..Aarti.. thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#1

We human beings have a cruel sense of humour. We always tend to laugh at the most sensitive of issues, at someone's misery or someone's shortcomings. It is no wonder that most of our jokes are about physically or mentally challenged people who have no control over these unfortunate circumstances.

The humour in our entertainment has been replete with such sequences. It is very rare to see comic moments in movies that do not in any way ridicule any kind of people, race or religion. An excellent instance of a deviation from the normal, cruel and often extremely derogatory jokes was the movie Rang De Basanti. It had several light moments that may not have cracked you up, but definitely would have made you laugh. Situational comedy is a lost art in our media now.

In our very dear DMG, I have always been slightly miffed with the entire Sister Lovely-Atul track. However the person may be placed in terms of appearance, stature or intellect, the emotions are as real and as intense of those who maybe better situated in terms of the superficial standards of the world!! In that vein, it is indeed very obnoxious to use an overweight, albeit nice person, and her feelings to invoke laughter among a group of people who think obesity is worthy of ridicule. Why have I not spoken against this politically incorrect sense of humour is because I too made an error in judgment, dismissing it as an ancillary story line that need not get too much importance.

But now the use of Atul's feelings for Anjali in a similar manner is pushing my buttons too far!! True, Atul may not score the same as Anjali on a suaveness meter, she is debonair, confident, a woman of the classes. He, on the other hand, is a cute, adorable guy, of(f) the masses, who lacks the chic finish and polish of Anjali. He lacks confidence, thinks local road side cuisine is perfect for a date, while she shirks even Chinese food and prefers the more socially sophisticated Italian palate.

I am definitely not assigning merit to either character. But in defence of Atul he is emotionally twice the person Anjali is. Sensitive, caring and definitely more aware, he does not deserve this portrayal of a bumbling fool, aiming too high with his love and ardor.

Aren't 'disadvantaged' people as prone to real emotions as the rest of us? Is the pain and longing of Lovely or Atul any less than what the more socially, intellectually and visually privileged feel? Love is a visceral feeling which biologically and emotionally elicits identical responses in whoever has had the pleasure or misfortune of experiencing it. It is a chemical reaction not very different from a hunger response or a reaction to pain.

Why is the love of those who fit our moulds of the stereotypical hero and heroine more significant or more worthy of solemn treatment, while that of the others relegated to something worse than negligence (which by me is still acceptable) like ridicule. Are we that starved as an intelligent, conscientious, thinking people that we need such cruel forms of humour?

A point to ponder….

Created

Last reply

Replies

85

Views

4k

Users

15

Likes

1

Frequent Posters

sareeta thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#2
Oh dear me... finally a post that actually brought forth that insensitive track of Lovely and Atul and ridiculing their emotions in the name of humor...

While Armaan gazed like a puppy eyed love stuck boy at Ridhima... everyone went gaga over him and whispered how cute.... and now when Atul or Lovely does that, we find it funny and what got me irritated is Armaan himself, smirks looking at Atul do that... why,..?? Wasnt he doing the same thing a few days ago.. acting like a love sick puppy.. It irked the hell outta me to see Armaan smirk like that ... at Atul...

Jus my 2 cents...
dhvanisoni thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#3
yeah i get wht u r saying...Atul and Lovely both r kinda similar ...as lovely longs for atul's love but she is laughed at cuz of her obesity and same thing goes with Atul...remember Armaan saidd to Atul in yesterday's episode thtt"woh tere level ki nahi" or somthing lik tht...he meant tht Ayul was aiming too high...and tht true too cuz Anjali doesnot even bother abt Atul...same goes with Lovely...Atul runs away from her....by the way I liked reading it....
AreYaar thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#4
Beautiful Beautiful post, Aarti!!! 👏

I've been thinking on those lines myself for a while...and you've penned down these thoughts so well!!

You know, I was thinking...it's so interesting that on one hand...everyone's perfectly ok with making a joke out of Lovely's affection for Atul...we all laugh about it...but on the other hand, when the same thing happens to Atul via Anjali...we feel so bad for him ...Somewhat ironical, i feel.

But yeah, the general point you've made is so true! In all the shows that are on air right now...all we see are the so called "perfect" people falling in love with each other...noone really thinks about the other end of the spectrum...the people who may not be as dazzling in looks and personality, but still have something special about them regardless!

Which is why...I've been harboring great hopes from the Atul-Angie love story cuz it would truly be something genuinely different and touching 😳 😳

Aarti, I especially love the last paragraph...the last line in particular...Food for thought, indeed! 👏 👏
prap thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#5
I see what you mean. Yet, throughout the show, Atul's character has never been portrayed as someone to be taken seriously. The way he keeps on talking about his landlady, about his plants, the way he randomly bursts out singing... his every single trait makes him a topic of laugh among his friends... that's what his friends are used to doing... laughing off everything he says.. he's never been taken seriously... so i think the reason armaan smirks is not because he thinks atul is not capable of loving, but because he doesn't think atul is serious... he is not making fun of atul, he is just playing with him... that's how his usual interaction with atul is... but he does trust atul with his judgment... he goest to atul everytime he needs some advice....

vaarti, about what you said,i think you're right... in movies.. in serials, it is a general conception that obesity and love do not go together... love only comes with beauty... yet, some shows like jassi jaisi koi nahin have tried to diverge from the trend and take a different path but for some reason, they find themselves incapable of staying on the path too long.. they had to make jassi beautiful before she got her real love... however, armaan did realize that he loved jassi before he saw the new, beautiful jassi....
AreYaar thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#6
@Sareeta: Arey yaar, I think Armaan only meant that in good humor 😉 😆 😆...That's just the bonding the two buddies share...you know that Atul would do the same the moment he found about AR, wouldn't he? 😆 😆 😆
sareeta thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#7
^^ Anu, I dont particularly agree on this aspect... agar ham apne emotions ki chaahte hai log kadar kare..toh no matter what we need to learn to respect theirs too... and Armaan sure seemed to in that one moment defied that basic expectation and even when he mentioned the bit about tere level ki nahin hai... a more sensitive approach could have been more appreciated... and notice Armaan's expressions when Atul goes all puppy eyed... its like Armaan has never seen anyone do that... It irks the freaking hell outta me...
Male bonding and all the buddy bonding et all is fine... he likes atul is all for his love... but well... those smirks sure need to be wiped off... they have a more of a mocking shade to them...
..Aarti.. thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: sareeta

Oh dear me... finally a post that actually brought forth that insensitive track of Lovely and Atul and ridiculing their emotions in the name of humor...

While Armaan gazed like a puppy eyed love stuck boy at Ridhima... everyone went gaga over him and whispered how cute.... and now when Atul or Lovely does that, we find it funny and what got me irritated is Armaan himself, smirks looking at Atul do that... why,..?? Wasnt he doing the same thing a few days ago.. acting like a love sick puppy.. It irked the hell outta me to see Armaan smirk like that ... at Atul...

Jus my 2 cents...

to quote asterix....zigackly!!!! why is armaan's love filled gaze worthy of our attention while that of atul or lovely just worthy of our laughs....

i wondered if i was being too controversial here. glad more people are sensitive to such issues!!!

did we not find the fights between armaan and ridz funny? why can't we havesomething more like that for humour?

and why not something like anjali falling for atul and her strong personality scaring atul and some funny moments from that? why is always the underdog who has to be laughed at? we could laugh at anjali trying to bulldoze atul into falling in love with her...

Edited by vaarti - 18 years ago
AreYaar thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#9
@Sareeta: but hasn't that been a part of Armaan's personality always?? He uses the same mocking smiles in almost every situation with Ridz too...I think that's just the way he is...You know, one of those ppl who are unconsciously insensitive...but don't really mean it in a bad way? Am I making any sense? 😆 😆 😆

The thing I've noticed with his character is that he always has to maintain his facade of "coolness" which is probably why he behaves with Atul in such varied ways...when asking him for advice, totally different...and when he sees a chance to make fun of him...back to prankster mode 😉

Actually, I personally really enjoy the smirks that Armaan gives Atul when he's going all moony over Angie 😆 😆...cuz to me, it appears to be good natured ribbing b/w friends...

but I do agree with the part about Armaan being kinda insensitive with the whole "tere level ki nahin hai" line...but then Atul wasn't exactly a doormat either with his retort 😉....So I think their relationship is such that they enjoy putting each other down whenever they can 😆
..Aarti.. thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#10
@ prap...atul's issues are real ones. being a paying guest in mumbai is no joke. ask me...and his environmenatl concerns are very relevant too. he just puts a good spin on things cos that's his nature. an adopted child of a father who succumbed to AIDS very early in his life, orphaned all over again, humour is his defence against the cruelties of life. not unlike our dear chandler from friends. but his feelings and concerns are real, sometimes more than those of others...

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".