watching on tv but online trp is high that shows people watch the show online rather on tv...its on us when we want to watch our beloved show...aunty's have different shows to watch on the same time so some people like me left with the only option to watch it online
TheUnique thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#22
I live in India & I know that people here mostly watch SP & Colors. In rural India they don't even show Sony TV.
Hence less trps but beyhadh is appreciated by the youth & most of us watch it online. So online trps r pretty high. Also beyhadh is becoming hugely popular & it's like trending almost everyday on you tube. So whateva may be trps the show is getting it's audiences. Also since its an finite series I don't think it will drag.
Edited by TheUnique - 8 years ago
MehbeerMyWorld thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#23
Bcoz It airs on Sony TV
The First Phase may be good but every single Indian show become crap after marriage
And lastly Sometimes to gain trps maker just loose d focus on main story & d story goes down the drain 😆
shruthiravi thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#24
It is doing good by Sony standards. Second is Indian audience cannot take suspense. They prefer narration than stories where the past has to reveal itself. Because most of the people watch the shows in between many activities.
If you need to enjoy a show like beyhadh you need to dedicate your 30 mins for the show. Because the expression change of the central character is that minute. The movement of Jenny's eyes you have to observe very closely.

There is no telling if it was on SP or Colors the fate would have been different. SP had Ek Hasina Thi from the same PH. It was doing good online, doing great in UK but then the Indian TRPs were below mark and it was wrapped up in 8 months instead of the promised one year. What was interesting was that the TRP build up on the second half to such an extend that it ended as the slot leader. CVs kept the theme of the show intact. EHT was re-run in UK and had a successful run in UAE, and I guess it is now airing in Ghana. But in India its record was not great as it never got repeated in Star Utsav.

Leave EHT, SP started many youth oriented show Bathameez Dil and Dosti yariyan had great online audiences but both died premature death.

Even the sit com Sumit Sambhal lega didnt had great TRP though it was a real stress buster and hence its Season 2 didnt happen.

Currently POW is a superb show but it doesnt have TRP. SP have experimented, but then shows have not been accepted.

So it is not the channel but the audience who has to give patronage for good content. And well dont tell it is the problem of TRP aunties.

I have read youngsters in EHT forum who had wanted the leading lady to marry the rapist and reform him.
There are many youngsters who stick to the theme of abusive male protoganist and the leading lady marrying him and reforming him.
There are many young fans for shows like Naagin and I dont want to take names of certain shows , that is also driven by the young generation in name of jodis.

I have watched a superb show Ek tha Chander Ek Thi Sudha just 21 epi show in Life Ok. It is based on a book Gunahon ke Devta written in 60s. The theme was far more progressive than any show of today. The character of Sudha, Pammi and Binti make you sit, each different and each showing a different strength.

Shows are economic ventures. If the audience wont consume the content what will the producers do.

Also many think strong woman means running business, doing all the jobs at home, solving all the problems etc etc..that definition itself is wrong.

A strong woman is not someone who wants to prove her strength by all the activities mentioned above. She is the one who can stand up for herself and realizes power is part and parcel of herself. It is in the choices she make.

And any day if you ask me who is the strongest female protoganist I have come across in a movie, it goes to Ganga of Malayalam movie Perumazhakalam( It is Dor in hindi). She is a simple housewife, widow living in a very orthodox surroundings, but under certain circumstances take the most courageous and out of box decision not fearing social ostracism.

Or Roja of Mani Ratnam's Roja who stands in the most adverse situation in kashmir and demands the release of her husband.
Bano of Bombay who doesnt hide her identity just for the sake of social acceptance. Yes she married a Hindu man, but her identity remains the same. He is Shekhar, she is Saira Bano.
riyya6 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#25

Originally posted by: shruthiravi

It is doing good by Sony standards. Second is Indian audience cannot take suspense. They prefer narration than stories where the past has to reveal itself. Because most of the people watch the shows in between many activities.

If you need to enjoy a show like beyhadh you need to dedicate your 30 mins for the show. Because the expression change of the central character is that minute. The movement of Jenny's eyes you have to observe very closely.

There is no telling if it was on SP or Colors the fate would have been different. SP had Ek Hasina Thi from the same PH. It was doing good online, doing great in UK but then the Indian TRPs were below mark and it was wrapped up in 8 months instead of the promised one year. What was interesting was that the TRP build up on the second half to such an extend that it ended as the slot leader. CVs kept the theme of the show intact. EHT was re-run in UK and had a successful run in UAE, and I guess it is now airing in Ghana. But in India its record was not great as it never got repeated in Star Utsav.

Leave EHT, SP started many youth oriented show Bathameez Dil and Dosti yariyan had great online audiences but both died premature death.

Even the sit com Sumit Sambhal lega didnt had great TRP though it was a real stress buster and hence its Season 2 didnt happen.

Currently POW is a superb show but it doesnt have TRP. SP have experimented, but then shows have not been accepted.

So it is not the channel but the audience who has to give patronage for good content. And well dont tell it is the problem of TRP aunties.

I have read youngsters in EHT forum who had wanted the leading lady to marry the rapist and reform him.
There are many youngsters who stick to the theme of abusive male protoganist and the leading lady marrying him and reforming him.
There are many young fans for shows like Naagin and I dont want to take names of certain shows , that is also driven by the young generation in name of jodis.

I have watched a superb show Ek tha Chander Ek Thi Sudha just 21 epi show in Life Ok. It is based on a book Gunahon ke Devta written in 60s. The theme was far more progressive than any show of today. The character of Sudha, Pammi and Binti make you sit, each different and each showing a different strength.

Shows are economic ventures. If the audience wont consume the content what will the producers do.

Also many think strong woman means running business, doing all the jobs at home, solving all the problems etc etc..that definition itself is wrong.

A strong woman is not someone who wants to prove her strength by all the activities mentioned above. She is the one who can stand up for herself and realizes power is part and parcel of herself. It is in the choices she make.

And any day if you ask me who is the strongest female protoganist I have come across in a movie, it goes to Ganga of Malayalam movie Perumazhakalam( It is Dor in hindi). She is a simple housewife, widow living in a very orthodox surroundings, but under certain circumstances take the most courageous and out of box decision not fearing social ostracism.

Or Roja of Mani Ratnam's Roja who stands in the most adverse situation in kashmir and demands the release of her husband.
Bano of Bombay who doesnt hide her identity just for the sake of social acceptance. Yes she married a Hindu man, but her identity remains the same. He is Shekhar, she is Saira Bano.

... you are def an asset to the forum ... how to do manage to remember and quote movies, examples is Beyond me ... thank you for writing and sharing the information ... 👏
shruthiravi thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#26
@riyya a woman has to realize what power is. She has to realize she can make choices. And marriage it is the most important choice of life. Have enough knowledge in you to choose a man who is not the slave of wealth and who considers you part of him.
If you need your identity that's the only way.
luxmi_1029 thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#27

Originally posted by: shruthiravi

It is doing good by Sony standards. Second is Indian audience cannot take suspense. They prefer narration than stories where the past has to reveal itself. Because most of the people watch the shows in between many activities.

If you need to enjoy a show like beyhadh you need to dedicate your 30 mins for the show. Because the expression change of the central character is that minute. The movement of Jenny's eyes you have to observe very closely.

There is no telling if it was on SP or Colors the fate would have been different. SP had Ek Hasina Thi from the same PH. It was doing good online, doing great in UK but then the Indian TRPs were below mark and it was wrapped up in 8 months instead of the promised one year. What was interesting was that the TRP build up on the second half to such an extend that it ended as the slot leader. CVs kept the theme of the show intact. EHT was re-run in UK and had a successful run in UAE, and I guess it is now airing in Ghana. But in India its record was not great as it never got repeated in Star Utsav.

Leave EHT, SP started many youth oriented show Bathameez Dil and Dosti yariyan had great online audiences but both died premature death.

Even the sit com Sumit Sambhal lega didnt had great TRP though it was a real stress buster and hence its Season 2 didnt happen.

Currently POW is a superb show but it doesnt have TRP. SP have experimented, but then shows have not been accepted.

So it is not the channel but the audience who has to give patronage for good content. And well dont tell it is the problem of TRP aunties.

I have read youngsters in EHT forum who had wanted the leading lady to marry the rapist and reform him.
There are many youngsters who stick to the theme of abusive male protoganist and the leading lady marrying him and reforming him.
There are many young fans for shows like Naagin and I dont want to take names of certain shows , that is also driven by the young generation in name of jodis.

I have watched a superb show Ek tha Chander Ek Thi Sudha just 21 epi show in Life Ok. It is based on a book Gunahon ke Devta written in 60s. The theme was far more progressive than any show of today. The character of Sudha, Pammi and Binti make you sit, each different and each showing a different strength.

Shows are economic ventures. If the audience wont consume the content what will the producers do.

Also many think strong woman means running business, doing all the jobs at home, solving all the problems etc etc..that definition itself is wrong.

A strong woman is not someone who wants to prove her strength by all the activities mentioned above. She is the one who can stand up for herself and realizes power is part and parcel of herself. It is in the choices she make.

And any day if you ask me who is the strongest female protoganist I have come across in a movie, it goes to Ganga of Malayalam movie Perumazhakalam( It is Dor in hindi). She is a simple housewife, widow living in a very orthodox surroundings, but under certain circumstances take the most courageous and out of box decision not fearing social ostracism.

Or Roja of Mani Ratnam's Roja who stands in the most adverse situation in kashmir and demands the release of her husband.
Bano of Bombay who doesnt hide her identity just for the sake of social acceptance. Yes she married a Hindu man, but her identity remains the same. He is Shekhar, she is Saira Bano.


Wow! I love your post. Malayalam movies have some of the best content when it comes to women-centric films and they explore so many shades of women, and continue to do so successfully (Kerala is historically known as being a matrilineal/matriarchal society- this continues to be the case in many of its regions today with families practicing the same 👏). Mani Ratnam too has created some of the most thought provoking, realistic- with a dash of the needed popular cinematic touches, and talent-filled movies within the Tamil film industry. Mani Ratnam has in my opinion never failed at creating strong female characters (that range in ages). I also love his movie, Anjali, that truly did an amazing job at trying to bring awareness around child developmental issues as well as many other things. Another director who has succeeded in this is Bharathiraja with movies such as "Karuthamma"- a tamil movie that depicted the lives of 3 sisters and the telling of their individual stories as intertwined to bring awareness about female infanticide. For anyone who has the time do check out the movie, it will not disappoint.

Beyhadh on the other hand is a show that is nothing compared to all of the above mentioned. Even their female portrayals are just okay- Maya's character included. I do think Beyhadh would've done better if it was a weekly series rather than a daily series.The thrill factor is dampened due to the dail episodes. Trps are honestly a waste of time. I wish they didn't exist. So many good shows have been cancelled or cut short because of it 😭
Edited by luxmi_1029 - 8 years ago
shruthiravi thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#28
Luxumi thanks for reminding Karuthama. I also like another Tamil movie Samsaram oru Minsaram. Lakshmi steals the show with her final decision.
See my point is one thing. From the discussions I have seen in the forum, I see very less mature discussions where characters, their motivations are discussed impartially. Most of the discussions are about the pairs, who will marry whom, who will stay with whom. It is about jodis and not about story.
Also the concept of strong. Maybe I have seen so many good Malayalam and Tamil movies and also the DD shows of mid to late 90s, my definition of strong differs vastly from what people define as strong.

I wont say Beyhadh is great or a master piece or something. But it is not bad. First thing the viewers have to know about the show is it is a 260 epi finite series so that means till 130 epi it is first half of the show. There will be many things which will be open at this point, we may not understand at this point.
A show like beyhadh can be criticized only after it crosses 130 and post that if it is not tying the loose ends yes it has a problem.
Before that if you shout why it is like this, why it is like that some things we have to accept it is like that for a reason.

And if time permits do watch the show Ek tha Chander Ek thi Sudha. it is 21 epi and available in hotstar. It's a beauty.
CutiepieAD thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#29

Originally posted by: shruthiravi

It is doing good by Sony standards. Second is Indian audience cannot take suspense. They prefer narration than stories where the past has to reveal itself. Because most of the people watch the shows in between many activities.

If you need to enjoy a show like beyhadh you need to dedicate your 30 mins for the show. Because the expression change of the central character is that minute. The movement of Jenny's eyes you have to observe very closely.

There is no telling if it was on SP or Colors the fate would have been different. SP had Ek Hasina Thi from the same PH. It was doing good online, doing great in UK but then the Indian TRPs were below mark and it was wrapped up in 8 months instead of the promised one year. What was interesting was that the TRP build up on the second half to such an extend that it ended as the slot leader. CVs kept the theme of the show intact. EHT was re-run in UK and had a successful run in UAE, and I guess it is now airing in Ghana. But in India its record was not great as it never got repeated in Star Utsav.

Leave EHT, SP started many youth oriented show Bathameez Dil and Dosti yariyan had great online audiences but both died premature death.

Even the sit com Sumit Sambhal lega didnt had great TRP though it was a real stress buster and hence its Season 2 didnt happen.

Currently POW is a superb show but it doesnt have TRP. SP have experimented, but then shows have not been accepted.

So it is not the channel but the audience who has to give patronage for good content. And well dont tell it is the problem of TRP aunties.

I have read youngsters in EHT forum who had wanted the leading lady to marry the rapist and reform him.
There are many youngsters who stick to the theme of abusive male protoganist and the leading lady marrying him and reforming him.
There are many young fans for shows like Naagin and I dont want to take names of certain shows , that is also driven by the young generation in name of jodis.

I have watched a superb show Ek tha Chander Ek Thi Sudha just 21 epi show in Life Ok. It is based on a book Gunahon ke Devta written in 60s. The theme was far more progressive than any show of today. The character of Sudha, Pammi and Binti make you sit, each different and each showing a different strength.

Shows are economic ventures. If the audience wont consume the content what will the producers do.

Also many think strong woman means running business, doing all the jobs at home, solving all the problems etc etc..that definition itself is wrong.

A strong woman is not someone who wants to prove her strength by all the activities mentioned above. She is the one who can stand up for herself and realizes power is part and parcel of herself. It is in the choices she make.

And any day if you ask me who is the strongest female protoganist I have come across in a movie, it goes to Ganga of Malayalam movie Perumazhakalam( It is Dor in hindi). She is a simple housewife, widow living in a very orthodox surroundings, but under certain circumstances take the most courageous and out of box decision not fearing social ostracism.

Or Roja of Mani Ratnam's Roja who stands in the most adverse situation in kashmir and demands the release of her husband.
Bano of Bombay who doesnt hide her identity just for the sake of social acceptance. Yes she married a Hindu man, but her identity remains the same. He is Shekhar, she is Saira Bano.


Agree with each n every word, Shruthi di.

Beyhadh is doing well as compared to Sony's other shows n is a hit online ( mainly due to Jenny's powerful performance n Arya fans)
Even channel seem to be happy with the show they are promoting the show nicely.
Infact it's a boon that it's on Sony because on colors or Star plus, the show wouldn't have been able to garner trp initially going by the story line, n Colors n SP wud have definitely mendled with the story line n spoilt the essence of the show.

I agree on the suspense factor. Even I personally like narration more than past getting revealed sply if it's stretched. And one can't guarantee that the revealition is going to be something out of the box till we see it actually (in any daily soap).. Thus show has been talking abt Maya ka raaz since soo long n nothing has come up yet. Audience do lose interest after some time.

Bold- trp audience has aunties as well as young ppl. Aunties like regressive Saas bahu drama n youngsters like Angry young man n bubbly heroine concept, where the FL finally "reforms" the ML n forgive him after he forced marriage or fakes luv or any other pathetic thing. Such FLs n ML's are considered strong(which is actually not). These shows are hit online too so why do blame just trp aunties? 😆 or else shows like POW would have done well..

Unfortunately Beyhad doesn't belong to any of the category. It's just the opposite. As u said Maya is not strong because she's a business woman, or fashionavesta, she's strong because she had the guts to stand against Ashwin, and even after being so called pagal, she is sane enough to choose the best match for her ie Arjun, and to leave behind her past n move on n correct her mistakes.
Even am drifting away from the show post marriage because of Vandana's pathetic behavior, but I will give it time as of now.

Di, I have watched ETC ETS. I have to say it was better than any show on air right now, but I also feel it was a bit complicated. The concept of love n physical satisfaction was quite well explained but don't u think Chander was similar to Devdas? I know u don't like devdas😆

shruthiravi thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#30
@aditi first thing people need to know in beyhadh is that it is Maya or perception. Perception will break only in second half, even our perception. So at this point all the perceptions are playing. So it is very annoying when perception is making you take decisions.
Coming to Chander. Yes Chander did a mistake. But where Chander is different from Devdas is that show closes with he willing to move ahead with Binti.

A girl whom the mother herself calls apashagun as her dad died immediately after birth, 2 of her marriages are broken in the mandap. In those days such a girl wont get married as she will be apashagun. But Chander honors Sudha's last wish giving life to Binti and Binti do get a good husband because of Sudha's sacrifice. That marriage also heralds the beginning of inter caste marriage as people might not oppose it as it will be touted as Sudha's death wish. Also it will be seen as Chander giving life to an unfortunate girl, while at the same time Chander gets Sudha's parchai.

Devdas drinked and died. Chander went into that phase. But BInti brings him back and Sudha forces him to move ahead with death wish.

You cant change past. But changing another life positively is equivalent to atoning your past, which Chander does with Binti.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".