Manya's singing last week

I saw the last weekends episode a bit late, but I definitely feel Manya deserves to stay after that performance. I think she is being unfairly targeted for a certain decision that the creatives have been accused. I would like to see her keep improving and making it to top 5 and so on.

She undoubtedly wasn't very bad last week.
But she's clearly weaker that the others (barring Khudabaksh, who is as good or bad as her, in my opinion).

She's been targetted because of the way she made a reentry. It wasn't fair to the other eliminated contestants.

It's not Manyas fault, purely the channels. But she's bearing the brunt of it all.

Exactly. How is it her fault that she was brought back? 😕

Originally posted by: lostNfound

I saw the last weekends episode a bit late, but I definitely feel Manya deserves to stay after that performance. I think she is being unfairly targeted for a certain decision that the creatives have been accused. I would like to see her keep improving and making it to top 5 and so on.

Its a moot point now ... however I would just like to say we folks don't have anything against Manya.
But if you do compare her voice and singing to the other contestants... sadly she does lack and it shows very much. Her song selection is in a particular zone and the range and the 'sur' per se is suspect.

She has improved but even the improvement is not enough to beat the some of the others on the platform ... even the untrained ones like Khudabaksh do not slip on ' sur ' so much.
She has a presence, easy on the eyes and she is a Female. Those are only of the few reasons she was back... Malavika was the only female on the Idol and just to boost the female presence Manya was selected.