IPKKND Ek Jashn. Celebrate on Blast. - Page 44

Created

Last reply

Replies

593

Views

80.3k

Users

58

Likes

3.8k

Frequent Posters

indi52 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 9 years ago





Ipkknd Ek Jashn Episode 5 Subtitles

ASR:
Di was in a state! But then I made her promise that she'll tell Khushi what I want her to...

HP:
Sir... it's come from your office. Marriage anniversary... (gestures drinking) champ-agney...

ASR:

Champagne...

Khushi doesn't drink that...

I...

Go and get all that's needed to make thandai (bhang).

HP:
Sir... Holi is over...

ASR:
uff... Just do as I say...

Go quickly!

If I toast our anniversary with bhang instead of champagne, will be fun!

You remember don't you what happens to Khushi after she has bhang!

(Holi sequence)

Khushi:
Stop me if you can!

Today whatever's in my heart...!

ASR:
Khushi, careful!!

Khushi, you've already had a lot to drink,

you aren't drinking any more! Put the glass down!

Khushi:
Why should I? If you want me not to drink any more...

and say nothing to anybody...

then you will have to drink a bit.

(He moves threateningly toward her)


See, don't come close, I'll drink!

ASR:
Khushi, don't you dare! Understood?!

Khushi!!! Kh-!

Okay!!

What do you want? That I too should drink bhang, right?

(She nods)


Okayhh!

Khushi:
What do you think...

you're very SMART! (hoshiyaar)

If you're smart the I'm even smarter than that!

What happened? Cat got your tongue?!

No problem! From your side, let me say it...

What the what the what the what the what the what the what the...

(Khushi and Mami ji)

Come, take... have some bhang.

And say what's in your heart to everyone!

Mami ji, I want to tell you what's in my heart. (dil ki baat, literally, words of the heart)

Shall I say...

Mami ji:
Tell! Tell!

Khushi:
You know? When you get all dressed up and go out, Mami ji...

Saree... blouse... lipstick... blusher...

then you... you absolutely...

absolutely... yes!!!

You look like a rainbow without rain!

Mami ji:
Whattt!

You call me rrrainbow!

You insolent girl! Out!

ASR:
How much more must I do this?

HP:
A bit more.

ASR:
Go, get milk.

Grind... till it becomes a paste... keep adding warm milk...

Well... it's been three years... I've managed to escape Holi every time!

Put colour on yourself...

put colour on everyone...

Fun without meaning... I don't... I don't understand!

Know where colour looks nice? On a rangoli...

Remember, Bua ji had called us after our marriage... what was that?

Rangoli dance...


(Rangoli scene)


Khushi:
Hold the next step!

One step... One.. keep one step at a time!

There!

Now keep your right foot there!

There there... now go there...

Stop stop stop stopstop!

Now raise your hands and go around!

When you listen to all I say, you look so good.

ASR:
Khushi... you have...

Khushi:
Okay, all right... give me your hand!

Shall I leave your hand?

No no! If I leave your hand the rangoli will get spoilt...

Come!

ASR:
Khushi hasn't called yet?!

Di told her...

Oh! I have told Di to tell Khushi I have extremely low sugar...

and I'm very very... weak.

I thought Khushi would come running when she heard that!

I think I shall leave her a note or something...

Remember the time madam thought that I married her...

because there was some problem in my horoscope?

(Suicide sequence)

ASR:

KHUSHI!!!


What the hell are you doing!

Get down instantly!!

Khushi:
See don't come close otherwise I'll jump!

ASR:
Okay okay! Relax! I'm not coming closer...

But, why will you jump? What's wrong with you??

Khushi:
Just let me jump!

Enough's enough! From yesterday, you've been at this only haven't you...

First, that poison...

then the srewdriver...

then knife... then rope...

I can't bear all this.

That's why what you're trying to do...

I'm doing it myself...

ASR:

KHUSHI, there's nothing like that!!

Relax! Listen to me!

Khushi:
I don't want to listen to anything!

Kamlesh Khabri ji has explained everything to me...

And I've understood as well!

There's a problem in your horoscope, that's why you've married me, right?

ASR:
What??!!!

Horoscope??

Khushi:
And that too only for six months!

After that... (gestures being strangled)

Yeah! and after that you'll marry Lavanya ji!

Your true love!

So I thought, why should I wait for you to kill me...

before that I myself will...

ASR:
CAREFUL!

Khushi:
Don't come close!

ASR:
Okay! Okay!

I won't come close!

but, Khushi, you get down! Because what you're thinking...

is not true!

You know I don't believe in horoscopes and such things.

It's all rubbish! Blind faith!

Khushi:
It's not rubbish, it's true!

ASR:
It's not true!

Khushi:
It's true! I know... I heard you talking to Lavanya ji on the phone!

That you'll get rid of me!

Since then you're following me...

and trying to kill me!

ASR:
What nonsense is that!

I wasn't talking to Lavanya about you ever!

And following you-

Khushi:
You never lie to someone about to die!

See I've made my peace with everything!

I've said goodbye to everyone...

And written my will too!

All my things... whoever I wanted to give it to...

I've given...

That's why-

Arrey... you've got the stars already!

ASR:
Khushi, enough of this fun and games! We can sit and talk about this, okay!

Khushi:
NO!

You be happy with Lavanya ji down here...

I'm okay up there...

ASR:

Yes, Di, didn't you... tell Khushi?

Neither did her call come, nor her message.

I thought she'd come like that!

Tch! Di, yeah when she comes she'll know I lied... but I'll make her come around...

Okay!

I'll make her come around with this!

You... want to know... what it says?

Khushi Kumari Gupta Singh Raizada...

You're slightly mad...

but that doesn't stop me from saying, I...

You know I...

I can't SAY it normally...

like that...

I can only say it if I'm...

under some pressure...

like KIDnap!

(Kidnap scene)

ASR:
Khushi!

Kh...

Khushi, I'm fine, I'm okay... okay?

Please don't cry.

Khushi, enough, just stop!

Khushi, stop crying...

Khushi, I...

Khushi, I... you...

Khushi, I love you.

ASR:
Anyway...

If today, right now she comes before me, I'll definitely tell her.

Khushi:
Arnav ji, you lied to me! I'll never forgive you! I'm going to Lucknow to Amma, Babu ji, and Bua ji!



Ekaanek100 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 9 years ago
Well , this is gonna be a long post.. it contains a lot of detailing from someone who gets too much into anything that concerns IPK.. I may go off topic also .. So a warning to ones who really don't like long posts..
The first time I watched Jashn.. it was a tonic to my otherwise sore eyes.. a melody to ears that has been acquainted with a lot of cacophony for the last few years. This lead me to not at all getting bothered by how pathetic the script has been till date.. I was too much into my arshi..my sarun... I was too exhilarated with them back on my screen...
But now when i watch it with a little less of excitement with a saner mind .. I realized that yes we have a lot of misses and bloopers in the Jashn as well...

In the first episode I could actually see Barun not into the character , he kind of look confused... and by the time what the came ... it looked out of place.. But just when he was all ready...showered and dress... is inhibitions took a back seat...From the first time i fell for the character of ASR ,.. i observed or rather deduced one thing... there is this one thing common between Barun and ASR .. they are not both with words.. They cannot talk in a stretch... They speak from their eyes... Barun Sobti has the most expressive set of eyes on Indian television.. This set of eyes have shown us all sort emotions in just single scene...too many times... Love...lust... anger...jealousy.. Vulnerability... Amusement... Happiness... Desolation... Stubbornness ...the giving up... and on and on I can on with the feelings that i could see in his eyes.. You just have to look in his eyes and you'll know what we has in his heart.Heck he has even made me cry...the only actor who has made me cry on TV. He was very convincing with that part...Even sanaya has said in one of her interviews that " With barun its different...other actors make act a lot..I am saying this when i have acted with so many actors... he is very much into the scene..he does not even have to act...But dialogue delivery was not his forte..I pointed it out many time...
So I really found him going out of the character of ASR and coming back again...But he took my heart away...with the dialogue "Ek dhun baji thi".. his voice modulation was too good...You can actually feel it in his voice...that's the caliber of the man.



Specially in the scene with Akash.. He looked more like Barun to me.. I thought that Akshay and Barun were talking... Because ASR will never call akash as Tu..ANd he will never call himself mereko...that was the script writer's fault...completely... Actors do make mistakes with the dialogue.. Every actors do.. No one is flawless.. Its the job of the team that is sitting behind the camera who needs to point this out...
But i would like to mention...Akshay looked like a matured and an Akash with a spine.. He was good...And Barun's expression in the end when he was told about the baby was actually Arnavish...



So yes when he kept turning back to ASR and then to BArun it was irritating... But i liked the fact that a person who is more comfortable acting was made to narrate. So i give him that benefit of doubt.. Had it been any actor who was made to stand infront of the camera ..and talk ...with flashback put here and there...with bad editing... it would have sucked... Sorry for the language here.. But this guy pulled it off pretty well.. IPK JAshn being Number two just with the narration part... is an achievement in itself...

I actually liked some parts of few episodes in between because they did focus on the fact that .. Yes for ASR saying I LOVE YOU is difficult...He'll do it only in dire consequences...He still does not believe in Devi Maiyaa..but cant ignore her if Khushi wants it..Him admitting from when he actually never had a distrust on Khushi

Coming straight to the episode where we had mamiji's entry... Okay again even being such an amazing actor it took time for her to get the correct accent.. Yes she was good with the expressions part... but i did not find the accent initially..I am saying this because i have been a huge fan of mamiji since the beginning... . I enjoyed this episode ..and i absolutely loved Barun's expressions as ASR.. Arnav/ASR and mami share a vvery different kind of chemistry... I used to enjoy the little tits and bits between them...the amusement in his eyes... That were there till today... yet again the eyes..and the facial expressions... Too good... I loved the chemistry...

The seventh episode that brought breath of fresh air for everyone on the forum..had also had its share of misses...along with the hits... First of all...it was completely known from the episodes that this guy did not know when the flashbacks are being put... Pathetic absolutely careless editing done by the Editors... Jumping directly to the scene where Khushi enters... The first thing i realised is..Oh God its not Khushi and not Sanaya... Not just the Hi part go with Khushi.. but the way she pronounced Main door..was absolutely very English..and she used "mai" instead of "HUm".She sounded more like Chanchan..and looked as well.. But may be I am wrong because Khushi and Chanchan were quite similar in their mannerism...i dont really know but i kind of found more of Sanaya or Chanchan in the introductory scene...And then I see both of them together in one screen... Giggling i was ..like a stupid fan girl.. And then again she says Hello Hi.. I was like what the ..This is not Khushi again... But all this is yet again the scripts writers fault...These things will not come in an actors mind...specially when they are shooting at such a short notice... and with such less time in hand..and with so many other commitments to look into... Improvisation can be done by the actor only when they have...they have settled down in the character.. Hell when a show starts even ab accomplished actor takes a few episodes to get the sync,... And these guys hardly got that.. So blaming sanaya or barun for not coming out of the script and performing correctly... will be totally wrong... Any way coming back to the scene.. I loved the expressions on Barun's face when he saw Khushi...The satisfaction was again in his eyes.. Yet again this man needs no dialogue.. And then that gussa... And even sanaya was back in the character...completely.. I got my khushi back.. Aage peeche... peeche aage.. I loved it... ANd i guess that's why And i give it to makers who included this scene..and BANG the door.. Both actors were very good in this scene... Arnav's longings to be with his khushi was heard in his voice.. Khushi's fight with her mind and heart to give in / to not give in was visible in her eyes... And then the Rabba Ve . I was gone..
Sanaya's forte is her dialogue delivery... She can speak a lot.. She is chirpy and can go and on.. And that s y i think both of them click..onscreen and off screen also interviews also...Just like AK said .. the other half of each other

Absence of masters like Arshad Khan,..hRishikesh Gandhi and ofcourse GUL made a difference.. Things would have been better. I wish star would have given more detailing ... more homework on this .. But guess their only concentration was on earning money


For me Jashn has been a reliever ..After IPK ended i never watched a single episode...i was too hurt..and hence i did not mind the flashbacks..because they included all my favourite scenes ..reminiscing what happened before or after them...I know Star India has done this as business... But i surely know that all the actors who came back for Jashn have done it for the love of the show..ANd i thank them for doing this...Because they are giving me a closure... I might never watch any other show..because I find them absolutely pathetic,. U tend to get hurt as a fan.. by the time it ends..I am glad IPK ended at the right time..SO as to remain in the hearts of all the fans unlike all the other forgetful shows... I am sad that I might not get to see them together again...atleast not onscreen... i know il get to see them off screen though because they are good friends,...rather family...unlike their respective fans.. I am at least satisfied that their fans have not turned them against each other... 😃😃

h-arshi89 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: asmi_Sarun

Well , this is gonna be a long post.. it contains a lot of detailing from someone who gets too much into anything that concerns IPK.. I may go off topic also .. So a warning to ones who really don't like long posts..

The first time I watched Jashn.. it was a tonic to my otherwise sore eyes.. a melody to ears that has been acquainted with a lot of cacophony for the last few years. This lead me to not at all getting bothered by how pathetic the script has been till date.. I was too much into my arshi..my sarun... I was too exhilarated with them back on my screen...
But now when i watch it with a little less of excitement with a saner mind .. I realized that yes we have a lot of misses and bloopers in the Jashn as well...

In the first episode I could actually see Barun not into the character , he kind of look confused... and by the time what the came ... it looked out of place.. But just when he was all ready...showered and dress... is inhibitions took a back seat...From the first time i fell for the character of ASR ,.. i observed or rather deduced one thing... there is this one thing common between Barun and ASR .. they are not both with words.. They cannot talk in a stretch... They speak from their eyes... Barun Sobti has the most expressive set of eyes on Indian television.. This set of eyes have shown us all sort emotions in just single scene...too many times... Love...lust... anger...jealousy.. Vulnerability... Amusement... Happiness... Desolation... Stubbornness ...the giving up... and on and on I can on with the feelings that i could see in his eyes.. You just have to look in his eyes and you'll know what we has in his heart.Heck he has even made me cry...the only actor who has made me cry on TV. He was very convincing with that part...Even sanaya has said in one of her interviews that " With barun its different...other actors make act a lot..I am saying this when i have acted with so many actors... he is very much into the scene..he does not even have to act...But dialogue delivery was not his forte..I pointed it out many time...
So I really found him going out of the character of ASR and coming back again...But he took my heart away...with the dialogue "Ek dhun baji thi".. his voice modulation was too good...You can actually feel it in his voice...that's the caliber of the man.



Specially in the scene with Akash.. He looked more like Barun to me.. I thought that Akshay and Barun were talking... Because ASR will never call akash as Tu..ANd he will never call himself mereko...that was the script writer's fault...completely... Actors do make mistakes with the dialogue.. Every actors do.. No one is flawless.. Its the job of the team that is sitting behind the camera who needs to point this out...
But i would like to mention...Akshay looked like a matured and an Akash with a spine.. He was good...And Barun's expression in the end when he was told about the baby was actually Arnavish...



So yes when he kept turning back to ASR and then to BArun it was irritating... But i liked the fact that a person who is more comfortable acting was made to narrate. So i give him that benefit of doubt.. Had it been any actor who was made to stand infront of the camera ..and talk ...with flashback put here and there...with bad editing... it would have sucked... Sorry for the language here.. But this guy pulled it off pretty well.. IPK JAshn being Number two just with the narration part... is an achievement in itself...

I actually liked some parts of few episodes in between because they did focus on the fact that .. Yes for ASR saying I LOVE YOU is difficult...He'll do it only in dire consequences...He still does not believe in Devi Maiyaa..but cant ignore her if Khushi wants it..Him admitting from when he actually never had a distrust on Khushi

Coming straight to the episode where we had mamiji's entry... Okay again even being such an amazing actor it took time for her to get the correct accent.. Yes she was good with the expressions part... but i did not find the accent initially..I am saying this because i have been a huge fan of mamiji since the beginning... . I enjoyed this episode ..and i absolutely loved Barun's expressions as ASR.. Arnav/ASR and mami share a vvery different kind of chemistry... I used to enjoy the little tits and bits between them...the amusement in his eyes... That were there till today... yet again the eyes..and the facial expressions... Too good... I loved the chemistry...

The seventh episode that brought breath of fresh air for everyone on the forum..had also had its share of misses...along with the hits... First of all...it was completely known from the episodes that this guy did not know when the flashbacks are being put... Pathetic absolutely careless editing done by the Editors... Jumping directly to the scene where Khushi enters... The first thing i realised is..Oh God its not Khushi and not Sanaya... Not just the Hi part go with Khushi.. but the way she pronounced Main door..was absolutely very English..and she used "mai" instead of "HUm".She sounded more like Chanchan..and looked as well.. But may be I am wrong because Khushi and Chanchan were quite similar in their mannerism...i dont really know but i kind of found more of Sanaya or Chanchan in the introductory scene...And then I see both of them together in one screen... Giggling i was ..like a stupid fan girl.. And then again she says Hello Hi.. I was like what the ..This is not Khushi again... But all this is yet again the scripts writers fault...These things will not come in an actors mind...specially when they are shooting at such a short notice... and with such less time in hand..and with so many other commitments to look into... Improvisation can be done by the actor only when they have...they have settled down in the character.. Hell when a show starts even ab accomplished actor takes a few episodes to get the sync,... And these guys hardly got that.. So blaming sanaya or barun for not coming out of the script and performing correctly... will be totally wrong... Any way coming back to the scene.. I loved the expressions on Barun's face when he saw Khushi...The satisfaction was again in his eyes.. Yet again this man needs no dialogue.. And then that gussa... And even sanaya was back in the character...completely.. I got my khushi back.. Aage peeche... peeche aage.. I loved it... ANd i guess that's why And i give it to makers who included this scene..and BANG the door.. Both actors were very good in this scene... Arnav's longings to be with his khushi was heard in his voice.. Khushi's fight with her mind and heart to give in / to not give in was visible in her eyes... And then the Rabba Ve . I was gone..
Sanaya's forte is her dialogue delivery... She can speak a lot.. She is chirpy and can go and on.. And that s y i think both of them click..onscreen and off screen also interviews also...Just like AK said .. the other half of each other

Absence of masters like Arshad Khan,..hRishikesh Gandhi and ofcourse GUL made a difference.. Things would have been better. I wish star would have given more detailing ... more homework on this .. But guess their only concentration was on earning money


For me Jashn has been a reliever ..After IPK ended i never watched a single episode...i was too hurt..and hence i did not mind the flashbacks..because they included all my favourite scenes ..reminiscing what happened before or after them...I know Star India has done this as business... But i surely know that all the actors who came back for Jashn have done it for the love of the show..ANd i thank them for doing this...Because they are giving me a closure... I might never watch any other show..because I find them absolutely pathetic,. U tend to get hurt as a fan.. by the time it ends..I am glad IPK ended at the right time..SO as to remain in the hearts of all the fans unlike all the other forgetful shows... I am sad that I might not get to see them together again...atleast not onscreen... i know il get to see them off screen though because they are good friends,...rather family...unlike their respective fans.. I am at least satisfied that their fans have not turned them against each other... 😃😃

apart from ur whole post, what surprised me is, u never watched IPK after it ended...really😲
how can an IPK fan can stay like that. no, I m not saying u r not a true fan.
but, I will get mad, if I don't watch atleast a short scene a day.
how can u stay like that
h-arshi89 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: Katelyn


Hi! I do have epi 348 eng subs.

Here's a link.

http://www.dailymotion.com/video/k6eNUZuUONUssbejvSn

thank u so much. I will try it.😃
h-arshi89 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago

I felt like, yesterdays episode was the best.

why is it wrong when arnav calls garima as amma.
garima has raised two children with motherly love who are not her own. she can easily give that to arnav too. so he will obviously love her, feel comfortable with her and call her amma.
arnav had changed with khushi's love.
Anjali always prayed that arnav should get a girl, who can take away his pain forever. that's what khushi did. obviously khushi is answer to di's mannat. like arnav said.
khushi can never push arnav to do things that will hurt him. she will advise him to do something only if that will give him some peace. that is the reason she asked him to call her mother as amma. she wanted to share her motherly love to him. so did arnav, when he finally accepted khushi with out any inhibitions.
those who found it meaning less when arnav called garima as amma, read this os. its a work from my favorite author, aparna.
u can understand the hidden relationships.
Horizon thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
Great to see lot of talk on the pages...the way every one perceived it...

My heart and eyes certainly melt seeing these two... few dhak dhaks..

Then, asr calling Khushi's amma... what did he address his mother as .."kya meri maa mujhe dekh kar khush hai?" "maa".. thats what the the asr I know would have addressed her as.. if he truly were to be accpeting garima to be filling up the gaping hole his mother's loss left.. i thought that was what khushi was also hoping for .. not mere name sake.. or to follow her foot steps ..

one of the tracks that didn't at all sit well with me in the original was the Gupta house track.. even more than sheetal or Mrs India, mostly becos at the time as it was unfolding, I still had a faith that the show would be restored ... lot of expectations still around..
the way that tack unfolded was itself on an off note.. that entry into Gupta house around rangoli... one of the flash backs of the recent jashn epi...she asked him to turn around in the rangoli.. he did it ...cluelessly...looked foolish.. not at all adorable to me..then she said how good you look listening to me .. made me wonder that time.. did Khushi love asr to be listening to her quietly.. rather foolishly?
back to present, repeat of the same.. on the phone she would command him to turn around.. look around...gaah..
khushi is witty, smart, very resourceful.. can give tit for tat in a ziffy.. he threw the cold milk she brought with all her laad pyaar.. care concern after eating the mirchi daal.. she made him get off a business call.. made some loss for him as well perhaps.. but he couldn't utter a word... pay the penalty my dear... the girl i fell/ still fall for...

Appreciate all the efforts to bring this back to us..
if only a little heart was put into it...of who/ what this love story is all about...
indi52 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 9 years ago
hi asmi_sarun,

great reading your take... has been quite an experience this jashn.

really liked what you say here and agree with you totally about those eyes. you choose lovely words... he made me cry too... and dhakdhak and angry and so many things.

"there is this one thing common between Barun and ASR .. they are not both with words.. They cannot talk in a stretch... They speak from their eyes... Barun Sobti has the most expressive set of eyes on Indian television.. This set of eyes have shown us all sort emotions in just single scene...too many times... Love...lust... anger...jealousy.. Vulnerability... Amusement... Happiness... Desolation... Stubbornness ...the giving up... and on and on I can on with the feelings that i could see in his eyes.. You just have to look in his eyes and you'll know what we has in his heart.Heck he has even made me cry..."
indi52 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: Horizon

Great to see lot of talk on the pages...the way every one perceived it...


My heart and eyes certainly melt seeing these two... few dhak dhaks..

Then, asr calling Khushi's amma... what did he address his mother as .."kya meri maa mujhe dekh kar khush hai?" "maa".. thats what the the asr I know would have addressed her as.. if he truly were to be accpeting garima to be filling up the gaping hole his mother's loss left.. i thought that was what khushi was also hoping for .. not mere name sake.. or to follow her foot steps ..

one of the tracks that didn't at all sit well with me in the original was the Gupta house track.. even more than sheetal or Mrs India, mostly becos at the time as it was unfolding, I still had a faith that the show would be restored ... lot of expectations still around..
the way that tack unfolded was itself on an off note.. that entry into Gupta house around rangoli... one of the flash backs of the recent jashn epi...she asked him to turn around in the rangoli.. he did it ...cluelessly...looked foolish.. not at all adorable to me..then she said how good you look listening to me .. made me wonder that time.. did Khushi love asr to be listening to her quietly.. rather foolishly?
back to present, repeat of the same.. on the phone she would command him to turn around.. look around...gaah..
khushi is witty, smart, very resourceful.. can give tit for tat in a ziffy.. he threw the cold milk she brought with all her laad pyaar.. care concern after eating the mirchi daal.. she made him get off a business call.. made some loss for him as well perhaps.. but he couldn't utter a word... pay the penalty my dear... the girl i fell/ still fall for...

Appreciate all the efforts to bring this back to us..
if only a little heart was put into it...of who/ what this love story is all about...




hi indu,

same pinch.

i never liked the gupta house days.. suddenly plonked in in the middle of a tale because everyone lost their way post the forced in forced wedding and decided a move there would be good for trp... a chance to go middle class holier than thou... no real story.

and really asr was not in need of public baths and gobar falls to appreciate the vicissitudes of less financially endowed lives. glad you had reservations about those days. mine were pretty severe... these are hindi serial ploys i find trying. but asr and khushi... both again got it done beautifully with their acting.

amma. a whole story there that might have been explored. yeah... he will never call anyone else maa. but to come to that amma also, if he indeed did that, there would be a great chance to tell a story... otherwise, it's just false sounding and unsettling.

but barun is sounding unlike asr... even unlike himself... he is looking really out of it. wonder why.

i didn't recognise khushi. and alas no dhakdhak when the two got together.

to me this is a marketing thing, didn't touch me. i am going to try and just forget it.

on the other hand.. if there had been a bit of that ingredient... heart... you speak of, might have been a winner. a killer even. sigh.

and thinking more... nah, i can't see him calling garima amma just to please anyone and even if he warmed to her more and more... in fact, i loved the peek into their relationship in ipk... it would have been great to see how he grappled with the fact that she was the other woman... emotionally that is... i wanted to see his initial rejection of the woman who had been indirectly responsible for his mother's death... then the gradual return to the woman who understood him almost instinctively and was gentle and empathised... his "aunty" would gather that love in it... just as his "pagal" did... and as she had said, what difference does it make what you call someone, it's the relationship... asr would call her aunty and love her like a dear elder, perhaps even feel her hurt... another victim of his father's irresponsible wayward nature and give her his support (is that the word i am looking for?) as well as a special tenderness for khushi's amma. who reared her when she lost her parents and never let her feel the loss, loved her like her own.


Edited by indi52 - 9 years ago
aarwen thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago
Nice conversation Indi and Indu di..
I have always liked ASR and Garima's relationship from the start.. he had slammed bundles of note in front of buaji (lol! oh I miss him), but with aunty he was respectful from the start (if am not wrong the first time he met her was after the diwali showdown.. what a moment there..)

During the Gupta house days when he says sorry for his high and mighty ways she is so understanding and lovable.. same with when he calls her aunty and says he can't call her amma.. she was a bit nervous around the hi fi hot headed damadji, but knew her daughter had found the perfect rajkumar.. and he just liked straightforward people I feel. He had warmed up to Khushi's family really well..

IPK's take on relationships was spot on.
Kowsi thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: indi52




hi indu,

same pinch.

i never liked the gupta house days.. suddenly plonked in in the middle of a tale because everyone lost their way post the forced in forced wedding and decided a move there would be good for trp... a chance to go middle class holier than thou... no real story.

and really asr was not in need of public baths and gobar falls to appreciate the vicissitudes of less financially endowed lives. glad you had reservations about those days. mine were pretty severe... these are hindi serial ploys i find trying. but asr and khushi... both again got it done beautifully with their acting.

amma. a whole story there that might have been explored. yeah... he will never call anyone else maa. but to come to that amma also, if he indeed did that, there would be a great chance to tell a story... otherwise, it's just false sounding and unsettling.

but barun is sounding unlike asr... even unlike himself... he is looking really out of it. wonder why.

i didn't recognise khushi. and alas no dhakdhak when the two got together.

to me this is a marketing thing, didn't touch me. i am going to try and just forget it.

on the other hand.. if there had been a bit of that ingredient... heart... you speak of, might have been a winner. a killer even. sigh.

and thinking more... nah, i can't see him calling garima amma just to please anyone and even if he warmed to her more and more... in fact, i loved the peek into their relationship in ipk... it would have been great to see how he grappled with the fact that she was the other woman... emotionally that is... i wanted to see his initial rejection of the woman who had been indirectly responsible for his mother's death... then the gradual return to the woman who understood him almost instinctively and was gentle and empathised... his "aunty" would gather that love in it... just as his "pagal" did... and as she had said, what difference does it make what you call someone, it's the relationship... asr would call her aunty and love her like a dear elder, perhaps even feel her hurt... another victim of his father's irresponsible wayward nature and give her his support (is that the word i am looking for?) as well as a special tenderness for khushi's amma. who reared her when she lost her parents and never let her feel the loss, loved her like her own.



That's it! This is exactly what I thought about the whole "Amma" thing!

I was so sure that he couldn't call anyone as Amma, Maa or even Mom! I love reading FF where Arnav call her Amma and I would like to write one where he calls her Amma or something like that because a fanfiction is imagination so it's okay I think but seeing ASR on screen and doing the same is so awkward!

Calling someone and giving someone a status of a Mother is something big and it represents so much for him

Or at least they should have explained the whole thing more or just let pass one "Amma" and not him repeating it several times

And as Garima said a relationship does not lay in a name, well in my opinion a sibling relationship and parents-children relationship does not need a name! Many are those who disagree with me but that's just my way of seeing the thing

About the Gupta House track... I plead guilty!!

I was one of those who loved that thing well maybe not that public shower (definitely not talking about seeing ASR's body!)😳

But I guess they could have extended it a bit! I loved to see ASR trying to live in a middle class place even if it was said that he did struggle at 14 till he got to Harvard and came back to be the businessman we love!

Related Topics

Iss Pyaar Ko Kya Naam Doon Thumbnail

Posted by: Mysticaldivine

9 years ago

IPKKND Ek-Jashn / New Post/ Page 47/Nov 2023

Nov, 30th ...Can we forget this day? When our favorite show "Iss Pyar Ko Kya Naam Doon ..." Ended abruptly. It was painful for all of us not to...

Expand ▼
Iss Pyaar Ko Kya Naam Doon Thumbnail

Posted by: Mysticaldivine

3 years ago

#IPKKND/ArShi Poolside Moments/A splishin&splashin’!/NEW post p123

A splishin’ and a splashin’! A little bit of pool time is among the unforgettable ones Entangled meetings straight from Kisses to heartbreaks By...

Expand ▼
Iss Pyaar Ko Kya Naam Doon Thumbnail

Posted by: IPK_Organisers

1 months ago

Benaam Ishq Ki Kahani - 14 years of IPKKND

Jo Pehle Hua Na Ab Hone Laga Hai, Dil Humko Jaga Kar Kyun Sone Laga Hai? 14 years back o n this day - 06th June 2011 The first step towards c...

Expand ▼
Iss Pyaar Ko Kya Naam Doon Thumbnail

Posted by: ssttuuttii

2 years ago

-- IPKKND CC #VI -- *A New Hope* O/A

Welcome to the As the name and picture suggests, this is a thread where you can chat with other members about anything you wish.... .... as long...

Expand ▼
Iss Pyaar Ko Kya Naam Doon Thumbnail

Posted by: pearl96

4 years ago

How can I download all episodes of ipkknd?

Hi, I'm a forever fan of ipkknd and i'm searching for the full episodes since long. Hotstar is also not available here. Can anyone please tell...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".