Manu is 100% right on BB Tasks. Salman 100% WRONG!

-Cruiser- thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 9 years ago
#1
Manu's take on BB tasks is 100% right.👏
One may recall initial tasks were simply Commoners vs Celebrities. Then to shake things up BB team mashed Gaurav to Manu-Manveer side in couple of tasks. 😊

Idea of tasks is to shake up established loyalties and formed groups.👏

What Salman seems to be suggesting is a recipe for disaster.👎🏼

You can't be screwing up tasks in the name of what your moral compass seems to suggest to you. If that were to happen,after first few days everyone would take a position as to who is a saint and who is an evil and thereafter help his / her saints through the season. How ridiculous that would be?😲

In the end it all boils down to over intrusive and absurd intervention of host that leads to all these confusions.

Imagine a Manu or a Lopa or a Rohan being asked by BB to help a Manveer or a Mona or a Nitibha in a task and them scratching their heads and wondering whether Salman would approve or blast them and subsequently taking positions according to their assessments of how Salman would react to their chosen behaviour.😕

Salman is getting more absurd with each passing week.🤢

Created

Last reply

Replies

18

Views

2.1k

Users

10

Likes

72

Frequent Posters

DoremonLove thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 9 years ago
#2
Though i didnt like when manu said that he would make om win. But ur point is right if everyone starts thinking ke chalo I ont support him becoz acc to me hes not right. Manu was somewhat right also when he said ke meri iss ghar me 5 logose nhi banti toh main kya pancho ko captain nhi banne duga.
Task apni jagah hai. One side they say task performing is very important than on other side sallu says ke task me aap om jaise ko jeetoge. Toh bhai exactly karna kya hai. 🤪
Picasso9 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#3
Why can't it be strategy. Manu can fake support for Om in task but ultimately make him lose. It's a game after all. In this case Manu applied false equivalency between Bani and Om and his hatred for celebrities won out not his pure intention to perform task at optimum level. Manu is a fake who wants to remain above the fray by sitting on fence and masking his hatred for celebs.
Lumos-Maxima thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#4
I don't agree with you on this! Where I believe everyone should give their 100% in a task but Om is a total different case. He is mentally unbalanced. Several times he crossed level of decency during tasks. He got aggressive during tasks. In short Om is not the eligible candidate for captaincy. During court room task, Manu gave his 100% to save him. Though I think Judge Manveer was partial but Manu did his job according to the task. Fair enough. But when it comes to captaincy it involves responsibility of the house as well as it includes immunity. Om is fit for none. He got quite a few unfair advantages in the show already. So Manu could clearly refuse to do the task on behalf of Om since he claimed he didn't want Om to become the captain. If it were a LB task then he should give his 100% for his team but in captaincy task every HM can support his/her favorite candidate in one's own way. If someone doesn't want to support a particular candidate in captaincy, I don't think it matters what host thinks. Clearly Manu was supporting Om over Bani and somehow it was pretty evident even without this discussion with Salman.
usmanm4u thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#5
Somehow you are right
BUT
Manu's intention was totally wrong. He put good point

In the taks we understand, task should be entertaining and should be completed
BUT
if task was on voting base, what he should do?
What he said about OM in WKV
and what he do if captain will be chosen on voting base
he very clearly said he will vote for OM
now what is logic behind his support to OM?
Rohan was right
They (Manu Manveer) use OM for their on purpose


kaps22 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#6
I agree with you, Cruiser.
A show like this brings people from different backgrounds and different personalities and makes them live with each other. The chief value of this show to the audience is to show how people can:
(1) live with each other amongst their differences, and
(2) leave aside their personal differences in the tasks to get the job done.

Unfortunately, the host and the channel management have turned the objective of the show to taking a stand and fighting with each other over each person's stand and let the host be the jury of whose stand is correct.

If Bigg Boss assigns Manu a task, and he leaves aside his personal judgments of a contestant to perform well in the assigned task, then he should be applauded and made a model of. Leaving aside personal differences and working with others is one of the chief highlights of Western Civilization and one of the key causes of its success.

If the host thinks that the personal opinion and judgment of each other is superior than the task at hand, then he is promoting the chief cause of infighting in the country and probably one of the reasons why people in our country keep fighting over their differences and not getting the work done. Taking a stand should be in service of getting the task performed well. These people have turned the performance of task in service of taking a stand.

I agree with you. Salman and the channel are the big problem. They are promoting 'the argumentative indian' - and not the Indian who finds unity in diversity or the indian who collaborates to get work done.
Edited by kaps22 - 9 years ago
-Cruiser- thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 9 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: kaps22

I agree with you, Cruiser.

A show like this brings people from different backgrounds and different personalities and makes them live with each other. The chief value of this show to the audience is to show how people can:
(1) live with each other amongst their differences, and
(2) leave aside their personal differences in the tasks to get the job done.

Unfortunately, the host and the channel management have turned the objective of the show to taking a stand and fighting with each other over each person's stand and let the host be the jury of whose stand is correct.

If Bigg Boss assigns Manu a task, and he leaves aside his personal judgments of a contestant to perform well in the assigned task, then he should be applauded and made a model of. Leaving aside personal differences and working with others is one of the chief highlights of Western Civilization and one of the key causes of its success.

If the host thinks that the personal opinion and judgment of each other is superior than the task at hand, then he is promoting the chief cause of infighting in the country and probably one of the reasons why people in our country keep fighting over their differences and not getting the work done. Taking a stand should be in service of getting the task performed well. These people have turned the performance of task in service of taking a stand.

I agree with you. Salman and the channel are the big problem. They are promoting 'the argumentative indian' - and not the Indian who finds unity in diversity or the indian who collaborates to get work done.

I could never have expressed it all so well. Hats off to you Kaps...
This is the post all must read in case you believe a contestant should be exercising moral judgment over any other contestant at the cost of a BB assigned task. Superb indeed...👏
Edited by -Cruiser- - 9 years ago
-Cruiser- thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 9 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: DoremonLove

Though i didnt like when manu said that he would make om win. But ur point is right if everyone starts thinking ke chalo I ont support him becoz acc to me hes not right. Manu was somewhat right also when he said ke meri iss ghar me 5 logose nhi banti toh main kya pancho ko captain nhi banne duga.

Task apni jagah hai. One side they say task performing is very important than on other side sallu says ke task me aap om jaise ko jeetoge. Toh bhai exactly karna kya hai. 🤪


Imagine the extreme and visualize Om not indulging in pee throwing and Manu somehow helping him to become captain.

May I know what disaster it would have brought on house as now Salman and few others seem to be so virtuously suggesting?😛

Baba would have given some cranky orders,housemates would have refused to listen to him just as they refused to listen to Rohan and few other Captains in last two months. Kya ukhaad leta Baba?😲

Task is a task and as it comes from Bigg Boss whose house it is, the sanctity should be respected and one must give his best. Simple
-Cruiser- thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 9 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: -LumosMaxima-

I don't agree with you on this! Where I believe everyone should give their 100% in a task but Om is a total different case. He is mentally unbalanced. Several times he crossed level of decency during tasks. He got aggressive during tasks. In short Om is not the eligible candidate for captaincy. During court room task, Manu gave his 100% to save him. Though I think Judge Manveer was partial but Manu did his job according to the task. Fair enough. But when it comes to captaincy it involves responsibility of the house as well as it includes immunity. Om is fit for none. He got quite a few unfair advantages in the show already. So Manu could clearly refuse to do the task on behalf of Om since he claimed he didn't want Om to become the captain. If it were a LB task then he should give his 100% for his team but in captaincy task every HM can support his/her favorite candidate in one's own way. If someone doesn't want to support a particular candidate in captaincy, I don't think it matters what host thinks. Clearly Manu was supporting Om over Bani and somehow it was pretty evident even without this discussion with Salman.


Suppose Om hadn't done this gross Pee sprinkle job and had actually become Captain. What max would have happened?😊

He would have come up with some crazy diktats like X tum Pool mein koodo, Y tumhein garden mein sona padega blah blah!😆

Just as orders of Rohan-Lopa were not followed his orders would have been ignored too and he would have cried to BB through couple of cams! How would it have mattered?😲
Edited by -Cruiser- - 9 years ago
951405 thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#10
Agreed with you fully Cruiser! Thanks for the objectivity. 👏

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".