ltelidevara thumbnail
Visit Streak 1000 Thumbnail Visit Streak 750 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 9 years ago
#1
Dev is wrong in hiding his relationship.He forgot that his relationship with his mother is not like any
Mother son duo. They shared their pain and happiness and lived for each other. They have come a
Long way to reach the position they have today.Dev never hid anything from her.He shared his business matters also with her case in point Gujral's deal. He freely discussed about Natasha and Iswari supported him when he chose her and also when he left her.Not even once he thought how much shock it will be for Iswari when she realises the truth. I wonder after confessing his love for Sonakshi what more he would want to know about her and vice versa. In the journey of their life they eventually know each other any way. They are supposedly madly in love with each other no? So it makes no difference even if they tell their families and get married.But hiding it just to spend moments with each other right under the nose of Iswari just too much. How can Dev be so mean to his mother?

If Dev wants to spend some more time atleast he should have let Sona tell her family and asked time to let his mother know about it.They would have happily let them spend together at their house.

I could never support Dev for what he did to Iswari.He is disloyal to a mother who believed him implicitly.I sympathise Iswari for the heartbreak her son gave her.
In the forth coming episodes it is said that Iswari won't let Sona take care of Dev when he falls ill.Why would Iswari oblige? Did her son tell her that Sona is his fiance ? No.Then how can she allow an outsider that also a girl take care of him? She is a nutritionist. Not a doctor. No mother will allow a girl nearer to her son,leave alone Iswari.If Dev revealed the truth then Iswari can be blamed. Not now.

I previously said Dev Dikshit's Charecter got butchered. I stick to that even now. Feel bad for Shaheer.

Created

Last reply

Replies

22

Views

2k

Users

17

Likes

179

Frequent Posters

M.soni thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#2
I dont think they are doing anything wrong...before damily melodrama and involvement ..they want to spend some time together ...to be with each other only...hiding relation at intial stage is not wrong...
And i would like to say u watch 1ooth episode of show...u will get u r answer that why is dev not ready to tell anyone...
aaliah3108 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#3
Feel bad for Shaheer... 😕 why... Sorry could not understand.
404_NotFound thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 9 years ago
#4
Lol... ..Ishwari is his mom not some girlfriend or wife that hiding his love is like betraying her...if this was true then half of the world has committed this mistake and all of them are characterless...
I respect your POV but but no matter what I cannot agree with you ...
Silambu thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago
#5
Dev is not wrong...he is just a human being.

Sorry, cannot agree with your viewpoints and Shaheer is doing a fantastic job as Dev till now.


Edited by Silambu - 9 years ago
Ferdous_69 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#6
Jab CV ne 100th episode main this million dollar question ka answer de diya tab kiyu Kuch log ek hi topic pe post banate hai ... Can't understand 🥱 🥱 ...
Nd feeling BAD for Shaheer 😲 😲 ...??????
BTW... Shaheer himself mentioned that he is very proud to be a part of this show...
So very very very happy for Shaheer...
sajinifaby thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 9 years ago
#7
For someone who has only lost more than gained.. you might not be able to relate to the character Dev is... He has the slightest idea of the most obnoxious feeling his mother carry towards him...
Beg your pardon, I totally disagree to the fact the Dev character is butchered... You are entitled to your own opinion and hold it close to your own self if that pleases you.. I'm sure it does...

Dev has not hid anything from his mom except this... imagine.. why? He is himself unsure of many things happening in his life all of a sudden.. and he needs time to settle down.. be it spending time with her.. or understanding relationships... but he told in the 100th episode.. the reason...
He does not want to share her with anyone else but him... after all mother's son he is..

Ishwari's problem is the same.. She cannot share him with anyone else...Natasha's case also she was not happy that he is getting married to her... And she readily accepted that he broke saying am with my son always..

How can you accept such a mother who lie to her son the real reason.. Are you cent person sure that she did it for her son.. NOT AT ALL.. she can't imagine to share him with anyone and that was the only reason.. (precap is sufficient enough to show us all.. what sort of bond she has with Dev)
Similarly Dev also said i did coz of what you told mom, wherein the real reason is his love to Sona..
They both always believe in pleasing the other...and never really understood the other (but atleast Dev had one point minus always..no belief to God.. and he was stubborn all the way)
Neither did Ishwari know about him eating sleeping pills.. nor does Dev know the extent to which Ishwari is obsessed with him.. and not like what he thinks that he is mom's favourite...

And you sympathise with Ishwari.. a mother who is partial herself and disowned neha.. even after things being so nice and well to do.. she still continued to love the attention and Godly devotion Dev gives her.. aadat ho gayi hai usko.. inn sabki...and she plainly ignored the others... all fair eh?

If your mom had pain regarding you unbelieving in a power like God, n finally if she see you take a step towards it.. will your mom not be happy - whatever be the reason...
Is that what you saw in last episode...???

She was okay Neha listening to Sona, and taking the dupatta of Ranveer.. moment she came to know Dev asked her to.. mood changed.. same way, why she can't accept that Sona could influence her son to doing what she only wanted... ??

If you feel Dev is wrong, Ishwari is way beyond wrong...
Love is such a feeling that you see the other person more than your own self...be it motherly... or sibling... or friends or for lovers...

I do not disapprove the fact that due to Dev's delay Sona is having to go through a lot... but he is also looking for a right moment to discuss this... and so Dev is not wrong...if he was... SONA would feel it more than you... 😉

JyotiBThakur thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 9 years ago
#8
I respect your point of view and thanks for sharing it with us.😊
But i think this topic has been discussed a lot of time earlier in the forum and all of the members who had doubt on why Dev is hiding his relationship from his mother was answered in the 100th episode itself. And Dev gave the answer to it.


First and the foremost thing. Dev don't discuss everything with his mother if you are following the show from the start. You must be aware, when it was about Neha's engagement that broke, Dev didn't tell his mother about Neha's conditions for the wedding. It was later that Ishwari ji came to know about it. And same was the case with Neha and Ranveer's relation. He didn't tell his mother before offering the job to Ranveer (Though Neha asked him not to tell her) and even when he wanted to gift new apartment to Ranveer he didn't tell his mother. And talking about the business, he only discussed about Gujrals to his mother, but not about any other business deal ever.

Gujrals were a different case. Becuase Mr. Gujral talked about the marriage proposal to Ishwari. Dev discussed about it with his mother. The yes, about Natasha he asked for Ishwari's help. But she refused and told him that it's the most important decision of his life and he has to take it on his own. Without her help. Then how on earth will he get a thought that he should talk to his mom about him and Sona. He's not aware of his mom's insecurities either.

In one of the episodes, he said you are always with me in all my decisions and i don't want anything else. And here Ishwari mom said i'll always be. Then what's the problem now. Sona is her son's choice. His love... And she know Sona well. She's a lovely girl and she likes her too. Its her possessiveness and insecurities about her place in Dev's life that's making her act rude towards Sona.

And you have already mentioned that Dev share the closest bond with his mom then why will he tell Sona to tell her parents about them, when he has not told Ishwari mom about it yet. Dev will never want to do that. Whenever he will decide to tell it to someone. The first person would be his mom.

And you said why they need to know each other after confessing love... Well my dear, they are in love... But when you are in love you surely want to know everything about each other... From where the question of getting married first and then getting to know each other with time came... They have all the right to spend time together, know eachother well and then decide on getting married. They are 2 mature and sensible people... There's no theory that confess your love, then go to your family and tell them, get the wedding dates fixed, get married and start knowing eachother. This actually sounds filmy.

These days couples do take time to know each other well and then decide on getting married. It's not that they don't want marriage. They surely want. But at present, want to spend quality time with each other, getting to know each other and exploring their feeling of love.

Dev gave the answer to your question in 100th episode itself. He don't know why is he hiding it from everyone. It's just that he don't want to tell it now. He fears to lose her. He don't want to share her love with anybody for now. Not even to his family. He want all her attention for sometimes. Eventually they have to tell the families... But for now she's only his.

And i don't find anything wrong in this. He want all her attention now. This is the first time, he has thought of his own happiness... He has someone in life, who's there to take care of him and who's taking his responsibility. For all these years, he was the one who was the pillar of strength and support of his family and still is. He is taking care of them. Fulfilling all his responsibility.

But here, Sona is his pillar of strength... She's his support system... He can talk about all his worries to her without even thinking. The Dev Dixit who never ever share his feeling to anyone and talk to her without thinking about the right and wrong and she accepts him the way he is. Don't he have a right to live for himself and have his lady love only for himself for sometime.

And for Dev's character, if after falling in love he was ignoring his mother or any of his responsibilities than i would have said that the character is butchered. But this is not the case... He's still the same Dev for his family... Still their pillar of strength. He still take care of the smallest things about his mother and is doing everything for his sister's happiness. This is the same Dev we love. Only difference is, now he is happy from within. He's in love and this Dev is the one who has started forgetting the troubled past and want to live in the present.


This is solely my POV.😊





HiTech thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#9
I dont think Dev is wrong. Ishwari's insecurities are wrong. Even with Natasha episode, Dev was quite open and the proposal came through Gujaral to Ishwari. Even then she was not happy, but was going with the flow. Because she thought, marriage with Natasha will help Dev grow...she knows that Dev takes decision thinking about others.
He asks her to help him make a decision regarding Natasha, but she says, it is your life changing decision and you have to take it yourself. And she was happy that the engagement was called off relieved not because Dev had made a decision for himself but her insecurities were pampered.
As a mother, Ishwari understood Dev well, but she did not know that he is lonely. He takes sleeping pills, he doesnt have anyone to speak to, etc. Now, he has taken a decision and is sure that Ishwari will support him, as she had told him in the past that she will be with him whatever decision he takes.

She feels so insecure about her son, that I am sure, her reaction would have been the same even if Dev has informed her first about his decision.
fanktlk thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#10


It's just finding the right time. Dev is also doing that.

Edited by fanktlk - 9 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".