It is Dida or Thakurma and Not Dadi

JuhiR thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#1
Hello CVs,
In Bengali Dad's mom is 'Thakurma' or 'Thamma' in short. Mom's mother is 'Dida'. Hope you can correct it next time.

Created

Last reply

Replies

7

Views

5.3k

Users

4

Likes

8

Frequent Posters

Morana thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 9 years ago
#2
To be honest for a family that has settled in Delhi for a long time I think that's perfectly ok , they're supposed to be quite removed from Bengali culture as it is in a lot of ways , be it their life style or diction, or day to day behavior.
My cousin bro has done his higher studies in Nepal n was studying medical in Kathmandu medical college and he's become much more attuned to the culture of Nepal than of Bengal. So I don't think any correction is needed. 😊
Edited by AnnaPaquinFan - 9 years ago
JuhiR thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: AnnaPaquinFan

To be honest for a family that has settled in Delhi for a long time I think that's perfectly ok , they're supposed to be quite removed from Bengali culture as it is in a lot of ways , be it their life style or diction, or day to day behavior.

My cousin bro has done his higher studies in Nepal n was studying medical in Kathmandu medical college and he's become much more attuned to the culture of Nepal than of Bengal. So I don't think any correction is needed. 😊


Well they are using Maa, Baba, Dada, so Thamma sounds more authentic.

Morana thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 9 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: JuhiRockz


Well they are using Maa, Baba, Dada, so Thamma sounds more authentic.

Okay , so during the era of Mahabharat n Ramayan people didn't use to talk in Sudh Hindi do they ?? We all know Sanskrit was their language but we can't see them talking in it in tv shows because it's not practical.
Thanks to different tv shows n movies main stream viewers are used to words like Maa Baba Dada , but thamma is some thing that may not sound known to them.
Plus they're not making an effort to show a pure Bengali family , it's just shows that the family has retained some of Bengali culture though the younger generation of children in the house has grown up removed from contact with Bengali society.
It's supposed to be a mix n match in their family , where parents are more Bengali than the kids probably they'd been to Bengal for a longer time. To be honest the Roys who are supposed to be Bengali family looked to me as non-Bengali as possible and that's perfectly logical, just like I've seen many non-bengali families appearing like almost Bengalies in Kolkata. It's just acclimatization.
Edited by AnnaPaquinFan - 9 years ago
Bolly*_Crazed thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#5
I don't think we should be so nit picky about such things.
As a Punjabi, if I could count the number of times a show has claimed a family was Punjabi and then continued to have them speak ONLY Hindi I would run out of fingers 😆

It's not a big deal.
JuhiR thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: AnnaPaquinFan

Okay , so during the era of Mahabharat n Ramayan people didn't use to talk in Sudh Hindi do they ?? We all know Sanskrit was their language but we can't see them talking in it in tv shows because it's not practical.
Thanks to different tv shows n movies main stream viewers are used to words like Maa Baba Dada , but thamma is some thing that may not sound known to them.
Plus they're not making an effort to show a pure Bengali family , it's just shows that the family has retained some of Bengali culture though the younger generation of children in the house has grown up removed from contact with Bengali society.
It's supposed to be a mix n match in their family , where parents are more Bengali than the kids probably they'd been to Bengal for a longer time. To be honest the Roys who are supposed to be Bengali family looked to me as non-Bengali as possible and that's perfectly logical, just like I've seen many non-bengali families appearing like almost Bengalies in Kolkata. It's just acclimatization.


For those who are not familiar with Bengali, Thamma or Thami is quite modern and contemporary. Even NRI kids call their grandma Thammi or Dida or Didun. 'Thamma' or 'Thami' or 'Dida' is not from age of Mahabharata. And Roys are shown as very much a typical Bengali family. The way the mother and grandama are dressed and the way they do slogan shouting 'cholbe na cholbe na' (which rarely happens in Bengali family) and the way the dad makes luchi aaloor dam which is typical Bengali dish so CVs are trying to portray them as an authentic Bengali family only. If they were not authentic Bengali , Sona will not use the word 'Abhadra'. It is a very typical Bengali word.

I still will stick to my request of changing Dadi. NO Bengali calls their grandma Dadi. Sorry! I have lot of friends and cousins who grew up in Chittaranjan Park in Delhi. Bengalis are very proud of their language and culture. They will never use Dadi.

And in every TV show we hear 'Bhabo', 'Aayi', 'Aajiamma' etc just to make it sound authentic. So why not 'Thami' or 'Didun' or 'Dida'?
Morana thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 9 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: JuhiRockz


For those who are not familiar with Bengali, Thamma or Thami is quite modern and contemporary. Even NRI kids call their grandma Thammi or Dida or Didun. 'Thamma' or 'Thami' or 'Dida' is not from age of Mahabharata. And Roys are shown as very much a typical Bengali family. The way the mother and grandama are dressed and the way they do slogan shouting 'cholbe na cholbe na' (which rarely happens in Bengali family) and the way the dad makes luchi aaloor dam which is typical Bengali dish so CVs are trying to portray them as an authentic Bengali family only. If they were not authentic Bengali , Sona will not use the word 'Abhadra'. It is a very typical Bengali word.

I still will stick to my request of changing Dadi. NO Bengali calls their grandma Dadi. Sorry! I have lot of friends and cousins who grew up in Chittaranjan Park in Delhi. Bengalis are very proud of their language and culture. They will never use Dadi.

And in every TV show we hear 'Bhabo', 'Aayi', 'Aajiamma' etc just to make it sound authentic. So why not 'Thami' or 'Didun' or 'Dida'?

@Bold, you're confusing Roys with the Bose family ! 😆 I said Roy not Bose.
And nope the CVs are not at all trying to portray them as true blue Bengali families and it's not that all Bengalis retain the pure Bengali culture once they settle outside of Bengal for good , it's just not possible always.
That's exactly why Sona's and her brother's bengali diction, which I agree is very bad, doesn't bother me in the least , it's almost a pleasant surprize that they kids in the family are at all talking in Bengali , I've quite a few NRI relatives and the younger generation doesn't know a single word of Bengali though they do attend Bengali festivals like Durga Puja held abroad . I'm not talking about whether it's wrong or right , all I say is it's perfectly normal n even expected.
So I'm not at all bothered about any of it, not about Sona's diction and not about Dadi instead of Thamma . And therefore I don't either share your concern nor I agree with any thing you said. 😳
To each her own i guess. And CVs shouldn't change anything IMO.
attiya1.3 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#8
Its a beautiful show...
So i think we should avoid these things...dadi bulaye..bengali thek na bolay...ya doctor bola jaye...its a drama and there will be flaws to some extent...😛

Just my opinion

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".