Tia.0 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 8 years ago
#1

Today's topic is Change...


Change is the only constant in life. We all know that, every living being and inanimate objects go through change and transformation to something different.


Living beings grow older, silver goes black, iron rusts, wood ages, wine ripens etc etc etc...


Change is unstoppable. So whether you gracefully embrace the change or fight it with all your might and lose your dignity in the process, the choice is yours. The choice you don't have is to stop the change from happening.

Among the two choices I mentioned, Dida and Asha chose the former and Ishwari chose the later.


I won't speak about Motherhood because I am not a mother yet. So obviously I don't know how one mother, who is obsessed with her son, can let go her daughter so easily. That kind of shows what she values more because obviously people clutch onto what they value more and let go of what they consider is not very useful.

But the reason I brought up change is because this is something I am familiar with.


Some people fear any change expecting it to be for the worse and some people welcome change expecting it to be for the better.

Among all major and minor changes of life, marital relationship is possibly the biggest change in anyone's life apart from puberty and motherhood.


In fact, if you ask me, marital relationship is the biggest change.

Why?


You see, during puberty a huge physical, emotional and mental transformation happen, but you are still holding the steering wheel of your life even if the road and the outside condition is rough.


Motherhood is also a huge change. But your baby completely depends on you. So you are the person holding this soft ball of clay to mold them the way you want to. Yes, you don't have the direction in which way to go and you'll have to figure out the road without GPS or a map. But you are again the only one at the steering wheel.


But in marriage, not only the drive is rough and the road uncertain, you will also have to share the steering wheel with someone else while people at your back seat is screaming direction, criticism and advice in every turn...


You see what I mean?


So to remain in control, the people holding the steering wheel together have to roll up the sound proof glass and focus on their road and on each other. Because the passengers will one by one get down or hop in. But the two people holding the steering wheel have to travel a long way without crashing the car. Unless they block out the outside distractions, they will never reach their destination.


What the passengers can do? Why, instead of complaining about the add on driver, they can encourage the driver that he/she is doing a great job and it's okay if they make mistakes, they are still loved and trusted and they will definitely figure things out.


And most of it depends on the previous driver who used to drive solo is to move a little and make space for the driver beside him and stop hogging the steering wheel .

(Have you ever drove a Go-cart at amusement park with one wheel like the Tea-cup ride? How pissed off you get when someone hogs the steering wheel all the time? Yeah like that)


Also, the former driver can tell his previous passenger to stop criticising the new driver because if they continue to do so, she just may crash the car and injure everyone in the process or get out of the car leaving the former driver forever alone in the front seat.


Now moving on to the main topic.


We knew from the beginning that there were three people in the equation - Dev, Sonakshi and Ishwari.


I was sold on the concept thinking, here are two people in love and the third is resisting change and hence two people together will try to help the third transform.


I concluded from that (as I think many of you did), that the two people in love was Dev and Sonakshi and Ishwari was resisting change having a new woman in her son's life and hence, Dev and Sona will make up a team and help her transform into an ideal mother-in-law.


The concept was on point.


But what I didn't know was that the two people in love were Dev and Ishwari and Sona was resisting change in her personality by turning into a meek, submissive woman and hence Dev and Ishwari will make up a team to turn her into a mindless robot that becomes invisible when she is not needed.


But I always wanted to know, why would we automatically accept that a mother-in-law won't love her daughter-in-law?


Why is it so easy to get used to?


When two siblings both love their parents, we don't think that one sibling is the enemy of the other or enemy of the parents? We know that they love our parents so as concerned for their welfare as we are.


When two friends have common interest, say they like same kind of books and movies, their bonding is stronger than two friends who have nothing in common.


And here, between a mother and daughter-in-law, their bonding should be the strongest. They both love the same man but very differently.

One has given birth and raised him and the other will give birth to his children and walk the rest of her life with him.


In Hinduism, which by the way Ishwari keeps misusing to suit her purpose, there are four ashrams.

They are: Brahmacharya (Student Life), Grihastha (Family Life), Vanaprastha (Retirement) and Sannyasa (Renunciation).

There are no blending between them, instead it was advised that when one ends, the other should start without delay.

Immediately after Brahmacharya, as one starts earning starts Grihastha.

Immediately after Grihastha as one's children start their own Grihastha, starts one's Vanaprastha (It doesn't mean going to the jungle. But means handing over one's responsibilities to the next generation while still present as an advisor, but not a contributor any more)

And as one become infirm and weak with old age, Vanaprastha turns into Sannyasa as in they are no longer is even in advisor position, but as an observer.


Why did our ancestors had to write down the stages of life? After all, every person is different?

I didn't know them (Duh! obviously!!!), but if I had to assume, it's to make change structured so easier to anticipate, expect and prepare for it.


Since Ishwari is a blind follower of religion, why is she clutching into Grihastha while snatching away Sonakshi's turn to follow the same.

When a woman loses her Grihastha stage, she then clutches into the next generation's Grihastha stage because she never had it. And the broken, twisted cycle continues.


Ishwari said yesterday that when a child is born, the mother's world becomes narrow. Even if I believe that, the child is no longer a child. The child has grown bigger than his own mother's narrow world.

But what she is trying to do is shove the child back into her little narrow box causing him extreme discomfort for her own selfish pleasure.


Now look at Dida. She was a single mother too and raised Bijoy. She could have kept her world narrow and forced Bijoy back into the little box.

But instead as Bijoy grew into a man, she expanded her little box to a wide open space along with her heart where Asha neatly settled in. As children kept coming, she kept on expanding so they could all live in comfort and in happiness without being crushed under narrow walls of segregation.

She is a mother, who loved Asha first because Bijoy loved her. Just like a mother learns to love video games their children love, books their children adore, movies their children want to watch.

But because of Dida's generous nature and wide open heart, Asha opened her heart too and embraced the relationship to the point that it's now seamless. It's hard to remember where it began or how, such is their bond.


Bijoy could have let go of Asha's insult. After all, she was not standing up for herself, so why bother looking bad himself when he can just ignore it?

But he didn't let it go. He turned the table on Dev in front of his own guests.

Some people blamed him because *GASP* he insulted his son-in-law at his birthday (never mind the insults Dev's family heaped on Sona on her wedding, vidaai, muh dikhai and so on. But she is a woman, so it's fine).


But you know what I see?


People who hide their deeds are ashamed of what they have done and know they have done is wrong.

People, who dare to say whatever they think is right in front of the whole world, know they are right and just and hence there is no need to hide behind secrecy.


Lie hides its face in shame, Truth always stands up proud.


If you need to give example of mother and son, give example of Bijoy and Dida.

If you need to give example of husband and wife, give example to Bijoy and Asha.

If you want to give example of in-laws, give example of Dida and Asha.

If you want to see how a change can be accepted, celebrated and incorporated in life for the betterment of all, look at Bose family. Dixit family so far had been utter failure in every aspect of relationship and change.


EDITED:


Society: Same woman who ignores/taunts/insults son's in-laws, bends over backward for daughter's in-laws.

When a daughter's in-laws feel slighted, they incite each other. When a son's in-laws feel slighted, they either keep silent or try to defuse the situation even if someone makes a fuss.


What a difference in consideration.


Ishwari: Mother is God. She knows business better than business man, law better than lawyer, medicine better than doctor.


With that kind of expertise, I am surprised why she was ever poor. She should have earned lots of money. If business men, lawyers and doctors earn in 6-7 figures, imagine if someone is all three how much will they earn?


In fact, since all human being had at least one mother, I don't know why we even bother to have any profession. Let us all retire and let mothers run all professional services.



Dev: All he wanted to have some freaking ice cream on his birthday. So what if he gets a bit sick? How many of us ate raw tamarind, danced in the rain, in short lived our life and fell sick? Did it make those tamarind any less mouth-watering, those rain dances any less fun, those moments any less memorable?


For heaven's sake, let the damn man live his life.


Sonakshi: A wife and doctor on duty. Be that formidable combination and don't let an illiterate idiot with delusion of grandour to make your husband and patient feel worse and challenge your expertise.


Me: Ishwari got smacked. God is great. But God, lagta hain nishana chuk gaya. Agli baar thode upar aim karna. Waise bhi khali jagah hain, kisi aur ko koi pareshani nehin hogi.


Precap: About the cold water bath, I think Sonakshi gave him a bath in luke warm water. But he was shivering because in fever when your temperature is high, even luke warm bath feels chilled. Think about this way, in winter, when our hand is cold, relatively warm thing seems warmer than usual.


Again, when our hands are warm from under the blanket, someone's hand which has regular temperature seems cold.

That's exactly what I think had happened.

If temperature goes too high, the organs start to overheat. You don't want a kidney or liver failure because the temperature went too high.

Bathing in room temperature water induces temperature to go down. But since fever is running hot, the water feels colder and hence shivering.

Heck, even sticking our toe outside our blanket in fever causes us to shiver in middle of summer. Does it mean, the room is chilled?
Edited by tia.o - 8 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

50

Views

5.5k

Users

17

Likes

136

Frequent Posters

baijubavra thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#2
The problem with Ishwari is that she wants to stay in the grihastha ashram with her son who she thinks should go back in his bhamhachrya ashram when ever she wants 😆 and her bahu to be in sanyasa ashram so she does not interfere in her unique setting with her son 😆

Have you noticed that she never talks about the Sr Mr Dixit although Dadi fondly remembers Bijoy's dad in almost all the ocassions. It looks like Ishwari never enjoyed her own short lived grihastha ashram and having more fun now as the son is more financially succesful.

She wants to make all the decisions starting with furniture placement in her bhamchari son and sanyasan bahu's bedroom to what he should eat and not eat 😆. She hogs all his time and attention then claims that a mother goes on vanvas when the son gets into the secondary relationships like husband- wife etc. 😆.

So the bottom line is that it is not the change that Ishwari hates. She wants to change the society rules already but it is just a ruse to hide her complicated setting 😆
Edited by baijubavra - 8 years ago
Tia.0 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 8 years ago
#3
You are right. Ishwari never talks about her husband nor gets any flashback about him. I wonder even if her husband was alive, would she ignore the poor guy and run after the rich son? In that sense I can see where Neha gets her obsession for money. She also dumped her poor husband and went back to her rich brother only for money. It's not as if she and Dev have a strong bond or closeness thanks to Ishwari's sucky parenting.

Originally posted by: baijubavra

The problem with Ishwari is that she wants to stay in the grihastha ashram with her son who she thinks should go back in his bhamhachrya ashram when ever she wants 😆 and her bahu to be in sanyasa ashram so she does not interfere in her unique setting with her son 😆


Have you noticed that she never talks about the Sr Mr Dixit although Dadi fondly remembers Bijoy's dad in almost all the ocassions. It looks like Ishwari never enjoyed her own short lived grihastha ashram and having more fun now as the son is more financially succesful.

She wants to make all the decisions starting with furniture placement in her bhamchari son and sanyasan bahu's bedroom to what he should eat and not eat 😆. She hogs all his time and attention then claims that a mother goes on vanvas when the son gets into the secondary relationships like husband- wife etc. 😆.

Edited by tia.o - 8 years ago
sona_naksh thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#4
Awsum post tia
Today i had to find ur post ...pata nhi kyun it was nt getting visible
Today watever ishwari did was just so wrong
Dev cannot eat icecream dev cannot have fun wid his sisters n wife ...cut dat man some slack ..
N way she behaved wid sona ...so rude n demeaning
Sona is a nutritionist but dats her speciality ...shez anyways a doctor first and can treat fever better dan u oshwari ji
Agree wid u reagarding change
D sooner u accept it ...easier it gets for u and for d concerned people
diyah_us thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#5
I must say u have lot of knowledge tia u discussed about different stages of life so true.
v have to change from one stage to another. I know its difficult for a mom to let go
of her kids especially for many moms sons but still they cant hold onto them longer
Tia.0 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 8 years ago
#6
True. And you know what was the weird part? Ishwari asking Sona, "Are you trying to kill my Dev?"

I was thinking, "Sure lady. After all, if Dev dies, she becomes a widow which is every woman's dream and she inherits you free-loading, narcissistic lot all hanging on her because you are all useless. That's exactly what she is aiming for."

Originally posted by: sona_naksh

Awsum post tia

Today i had to find ur post ...pata nhi kyun it was nt getting visible
Today watever ishwari did was just so wrong
Dev cannot eat icecream dev cannot have fun wid his sisters n wife ...cut dat man some slack ..
N way she behaved wid sona ...so rude n demeaning
Sona is a nutritionist but dats her speciality ...shez anyways a doctor first and can treat fever better dan u oshwari ji
Agree wid u reagarding change
D sooner u accept it ...easier it gets for u and for d concerned people

Tia.0 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 8 years ago
#7
Thank you. I am very curious so I like to ask why. Why is it easy for mother of daughters to let go and not for mother of sons?

Because every mother of a daughter know that one day she will get married and leave her, so she prepares for that day and learn to be happy in her happiness.

Some mother of a son takes it for granted that her son will forever be with her as long as she lives, so she clutches tighter and can't let another woman take him away (or so she thinks).

But not all mothers of sons are same. In Western countries, every one leaves their parents and lives on their own. You won't see mothers of daughters behaving differently than mothers of sons in terms of behaving like neurotic. There are difference human to human but that's it.

So for this mentality to change, the society needs to change and man and woman need to have same rights and responsibility towards their parents.

Originally posted by: diyah_us

I must say u have lot of knowledge tia u discussed about different stages of life so true.
v have to change from one stage to another. I know its difficult for a mom to let go
of her kids especially for many moms sons but still they cant hold onto them longer

diyah_us thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: tia.o

Thank you. I am very curious so I like to ask why. Why is it easy for mother of daughters to let go and not for mother of sons?

Because every mother of a daughter know that one day she will get married and leave her, so she prepares for that day and learn to be happy in her happiness.

Some mother of a son takes it for granted that her son will forever be with her as long as she lives, so she clutches tighter and can't let another woman take him away (or so she thinks).

But not all mothers of sons are same. In Western countries, every one leaves their parents and lives on their own. You won't see mothers of daughters behaving differently than mothers of sons in terms of behaving like neurotic. There are difference human to human but that's it.

So for this mentality to change, the society needs to change and man and woman need to have same rights and responsibility towards their parents.


I know in western countries most leave their parents girl or boy but in indian household only
the girl gets to leave her family. even though she may not be living with her in-laws as sona's case
but just living with her husband there r lots of expectations from her in-laws than how much
they expect from their son-in-law. In fact son-in-law is still considered as god in even educated
families. I don't think this will ever change in indian society how much ever modern the mil
may become like even she doesn't interfere in her dil wearing western clothes still mil
will expect more from dil than from sil. I am saying from personal experience😆😆
gemini54 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#9
Tia 👏 for your post.
Today I am going to play devils advocate. I am a hyper mother myself when it comes to my kids illness i freak out and don't feel comfortable whoever takes care including my husband.

Regarding the treatments there are two schools of thought to combat fever my grandma used to cover us with heavy blankets to ward temperature she used to say we have to sweat it out and I chose the shower method. My son ones had high fever that he went into shock and started getting fits I did take him to the bath tub and immersed him in water and when the ambulance came they said that I did right otherwise he would have got worse. Yesterday, my dog fell ill and i was freaking out so much that my husband banned me from coming to the vet 😆

As a parent I freak out every time my child has a simple cold my kids get irritated, my husband gets irritated but that is the way I am so I can understand where Easwari is coming from of course the whole thing has been exaggerated for drama sake.

For the rest of the episode I have no comments

P.S hopefully my DIL Sona's will not think I am crazy if I do overreact ...Thank God they will not live with us😆


Cant wait for the write up of Fusion Tia😉
Edited by gemini54 - 8 years ago
Tia.0 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 8 years ago
#10
Isn't that so sad? Someone's daughter-in-law is someone else's daughter, someone's son is someone else's son-in-law. If society treats them differently, then no wonder people still differentiate between boy and girl child.

Originally posted by: diyah_us


I know in western countries most leave their parents girl or boy but in indian household only
the girl gets to leave her family. even though she may not be living with her in-laws as sona's case
but just living with her husband there r lots of expectations from her in-laws than how much
they expect from their son-in-law. In fact son-in-law is still considered as god in even educated
families. I don't think this will ever change in indian society how much ever modern the mil
may become like even she doesn't interfere in her dil wearing western clothes still mil
will expect more from dil than from sil. I am saying from personal experience😆😆

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".