enness thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#1
Disclaimer - this post has NOTHING to do with the whole offscreen drama that was...and is...KYY. By that I mean cast trolling, fan wars, allegations et all. It's purely a reaction to the creative aspects of the show.
Happened to listen to a part of a new Niti IV, where she actually said that Karishma was a fabulous creative head, who opened the story lines for all characters etc., that she was the one who sent appreciation if anyone did well...and Niti had never got that before.
I am seriously struggling to reconcile this with what WE saw as output...if Karishma was that good and involved, why did we see such crap in S2 ?? Infact to me, the other characters kept getting more and more pointless...am I delusional?? Made me stop and think - that if the cast and CVs actually even understood what the audience liked in S1, and what was needed in S2.
Niti was brilliant in S1...and in S2 everyone including both leads became sooo obviously disinterested, esp after Parth's comeback. So where was Karishma then?? I don't know about Richa Yamini's motivation tactics...but one thing is for sure...she managed to bring the best out of the cast. Which is why was very disappointed wth the iv.

Why am I writing this when it clearly is a moot point...well, had hoped for a decent ending but even that was sooo screwed up...onscreen as well as offscreen...so needed ranting space. Please don't make this about any one fan faction... I loved the original show, and it has been a very frustrating journey to see it die a slow, painful death, all thanks to politics, petty differences and immaturity.
Edited by enness - 9 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

63

Views

9.6k

Users

26

Likes

710

Frequent Posters

BrightNSparkle thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#2
Really RY mam might not have done those appreciation directly, but she made all the audience appreciate their work. People loved all the characters head over heels.
S2 really lost its charm and they could not really pull the charm. Even after Parth came back they did not know how to take the story further. Really butchered many beautiful memories. We can't even compare the fairy tale S1 to S2. The damage which they made was beyond repair.

We all did not want the show to end in S1, but in S2 finally we all were forced to get a HEA as soon as possible.
Edited by Sidhaarthi - 9 years ago
hav6587 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#3
Karisma had nothing to do after parth's cenack ...I guess just at the most few episodes ...she was no more cv of kyy ...she even made a tweet regarding it ...most of the parth of kyy and the ending of s2 was some others job ...she even cleared this ..when few fans were bashing her she said cheers and celebrate but they r not my episodes and I'm no more a part of kyy
AreYaar thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: enness

Disclaimer - this post has NOTHING to do with the whole offscreen drama that was...and is...KYY. By that I mean cast trolling, fan wars, allegations et all. It's purely a reaction to the creative aspects of the show.

Happened to listen to a part of a new Niti IV, where she actually said that Karishma was a fabulous creative head, who opened the story lines for all characters etc., that she was the one who sent appreciation if anyone did well...and Niti had never got that before.

I am seriously struggling to reconcile this with what WE saw as output...if Karishma was that good and involved, why did we see such crap in S2 ?? Infact to me, the other characters kept getting more and more pointless...am I delusional?? Made me stop and think - that if the cast and CVs actually even understood what the audience liked in S1, and what was needed in S2.
Niti was brilliant in S1...and in S2 everyone including both leads became sooo obviously disinterested, esp after Parth's comeback. So where was Karishma then?? I don't know about Richa Yamini's motivation tactics...but one thing is for sure...she managed to bring the best out of the cast. Which is why was very disappointed wth the iv.

Why am I writing this when it clearly is a moot point...well, had hoped for a decent ending but even that was sooo screwed up...onscreen as well as offscreen...so needed ranting space. Please don't make this about any one fan faction... I loved the original show, and it has been a very frustrating journey to see it die a slow, painful death, all thanks to politics, petty differences and immaturity.


So is Niti actually saying that season 1 creatives never appreciated her? 😆

And Karishma a fabulous creative head? 🤣 Oh boy...I never knew Niti was this delusional about story/screenplay. This is all seperate from offscreen mess...if she isn't even able to objectively see how pathetic the storylines were in season 2, then truly all the best to her for her future choices...😆 She's not a kid in a candy shop that whoever gives her the most lollypops is automatically the best person. This is about objective evaluation of a show.
Suma1973 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#5
Sorry to disagree with u ppl .season 1is excellent but s2wasnt bad it was in different line ya only till Manik returned.if the same show wid different cast it would have been a great story .A good story of. girl power.of course I don't like it as a continuation of kyy s1 coz it made me miserable missing fab5fun Cabir Navya friendships above all my dearest Manan.if seen it as a different show it was good .Though Richa yami was a super CV.Karishma wasn't bad just that we couldn't accept it as kyys2.hope u guys hit my pov.just think in that line .coz I saw good fans of Niti bashing her.so have bit broader perspective and think.
sunnymunny thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#6
Check her new tweet
Have made a post avt it
ParthForeverRia thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#7
haha Niti told after Karishma gone,tvt went down.and Karishma was good bcz all was getting screen space...then mujhe creative head bana lete.mein sabko 5 mins de deta,all could have showed their "kalakari" and I would have become the mahan best creative 🤣
spnfan thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Most Posts (July 2022) Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 9 years ago
#8
Actually s2 starting, was good if.we forget about manan...my friends who didnt.watch s1 was.fine.with s2 and they liked it... Its.not karsihma's.fault that we were.too much in love.with manan and its next to.impossible to see niti without parth as nandini... She.did gave screen space.to every character.in s2... Also it was not karishma's.fault that partg and Ayaz left... All these happened.due to parth and Vikas.but everyone except them got bashed.at that time esp niti... We also cannot deny that after sometimes in s1 nandu's character had no growth and only manik was given importance...
Karishma left after parth's comeback...

Also stop finding fault in everything and.anything niti does or says... She was the only one who was genuinely sad that kyy was ending... Just like everyone here has an opinion she also has one... Maybe richa.was.not close to niti and she.felt connected.to karishma... How do we know wheather richa appreciated niti or not???
hav6587 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: ParthForeverRia

haha Niti told after Karishma gone,tvt went down.and Karishma was good bcz all was getting screen space...then mujhe creative head bana lete.mein sabko 5 mins de deta,all could have showed their "kalakari" and I would have become the mahan best creative🤣


I think u need to check the iv again niti never said after karisma left tvp went down...
AreYaar thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#10
LOL the people actually defending season 2... are ppl seriously deliberately being obtuse to the terrible execution?

This isn't just so simple as to blame it on season 1 being MaNan-centric...there is no harm in opening up new storylines provided you have good actors and competent execution...they FAILED...SPECTACULARLY failed on that count when they had laughable acting from Maddy and Arya and random tracks for most of the characters...execution MATTERS.


TRPs were up and down in season 1 anyways...lol for Niti to use that as an excuse to justify that season 2 was an improvement is hilarious.

She is very much welcome to her own biases for her own reasons but that won't change the facts on the ground vis a vis how the scenes were executed and a crappy execution can't be overlooked simply cuz you love your new creative.


She fails to realize that season 1 made Nandini Murthy and to venerate Karishma, she has forgotten Nandini's original characterization.


First time I'm seeing this...most other shows, people value their roots, their beginnings...what made the show...here it's the opposite...lol ppl want to pretend like season 1 didn't exist cuz season 2 supposedly had ppl giving them more chocolates.
Edited by AreYaar - 9 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".