Predict the top 3

First Previous

Page

Frequent Posters

chahat4u

@chahat4u

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 9 years ago

#11

probable top 3: Mohit, Revanth, Khudabakhsh/Shravan.

According to me: Mohit, Shravan, Maalvika/Tajinder

Quote

Adtt

@Adtt

Voyager

Posted: 9 years ago

#12

Originally posted by: ~Raina~

Indian idol has never been solely about singing, they lay a lot of emphasis on style and personality.
Sony will release an album with the singer, most people don't enjoy classical music or classically influenced music. Also they all seem to like flashy videos. As such the winner will likely be someone who oozes charisma, the audience likes or grows to like.

Shravan is an amazing winner, but this show isn't for him. Or even Rohit for that matter. They have abundance of talent, but sadly it's not appreciated by the audience.
Revanth isn't classically trained, his base maybe weak, but he has a great voice. His pronounciation almost makes me commit suicide, but he's a smart chap - see how he asks for votes, useable terms like aapka pyaar chahiye, aapka aashirwad chahiye. He makes statements like meri girlfriend ka naam Indian idol hai, flashes a sly smile showing his dimples - all of course for the umpteen females to vote for him.

The other talented ones aren't doing any of that, they trust their talent, but in a commercial show that's seldom enough.

Wonder what's wrong with Shravan's and Rohit's personality?

Is it wrong to be modest and simple? Or is it the physical appearence that 'connects' the audience? In that case why a big hue on bringing Manya back?

Edited by chutty - 9 years ago

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Raina

@Raina101

Dazzler

Posted: 9 years ago

#13

Originally posted by: chutty

What's wrong with Shravan's and Rohit's personality?
Is it wrong to be modest and simple? Or is it the physical appearence that would 'connect' the audience with the singers? In that case why a big hue on bringing Manya back?

Nothing wrong in my opinion, but the don't have a charismatic personality which will help sell.
As for Manya, it's only looks and not a good enough voice.

With Revanth or Mohit Atleast they have good voice to go with their personality

Edited by ~Raina~ - 9 years ago

Quote

Adtt

@Adtt

Voyager

Posted: 9 years ago

#14

@Raina...how do you define charisma, and how do you apply on the contestants? I think each contestant are special in their own way- be it in sobbing, singing or stage performance.

Rohit, Shravan and Tajinder for that matter, have strenth of character, individuality and moreover talent. What else one needs to have more to be charismatic other than these?

KudhaB and Mohit have plenty of supporters..so is it like that sobbing and crying out revealing your sad stories is a kind of charisma? Or is it one's charismatic character is based on whether he or she is already a play back singer?

Quote

Raina

@Raina101

Dazzler

Posted: 9 years ago

#15

Everyone has a personality, but charismatic is much more than that.
Honestly to describe in words is very very difficult.
Crying and sob stories doesn't contribute to sob stories. Infact I won't say Khudabaksh is charismatic.

Quote

Adtt

@Adtt

Voyager

Posted: 9 years ago

#16

Originally posted by: ~Raina~
Everyone has a personality, but charismatic is much more than that.
Honestly to describe in words is very very difficult.
Crying and sob stories doesn't contribute to sob stories. Infact I won't say Khudabaksh is charismatic.

In my view, people have their own favorites, hence the support. People support due to many factors-region, state, language etc etc which I think has nothing to do with anybody's character or charisma. Saying some don't get support due to lack of charisma is kinda judgemental, coz these contestants are neither public figures nor celebrities.

Edited by chutty - 9 years ago