TianaWrites thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 9 years ago
#1
Hello all, I know plenty of you here cannot tolerate Shagun... I know how horrid she was in the past but I couldn't help feeling sorry for her when I watched yesterday's episode... isn't it fair that she feels insecure? She didn't expect much when she stepped into Ishita's shoes 7 years ago but the Ballas especially Toshi gave her hope and made her feel secure and special in that family... Now that Ishita has come back... they have just reversed the roles...

I understand that Raman never really cared for Shagun.. so it is only fair that he doesn't think about her insecurities but the family who pretended to understand her so well doesn't once think about her insecurities? It is something I fail to understand. Why can't Toshi or any of the family who so wanted Shagun to be their bahu understand how it feels to be shown that you will get something and suddenly taken away from you just because someone else came back?

It is a pity... Now why wouldn't Shagun feel cheated?

Created

Last reply

Replies

14

Views

1.9k

Users

12

Likes

103

Frequent Posters

svati12 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#2
TOshiji ws getting shagun married jst bcz she ws being questioned as to wat is her position... faking marriage..
jst for shagun's respect..
bt she can never accept as her bahu...
she has never done anythng a bahu wud do..

ISHITA is ishita n dats ben proved tym n again..

Are her insecurities n life more important dn her child's life RUHI...??

whn pihu asked ishita to go away.. she didnt thought otherwise n decided to leave widout a second thought for her daughter pihu happiness..

bt ds shagun...
she wasnt an ounce happy wid news of ruhi might b alive.. n is jst keen for her security..
such woman dosnt deserve any pity or sympathy...

she deserves wat she is getting,...

had ishita ever kept adi ruhi away frm shagun..
or said dat she cant spend tym or meet dem... ANSWER is NO..
bt she is nt even allowing her to stand near her for a minute..even dat pihu wanted to b wid ishita for dat moment..

Shagun is dling al ds jst bcz she knws dat watevr she thinks is her is nt her... dat ws never her.. n vl never b her...
She is nt even a replacement...

so having pity on her n felling bad for a selfish person lyk her is out of question..

she jst knws hw to get her happiness by hook or crook..
even using d same child she nurtured for 7yrs is nt a big thing for her..
pihu is jst a pawn for her nw...

"main ruhi ke liye pray kyu karu.. uske liye log hai na pray karne ke liye.. muje khushi kyu hogi.. mian apni khushi dekhungi..."

I dnt think any mother wud ever think even if her daughter dosnt lyk her..
Her indiffernt behaviour towards ruhi n nt even an once she tried to talk to ruhi lyk a mother wud do.. nt even hugged her once...
She is nt a mother n can never b..

She dosnt deserve bhalla family.. n raman..
n nw even she has surpassed her right to b wid pihu too wid her selfishness...
A mother is never selfish for her child...she never uses her child..

So pihu is nt her child at al..


-Gan- thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: ...Tiana...

Hello all, I know plenty of you here cannot tolerate Shagun... I know how horrid she was in the past but I couldn't help feeling sorry for her when I watched yesterday's episode... isn't it fair that she feels insecure? She didn't expect much when she stepped into Ishita's shoes 7 years ago but the Ballas especially Toshi gave her hope and made her feel secure and special in that family... Now that Ishita has come back... they have just reversed the roles...

I understand that Raman never really cared for Shagun.. so it is only fair that he doesn't think about her insecurities but the family who pretended to understand her so well doesn't once think about her insecurities? It is something I fail to understand. Why can't Toshi or any of the family who so wanted Shagun to be their bahu understand how it feels to be shown that you will get something and suddenly taken away from you just because someone else came back?

It is a pity... Now why wouldn't Shagun feel cheated?



Your answer lies in your post itself..if Raman doesn't care about Shagun where is she cheated ? her incesurity is not because of how Bhallas and others reversed.. I think it's more so because she knows that other than Pihu she really doesn't have anything to call her own there..and she's afraid she might lose Pihu yo Ishita if Ishita is in close proximity to Pihu. Even her biological son wants his Ishima abd Papa together because he like the rest of the Bhallas know how much Ishita and Raman still love each other .. And like Shagun they are also looking at their own interest, Raman's happiness.

Ishita never fights for herself, others do.. While Shagun only cares only about her own interest.. For heavesn's sake the woman found her own biological child, Ruhi's return inconvenient as it left her pheres incomplete... And since then have stayed away from anything to do with Ruhi. So had it been someone else, I would have felt bad... Shagun tries so hard to milk any situation to her own benefit.. It doesn't leave any room for any sympathy for her..

nicegul thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#4
sorry dear I don't agreei dont feel pity on shagun as she is getting what she deserved...and thr is no comparison between ishita's love for ruhi and shagun's love for pihu ishita loved ruhi selflessly she never cared about herself or her place in Raman's life when she married him for ruhi's sake she has always taught ruhi good about her shagun mumma that shagun loves her too but on contrary shagun's love is selfish she didn't even told pihu the truth about her real mother forget about telling something good about ishita instead she instigated her against ishita saying that haar wali aunty will take you away from your family is this what you call that shagun really loves pihu even in yesterday's epi she was more concerned about herself and her place in Raman's life mera kya hoga she didn't said meri pihu ka kya hoga mere bina...her insecurities are more about herself than the fear of loosing pihu
--QUEEN-- thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 3

IshRa's Icons

Posted: 9 years ago
#5
When bhallas asked her to marry Raman, she herself confessed that she wanna marry Raman to set his shattered life.
Now ishita is back, and shagun knew very well that ishita can make Raman's life more beautiful than she could ever think of. So now she changed her decision that she's marrying pihu ke liye. If tomorrow pihu agrees for ishra marriage then she'll have some other reason. Finally she wanna get married to Raman at any cost. So the abla naari get up of past seven years was bakwaas. First give then take is the policy. Let her think of others happiness atleast once like our FL, then I'll think about sympathy for her😆
People who have no consistency can never like happy, however the things may be.
Edited by kingmanu - 9 years ago
megha2227 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#6
Shagun for once never cared for anyone. Her taking care of pihu is all for her own selfish reasons, her obsession towards raman and trying to imitate ishita so that people start loving her. She needs attention. Period! But she failed to realize that loving others can only bring her the love and attention she needs. I fail to see her love to pihu. If it's true, she would have let pihu free. True love will always come back to you know matter what. So she is not even sure of how strong her love is towards pihu, which is letting her to hold the bonds strong.
She build a beautiful castle around her with ashok with all the luxurious she wished, breaking a beautiful family into pieces. And then later she realize ishita is having a life so loved by everyone and better than her. Great that she didn't try to break the bond ishita has with her family after her n number of attempts to and settled back accepting manoj. But then she has got a hope to get back what ishita has (the one she wanted to ) and started to imitate ishita more than she did. And so she accepted pihu, and her family ( shagun: remember ishita doing
the same?) But what failed? She didn't realize that caring and loving others will actually help her to get the love she carved for and not being self centered. Is that even a insecurity for us to pity that @she doesn't even want ruhi to be back for her own selfish reasons?
Edited by megha2227 - 9 years ago
-Silencia- thumbnail
21st Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: ...Tiana...

Hello all, I know plenty of you here cannot tolerate Shagun... I know how horrid she was in the past but I couldn't help feeling sorry for her when I watched yesterday's episode... isn't it fair that she feels insecure? She didn't expect much when she stepped into Ishita's shoes 7 years ago but the Ballas especially Toshi gave her hope and made her feel secure and special in that family... Now that Ishita has come back... they have just reversed the roles...

I understand that Raman never really cared for Shagun.. so it is only fair that he doesn't think about her insecurities but the family who pretended to understand her so well doesn't once think about her insecurities? It is something I fail to understand. Why can't Toshi or any of the family who so wanted Shagun to be their bahu understand how it feels to be shown that you will get something and suddenly taken away from you just because someone else came back?

It is a pity... Now why wouldn't Shagun feel cheated?


Hello there, I am one of those who cannot tolerate Shagun for obvious reasons 😊 and as a female, I also understand where you are coming from, especially the piece in bold.

The reason why nobody is paying heed to Shagun's insecurities is not just because Ishita came back. It is because of a much, much, much larger problem, which everyone else can see, but alas Shagun cannot.

The cause for which everyone is fighting together is Ruhi's comeback. Their little girl who was taken away for 7 long years, tortured and brainwashed, and hurt so bad, that she has now gone against her entire family, including the parents who doted on her. In such a scenario, which issue requires more importance and pro-active consideration - Ruhi to be saved from Niddhi, or Shagun's insecurities for a position she never truly had in the first place, and was only filing in, in Ishita's absence?

On top of that, Shagun, blinded by her own insecurities, not only fails to understand the primary reason behind everyone's motive, but also fails to see the plight of her own biological daughter. Had she been more humane towards a child who needs to be rescued and protected and loved, even if she wasn't her daughter, had she stood right next to Raman or the family in bringing Ruhi back home, who knows, her true goodness might have been valued, and the family, if nothing more, would at least feel fer insecurities. Her own son, yesterday, pointed out brilliantly, that she doesn't think about anyone else, but herself. Yes, it is ok to be selfish and to think about one's own self, but not at the cost of a kid's life which might get ruined by one's own vested interests.

In addition, yes, the family members, in the past, wanted to make her their bahu, but only because they thought she needed that legal obligation, a name to the relationship she shares with them, and more importantly, because they believed Ishita was dead and there would be nobody to care for Raman or the kids in the years to come. But would you force a horse to still drink cola to quench his long-pending thirst, if you knew water was around somewhere?

It would indeed have been pitiful and sympathetic, had she tried to balance her insecurities with the human being inside of her, and care a tiny bit more for Ruhi than her own self. Hence, you wouldn't see much support for her from people here, despite most of us being women 😊

Edited by -Nidoo- - 9 years ago
Sri1091 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#8
Y shld we feel pity for Shagun??? Didn't Mihir and adi tried their level best to say dat Raman will never give ishita's place to anyone else?? She was adamant and delusional dat she will marry Raman for ishita and pihu's happiness like really??
She lost it all wen she used Pihu as pawn to keep ishita away for her selfishness and watever she said to Mihir she didn't want Ruhi to be alive for her selfish reasons and yest she was like Ruhi Pihu adi Raman and her will be a happy family if Raman marries her and dey will not be any complications she is one self centric women who cannot think beyond herself den y shld anyone feel pity for her?
ItsNoorfatima thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#9
Pity for shagun? ??
Are you kidding me 🤣
Ramyalaxmi thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#10
Well from this survey of small sample population it's clear that CVs have to work very hard and degrade ishra more to gain sympathy for their favourite lead.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".