319125 thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#1

Mediocrity reigns here
Randeep Wadehra

Dill Mill Gayye, with characters from the medical fraternity, doesn't go beyond the hackneyed romance

Why do various productions on the Indian small screen invariably fail to breach the wall of crassness? There was a time when paucity of foreign exchange, lack of infrastructure and inability to access quality training facilities for TV professionals were given as reasons for the Indian television's inability to attain excellence. But these do not hold water any more. In fact, not only do we have world-class facilities for nurturing talented actors, technicians, etc, but also the requisite infrastructure for launching quality entertainers. This is evident from the slick soaps and movies being churned out by various production houses. What they lack is imagination, originality and application of mind.

Take the recently concluded mini-series, Bombay Lawyers, on NDTV. Its format was on the lines of Star World's notable serials like The Practice and Boston Legal. Moreover, while the acting was competent, the content was neither well researched nor exactly original. Although its episodes were supposedly based on real-life events, the actual execution indicated otherwise. Take the episode of a Muslim girl's rustication from a 'mixed' school for wearing hijaab. This situation looks more French than Indian as our tolerance levels are comparatively high and secular ethos are inbred into our collective psyche. Similarly the resolution of a divorce case involving a Tambrahm couple over the wife's right to abortion was a bit too pat.

In Star One's Dill Mill Gayye, the backdrop is a hospital and the characters are from medical fraternity. So it is natural to expect high-voltage drama involving treatment of patients suffering from terminal diseases, or a spastic struggling to lead a normal life, or a hopelessly handicapped person getting equipped for overcoming various existential challenges. There could've been absorbing drama involving a medical team dealing with disaster/terrorist victims. But our Maharajas of Mediocrity fob us off with clich'E9d romance. After all, crafting an original script involves genuine intellectual effort which our kitsch makers are incapable of.

Take Chhoona Hai Aasmaan, again on Star One. It lacks the kinetic energy that would've enthralled the discerning viewer, thanks to assorted omissions and gaffes. Group Captain Veer 'rectifies' the clerical error involving the posting of Flight Lieutenants Sameer Singh and Sameera Singh by tearing off Sameera's posting orders instead of resorting to a more credible response. But credibility has never been a favoured option with our soap-makers, who mindlessly rely on exaggerated gestures to create a dramatic effect. Or, take the episode involving a Pakistani stealing an IAF fighter and Sameera chasing him by clambering on to another jet – a la the filmy car chase. What the scriptwriter ignores is a vital detail: fighter jets are never kept in a ready-to-fly condition except during wartime. And, the jets are too heavily guarded for anyone to sneak them off so easily.

The pice de mdiocrit is 'training' of five best pilots as amateur spies. While watching the serial, one misses the atmospherics. There are no airmen attending to assorted jobs in hangars, on the tarmac and inside offices, thus robbing the narrative of the much-needed frisson and professional touch. Since the stereotypical confrontation-cum-romantic element between Abhimanyu and Sameera has already been introduced, be ready for more mind-numbing mediocrity.

Created

Last reply

Replies

9

Views

931

Users

10

Frequent Posters

armaanasya thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#2
i agree
however good the serial might be with the romance,it shud be based on medical background,it shud make more sense
pribhu thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#3
thanks for sharing......I agree a lil abt that the indian television has not gone to excellence level yet but i hope they will improve as time goes by.....I like the picture....armaan and riddz looks relly nye together 😳 ...
DivineSelf thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#4
There is a serial called "Scrubs" in Star World which is also based on doctors but it is a totally zany serial and totally crazy doctors. When they can have those serialse
why not DMG?? And I think the promos of the serial before it started clearly informed that it would be about love and friendship. It would be nice if there was some dose of serious medical drama, but even if it is not there, its fine because they never projected the image that it was meant to be a serious medical drama.
Catwoman thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 17 years ago
#5
😆 ..... do we want to see?? 😕
"treatment of patients suffering from terminal diseases, or a spastic struggling to lead a normal life, or a hopelessly handicapped person getting equipped for overcoming various existential challenges. There could've been absorbing drama involving a medical team dealing with disaster/terrorist victims." just yet as we are still understanding the characters at the moment... like kirti and others... i guess the creaters have so many options to explore before they take up this track... 😳

Kat
Edited by Catwoman - 17 years ago
-Mansi- thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 17 years ago
#6
ya..agreed...but after all its a serial..nd romance has 2 be there..btw chrarcters. 😳 😳
MrsKaranGrover thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 17 years ago
#7
Tfs, its been posed be4 😳 ...
dmg_sonia thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 17 years ago
#8
thanks 4 the article

dmg is all about their life after Dr dutis....n from the 1st promo only dmg has stated its about love n friendship
n y the hell they r saying bad about DMG, CHA jus look at ekta's serial its uther shit, any1 dies anyime n comes back also, few villan r there who has nothing 2 do in their life except running behind 2 people (main leads), these serial r far better than ekta's serial

plus those serial always has sadness scenes n dmg has fun,chilled out, funny scene
DMG ROCKS 👏
akaur thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#9
i dont agree with the article
do u really want 2 c diseases n illnesses on a daily bases?
soaps r 4 entertainment!
the pic is really nice
thanx 4 sharin
mads thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 17 years ago
#10
I agree wid the article..I mean..lets be honest..I kno tht 90% of the ppl ( including me of course ) watch DMG only coz of AR love story n nothin else.. 😆 😆 😳 but then, its also true tht as far as medical aspect is concerned..the serial doesnt evn hav 1% reality..take for example sister padma's brain tumour operation, armaan wandering off the corridors n treating patients without handkerchief wen suffering frm cold, n most imporatantly..interns not bothering to wear their lab-coats properly..leaving all the buttons open..!!

I mean..these are jus some of the many aspects..n if we come to think of it..each epi has some sort of blooper as far as medicine is concerned..so if u watch it frm the entertainment point of view, yes..its very entertaining.. 😃 😃 but not knowledgeable at all..

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".