Deepika as Piku or Sonam as Neerja??

Okay so Neerja was a beautiful movie and so was Piku.
I found Piku better as a movie overall, and while the other co-stars fared better than both Sonam and Deepika in respective movies.


Still Deepika gave a very refreshing and calm performance in Piku, while Sonam finally gained the respect with Neerja.

So which performance do you think was better?
I personally found Deepika's Piki better.

I have not seen PIKU but I have seen NEERJA just yesterday.

Neerja was a good film. The actors playing the terrorists were exceptionally good which made the film that more believable and intense. I think Sonam was able to work off their acting.

Shame they did not get their dues and bollywood should make more films like Neerja.More realistic.

Originally posted by: ThugLeader

Still Deepika gave a very refreshing and calm performance in Piku, while Sonam finally gained the respect with Neerja.

.

For me everything Cocktail and after has proved Deepikapadukone as a fabulous actress. Every film post Cocktail she's done a phenomenal job in. She's already at the top position for me.


As far as Sonam is concerned. She unfortunately has never 'wowed' me with her performances. Shea come off as a terrible actress. Which is why the success of Neerja and the amount of respect and praise she has gained out of it is huge. She did an amazing job portraying the character of Neerja. When you have to portray a real life character on screen it is so difficult and you have to portray it with so much perfection because this is a story of a real person and not some fictional character. Sonam deserves this success, this respect, and this praise.


So as much as I love Deepika and will continue to do so, Neerja stole my heart. Sonam delivered in this movie! And she delivered well!

Sonam for Neerja.

Originally posted by: -cuteee.tigress

Sonam for Neerja.

Piku was maha boring and I found DP's acting average as always but Sonam had some great highlights in Neerja where she emoted very well. There was a certain tenderness with which she played that strong role and it was beautiful.

finally koi toh mili jisse piku boring lagti hai. I have heard so much praise about piku, but when I saw it., found it really boring. i will not say its a bad film,, its good but boring

People are only connecting to Sonam because of NEERJA and NEERJA's story. Her performance itself was underwhelming

Originally posted by: Shaitan-Haiwan

People are only connecting to Sonam because of NEERJA and NEERJA's story. Her performance itself was underwhelming

If we strictly look at Sonam's performance in Neerja, she didnt really do anything great and there were a number of scenes where she did not deliver! Sorry but thats the truth.

And I find Piku ridiculously overrated too. Nothing special in that.

I need your opinion in this thread:
http://www.india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=4634366&TPN=4&#p134081492

Piku is really overrated
I actually get bored from half way and too loud for me. More than piku I like bewakoofiyan which has also father and daughter story and its also yrf production even the house of piku is same there's.
As far sonam concerned she was great in neerha and neerja Is one of the well made movie of the year till now all biopics releases neerja I leading the pack