Niti iv - Karishma?? - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

63

Views

9.6k

Users

26

Likes

710

Frequent Posters

pranjali98 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#11
Niti aj accha nahi kia.she fought with the same fan today who is a Manan fan.loves both equally..just for criticising her on her karishma thing(that was actually so funny to me,Karishma was the worst thing of ky2)..she gave her the tag of hater..even she made VM for Niti on her birthday with shahid's one and Niti saw this also.as far I understood Niti,she can't bear any bit of bashing..she today said she gets the most bashing among ky2 cast.that's also not true..when she will learn how this world is,she will become a woman from a child doll
my pov.no argue.#OkThnxBye
AreYaar thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: -siyali-

Niti's comment is not about which season was better, nor about what the fans liked, rather its about what an actor (Niti) thought about the show, her work, how her co-stars also got equal opportunity to showcase their talent and how their work was appreciated among each other. There's a fine line between an actor's perceptive to the show vs how a fan perceives the show...



An actor is welcome to her own perceptions but when there is suchhh a wide gap in perception b/w how you view your work and how the audience views it, surely there is a problem...it's almost like they were making their own show in their head and didn't care how the execution looked.

And even on the perception count, I don't agree with her statements...she's making it sound like the other characters had NO good storylines in season 1 and that is also incorrect...I would say any storyline Navya got in season 1 has to be better than her baby being sold online on OLX.

Season 1 actually had interconnected stoylines b/w the characters...Mukti-Harshad-Navya, Alya-Dhruv-Manik etc. etc...season 2 was an utter joke on that count cuz they did not have compelling storylines and on top of that some pathetic acting and direction made things worse.
charminggenie thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#13
Nandini Moorthy was created in S1 , she won't have been this big or this popular had it not been for that one S1. She was so powerful that she changed the anchor of the show , moved it from feb5 to MaNan and herself. She became the narrator of the show and someone we fought to defend all the time. Niti played her brilliantly but it was S1 team , precisely Richa , who let her play the ball. Yes MaNan were the core story , because Nandini and Manik rose beyond the show's basic elements.
But guess, who cares, there are shiny diamonds and lollpops to fight over that we dismiss and negate what created S2. You won't have had S2 had it not been or the brilliance of S1.

Yes , she has full right to state her opinion but so is the right of the audience to reject/embrace what they want and also to question her opinon given it was made on a public platform.

S2- i don't even want to sit and show the flaws . Opened the track for others"? Are you kidding me . OLX sale of a baby- enough said. So what were Homosexuality, Teen pregnancy and more . Sigh..I just should stop dissing it because not worth it.

Conveniently the blame-game falls on the fans na- coz they bashed, they didn't "support" what about the failed execution and bad acting of S2 . My opinion- Niti herself dropped the ball in S2 as far as acting is concerned. But who would take accountability for that eh?


Pretty sad that people cannot even appreciate and respect what made them . Throwing someone's work of 245 episodes for a shiny little toy , Nice. And then whine about why nobody loves me and I get criticized. Heck anyone from the cast/crew damaged Nandini was bashed so badly..heck her co-star bore the brunt for being obtuse about MaNan In S1.

TRPs eh? Haha, I am sure someone will fetch up the data..last leg of S1 was run by Karishma btw..product placement and failed handling. Nice.

Merger, FC ..RY handled that not by making her actors defend her but by respecting her audience and making amends.

But why bother, this cast is smoking a serious pot.


But cannot help but wonder, what would have happened had someone else dared to make this statement.
shahz thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#14
Maybe on paper it all looked good but the end result wasn't.
I felt Niti was damn annoyed cuz we didn't give S2 a chance..But she has to understand that we watch for entertainment and that was something we weren't getting.
Even if we ignored MaNan it still made zero sense.
All we saw was random scenes that didn't fit Nandini's continues crying and forced tashans.
I'm sorry but what ever Niti's opinion may be but Karishma was not anywhere near as creative as Richa.
And season 2 was a disaster especially that 1st month.
Wish they had ended it with season 1 bit then again we did get a handful of sweet MaNan scenes in s2 so shouldn't complain.
But as far as everything else goes S2 was epic failure.
blazingflame thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: pranjali98

Niti aj accha nahi kia.she fought with the same fan today who is a Manan fan.loves both equally..just for criticising her on her karishma thing(that was actually so funny to me,Karishma was the worst thing of ky2)..she gave her the tag of hater..even she made VM for Niti on her birthday with shahid's one and Niti saw this also.as far I understood Niti,she can't bear any bit of bashing..she today said she gets the most bashing among ky2 cast.that's also not true..when she will learn how this world is,she will become a woman from a child doll

my pov.no argue.#OkThnxBye

niti is childish and immature and she shldn't have reacted but that girl tammy man she always bashed the hell out of her. Now she playing victim card. 🥱
pranjali98 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: s45ve7

niti is childish and immature and she shldn't have reacted but that girl tammy man she always bashed the hell out of her. Now she playing victim card. 🥱

tammy never bashed her. only supports the truth.she is a big Manan fan.also she likes Niti,made vm for her in birthday.all know her well in twitter.she never bashes anyone,it's calling pointing one's bad or good..
Edited by pranjali98 - 9 years ago
charminggenie thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#17
Co-stars got equal opportunity?
Cabir was loved in S1 . Navya made a big impact in S1, heck atleast she got solid 3 tracks and interpersonal relationships . Mukti had 2 arcs focused on her. Harshad, Dhruv and many more.

Her own role was reduced to an expressionless lamppost.

She is entitled to her perception but she is certainly open to critique based on her perception because she made it in a public interview which is circulated to be discussed and talked about.

She is certainly being obtuse and indifferent to what went wrong in S2 which is why it failed to click .Why was S1 such a craze . Her co-stars were discussed, evoked strong reactions all the time but in S2 they were reduced to bunch of silliness in the name of "screenspace".

S2 failed. Period. Stop blaming the audience but take a moment and introspect why it didn't click. The product was made not to satiate the actors with screentime but to sell it to the audience.
AreYaar thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: charminggenie

Nandini Moorthy was created in S1 , she won't have been this big or this popular had it not been for that one S1. She was so powerful that she changed the anchor of the show , moved it from feb5 to MaNan and herself. She became the narrator of the show and someone we fought to defend all the time. Niti played her brilliantly but it was S1 team , precisely Richa , who let her play the ball. Yes MaNan were the core story , because Nandini and Manik rose beyond the show's basic elements.
But guess, who cares, there are shiny diamonds and lollpops to fight over that we dismiss and negate what created S2. You won't have had S2 had it not been or the brilliance of S1.

Yes , she has full right to state her opinion but so is the right of the audience to reject/embrace what they want and also to question her opinon given it was made on a public platform.

S2- i don't even want to sit and show the flaws . Opened the track for others"? Are you kidding me . OLX sale of a baby- enough said. So what were Homosexuality, Teen pregnancy and more . Sigh..I just should stop dissing it because not worth it.

Conveniently the blame-game falls on the fans na- coz they bashed, they didn't "support" what about the failed execution and bad acting of S2 . My opinion- Niti herself dropped the ball in S2 as far as acting is concerned. But who would take accountability for that eh?


Pretty sad that people cannot even appreciate and respect what made them . Throwing someone's work of 245 episodes for a shiny little toy , Nice. And then whine about why nobody loves me and I get criticized. Heck anyone from the cast/crew damaged Nandini was bashed so badly..heck her co-star bore the brunt for being obtuse about MaNan In S1.

TRPs eh? Haha, I am sure someone will fetch up the data..last leg of S1 was run by Karishma btw..product placement and failed handling. Nice.

Merger, FC ..RY handled that not by making her actors defend her but by respecting her audience and making amends.

But why bother, this cast is smoking a serious pot.


But cannot help but wonder, what would have happened had someone else dared to make this statement.



This.

And I haven't said anything about most of this offscreen mess for many days now but I'm done...I'm done with these ppl whining and trying to paint themselves as victims...I am counting all of them in this now...on one's a saint or above using such underhanded tactics, that much is abundantly clear now...this card can only be used upto a point...find a new one now.


I spoke up cuz I take offense as a MaNan fan...I'm not a fan of any individual character or actor...but I've been a fan of MaNan...they struck a chord with me as they did with many ppl...and those are the ppl that these actors disrespect in this form by making such statements. The fact that they let their own biases, their own agendas overshadow the CONTENT that made this show is just sad. The fact that they want to pretend that a whole season of 200+ episodes didn't exist and the show only got "good" when it came into an asinine season 2...that is major disrespect to the fanbase that stood by this show so loyally.


I honestly do not care anymore who got bashed when...sorry but move on...the show just ended, this is the time to pay homage, respect to it and this is what you come up with? Busy hailing your friends in lieu of the show? Grow up, seriously.


I don't know or care what their personal equations were...I am going by what was shown to us...I can't recall RY or her team ever publicly undercutting Niti or her contribution to Nandini...I can't recall them ever saying that this show was only about one character...What I do recall is them rising above a TON of shit to deliver the content we saw onscreen...and that had to be a team effort...This isn't some effing playground where you can do whatever fun you want and not do your job.

And I'm sorry Niti but you FALTERED in season 2...that's fact...so I'm sorry but your wonderful, compassionate new friend did not get good work out of you...and to me this is about your WORK...not what timepass you were doing onsets.


Nothing in season 2 compares to the work you did in season 1, Niti...I'm sorry if you don't like that uncomfortable truth but it's the truth...so maybe acknowledging it will help you better understand how to do your best.


It's especially disappointing to see the one person in the cast who at one point seemed to have relative maturity regarding this show has now utterly lost it ...for reasons best known to her and best justified by her fanbase...this is not what the loyal fanbase deserved in the end...actors who put their own biases above the SHOW that gave them everything...that they failed to see the big picture in the last stretch is truly unfortunate.




charminggenie thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: -siyali-


Off course there's going to be a wide gap in an actor's perception vs ours, e.g. when an actor views their scene they are concentrating on how they acted in the scene, were their expressions and body movements on the mark, did they deliver the essence and the emotions required as per the script, were their dialogues believable, etc While when a fan looks at the same scene they are concentrating on how they can connect with the characters, the emotions, the feelings, etc. So yes the perception would also have a wide gap!

We agree or disagree with her comment is a whole another ball game, our perception will always differ from an actor's point of views.

I don't think her comment really meant that other characters had no story line in season1, where as Cabir, Dhruv, Mukti, Harshad, Nyo, Navya and even Aliya had decent size role in season1, they all had their own stories to tell, but majority of the space was taken up by MaNan because that is what the fans liked the most, so the script heavily concentrated on MaNan as well. So her comment is not disrepecting what the fans liked the most but rather what she as an actor liked the most in teh show, regardless of the season. At the end of the day an actor looks for two things, how the fans appreciated her work and how good is the role she's playing (the script).



Bold

@Fans appreciation was universal in S1. They took her for Nandini and made her super big that her association with Manik became the story.Doubt there can be any bigger appreciation for any actor.

Second part- her role was silly, stupid and made no sense script-wise and her own performance was a shadow of her own good work.

These are the two reason , which most of us feel why her statements about the two seasons made no sense.
BrightNSparkle thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: pranjali98

tammy never bashed her.she is like shibz,chandramukhi here,only supports the truth.she is a big Manan fan.also she likes Niti,made vm for her in birthday.all know her well in twitter.she never bashes anyone,it's calling pointing one's bad or good..

What you know about Tammy she was a very big MaNan fan, she even made Niti and Shahid video on Niti bday which is uploaded in her fan page... When even Niti was bashed she was the one to defend Niti in first place... But all the love she has for Niti was just visible to her eyes and she herself concluded to be hate...

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".