PAAP !!!! - Page 4

First Previous

Page

Frequent Posters

Spnfan

@spnfan

Trailblazer

+ 6

Posted: 9 years ago

#31

Originally posted by: shibz
I don't want to know how innocent or amazing Arya is __/\__
You deviated from the topic! The topic was about Nandini.. comparing her friendship to Manik's! Hence I put my points across!
I'm not even comparing Nandini to Manik. I'm comparing Nandini to Nandini! I hate repeating myself.
Quoting Shahz from the above post
Isn't she the one who said how manik was deprived of love and how she wished she could have shower all her love and concern for him when he wasn't here.

So it's my fault if I can't relate with this Nandini?

It's funny how ppl have to round it off Manik vs Nandini everytime! Story, consistency gaya tel lene. Just coz blunders have happend in the past too, we should compromise in the present n future too! Amazing

My reply was never a manik vs Nandini one...

I just reploed to your point of.aryamnn not having friends before nandu and fab 3 and.why hr.is not.close.to fab3 as he is to nandu...

Just coz for a monent she got worried abt her friend and didnt give imo to manik doesnot mean she wikl not shower manik with the love.and.care she wanted to give him...

Nandu's character.is been judged.by one scene.from a 20 min episode... She loves manik more.than anyone... Just coz she got worried for someone else for a second doesnot ruin.manan or her promises and love for manik... She didnt stop him from kissing her.im.public or got angry with him... She was ready to kiss him in public whoch is unlike nandu...

Manan from s1 and s2 are.different... Where they stand in their relationship now and then are.different so their behaviour will also be different... I don't see any change in nandu's charcter... Last episode she was worried.about navya only and she was thinking about her... Same way in todays episode she was worried for aryamann... She must have behaved the same way if she was texting to navya when.manik came... Aryamnn is the one who has feelings.for nandu.. Its noy the.other way around... Hating aryamAnn upto an extrend I umderstand but.blaMing nandubfor aryamann's feelings or her friendship is wrong... Also aryamnn till date has not given any kind of hints thay he liks nandu in a romantic way so nandu not getting aryamann's feelings is not her.fault...

Quote

diva82

@diva82

Rocker

Posted: 9 years ago

#32

Here is my concern:

Nandini being concerned for Arya, not a problem, she should be worried for her friend. My problem is the execution of scenes..the transition. For example, there is Nandini, being concerned for Arya and not once did she think about Manik, This is Manik whom she hasn't seen since the night they consummated. She should be more emotional more restlessness for him..that is not coming out from her today. Like when Manik came out with Dhruv in shorts, she should have given a moment to herself, giving an eyelock to him, just like Manik was looking at Nandini restless and wanting her attention. The balance for Nandini's love for Manik and concern for her friend Arya..is not executed well...direction fault.

Secondly, ok, Nandini is worried about Arya not picking up, Manik comes..she is not even noticing he changed, not complimenting how good he looks...not even drinking him in with her eyes, too distracted on Arya. Manik comes, asking who is this jerk..Nandini gets mad..alittle short with him. Ok fine...Manik should have realised her reaction and asked..."Nandini, everything okay?" and then Nandini should have realised what she was doing..and they could have talked..alittle more emotional..instead Manik grabs her chin and does a miss-kiss. Out of sync..no transition!

Problem is not Arya...Problem is Execution of MaNan scenes! Nandini's restlessness and Manik's perceptiveness is missing!

On top of that, we haven't had the chance for MaNan to crave for eachother, its coming from Manik at times..but the emotional reunion is not done properly. It started well on Tues but then went playful which is not correct at that time. Come on, just last week, Nandini was crying for Manik, hallucinating..where is the link up to this weeks episodes?

Finally they should have started "the Arya having importance in Nandini's life" track alittle later...I liked how Nandini finally noticed how uncomfortable Manik was at the karela scene..but again...this is too soon. The reason being..Manik has come back after 4 months, that too being presumed dead/missing so Nandini should have been shown wanting to be around him more all the time...Had the concern for Arya was done had Manik been there all the time, that it wouldn't have looked odd.

Again, I stress. problem is not Arya..it is the execution of MaNan Track that is undersold.

Edited by diva82 - 9 years ago

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

diva82

@diva82

Rocker

Posted: 9 years ago

#33

The emotional reunion got underplayed with MaNan and instead the concern for Arya got Magnified. It was ott and the link to Miss kiss...direction fail.

Quote

shahz

@shahz

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 9 years ago

#34

Originally posted by: diva82
Here is my concern:
Nandini being concerned for Arya, not a problem, she should be worried for her friend. My problem is the execution of scenes..the transition. For example, there is Nandini, being concerned for Arya and not once did she think about Manik, This is Manik whom she hasn't seen since the night they consummated. She should be more emotional more restlessness for him..that is not coming out from her today. Like when Manik came out with Dhruv in shorts, she should have given a moment to herself, giving an eyelock to him, just like Manik was looking at Nandini restless and wanting her attention. The balance for Nandini's love for Manik and concern for her friend Arya..is not executed well...direction fault.

Secondly, ok, Nandini is worried about Arya not picking up, Manik comes..she is not even noticing he changed, not complimenting how good he looks...not even drinking him in with her eyes, too distracted on Arya. Manik comes, asking who is this jerk..Nandini gets mad..alittle short with him. Ok fine...Manik should have realised her reaction and asked..."Nandini, everything okay?" and then Nandini should have realised what she was doing..and they could have talked..alittle more emotional..instead Manik grabs her chin and does a miss-kiss. Out of sync..no transition!

Problem is not Arya...Problem is Execution of MaNan scenes! Nandini's restlessness and Manik's perceptiveness is missing!

On top of that, we haven't had the chance for MaNan to crave for eachother, its coming from Manik at times..but the emotional reunion is not done properly. It started well on Tues but then went playful which is not correct at that time. Come on, just last week, Nandini was crying for Manik, hallucinating..where is the link up to this weeks episodes?

Finally they should have started "the Arya having importance in Nandini's life" track alittle later...I liked how Nandini finally noticed how uncomfortable Manik was at the karela scene..but again...this is too soon. The reason being..Manik has come back after 4 months, that too being presumed dead/missing so Nandini should have been shown wanting to be around him more all the time...Had the concern for Arya was done had Manik been there all the time, that it wouldn't have looked odd.

Again, I stress. problem is not Arya..it is the execution of MaNan Track that is undersold.

EXACTLY...It's not Aryaman neither is it about Nandinis concern for Aryaman that is the issue here.it's the timing and the way it is played out.

If this same thing happened a few days after getting Manik back I would not for once question Nandini's behaviour.But at this point it is so forced and out of place that it is doing serious damage to MaNan.The writers are rushing into a huge misunderstanding for break up and I'm sure of it.And fine we probably need it if we want the show to go on for longer.But personally I would rather see it end than these bakwas breakups.The only way to save MaNan is to get Richa mam back or just bite ur tongue and watch all this rubbish in the name of entertainment.I don't Care if Aryaman has feelings for Nandini but Nandini I'm unable to understand her.She was more emotional with Maniks booth than she is with Manik.Nandini needs to balance between her love and friends but today not a single sec where she wantedly looked toward Manik or thought of him.it was like her body was there but her soul was with aryaman.I'm hoping for some major damage control on Monday.

Quote

diva82

@diva82

Rocker

Posted: 9 years ago

#35

Originally posted by: shahz

EXACTLY...It's not Aryaman neither is it about Nandinis concern for Aryaman that is the issue here.it's the timing and the way it is played out.
If this same thing happened a few days after getting Manik back I would not for once question Nandini's behaviour.But at this point it is so forced and out of place that it is doing serious damage to MaNan.The writers are rushing into a huge misunderstanding for break up and I'm sure of it.And fine we probably need it if we want the show to go on for longer.But personally I would rather see it end than these bakwas breakups.The only way to save MaNan is to get Richa mam back or just bite ur tongue and watch all this rubbish in the name of entertainment.I don't Care if Aryaman has feelings for Nandini but Nandini I'm unable to understand her.She was more emotional with Maniks booth than she is with Manik.Nandini needs to balance between her love and friends but today not a single sec where she wantedly looked toward Manik or thought of him.it was like her body was there but her soul was with aryaman.I'm hoping for some major damage control on Monday.

@Bold, this is where the problem happened. Manik was fully there but Nandini wasn't. This is odd and out of character for Nandini as she not once focused on Manik today.

Edited by diva82 - 9 years ago

Quote

charminggenie

@charminggenie

Stunner

+ 2

Posted: 9 years ago

#36

The problem is again two folds - they badly underplayed MaNan scenes on Monday..they downplayed Nandu's reaction on getting him back and that was stupid. Should have let it play on a bit ALONE. They barely had time off and there is a big need for them to talk about those 3-4 months. Neither does Manik act like he came from dead and nor is Nandu treating it like that.

Maybe they should have started this after letting both kids talk about what happened during those months and how they both suffered.They completely underplayed the whole sequence. Nandu has gone from hallucinating to this - again badly transitioned.😆

Just like they have downplayed Manik's trauma and his need for her too.😆

I get the annoyance at her for ignoring Manik and texting Arya, because it will look jarring considering Manik has just popped back . I get her concern and her worry for Arya too but even for viewers who saw S2 , don't really see the depth of this friendship..we are just told to buy it at the face-value and buy whatever Nandu says that he is being there and is the bff..whatever. This for a character like Arya who has had so many turn-arounds.

Basically he is Nandu's feb5 and unlike Manik's feb5 we have never really seen this friendship as it is. So, it is natural for people to question his imp in her life. My advice- thats her baggage and her feb5- we will just have to live with it.

The argument that people want to see "romance" is moot..simply all wanted these two kids who meant so much to each other to have that one poignant moment , before they go back to the normalcy of their lives. There has been a lot of expectations and need for viewers to know how they both handled those months apart. There is a death of their friend too. But like the whole S2 which side-stepped Nandu reactions , they are doing the same, again.

I wanted Manik to ask her about her worry too because he is that perceptive always.

They have muted both Manik and Nandu about this big return from that..bottomlime he looks like he came from a resort and she takes it as him coming back from holiday.

So while Nandu is in her character to worry about Arya ..the overall consistency has gone for a toss BECAUSE OF MONDAY.

In the end they want to force-feed Arya as her bff and Manik will take to him as well. Happy family. Meh.

Also, let that night promo play out..lets see if the kids talk..when they are finally alone.

Edited by charminggenie - 9 years ago

Quote

Alina89

@Alina89

Beginner

Posted: 9 years ago

#37

Guys cool down pls.its nt da fault of da characters.jst cvs r nt serious about handling da situation carefully. frnds r important but nt more dan ur soulmate.pls think practically.

Quote

piyu008

@piyu008

Voyager

+ 2

Posted: 9 years ago

#38

U r somewhat right but girl..the person you love..the person for whom you cried like hell ...day and night..

the only person you kept thinking about for bloody 4 month ..is right in front of you and its not been 12 hours you met him and you are already behaving like nothing happened at all..

even we people who stay away from home..ask them..we miss home like crazy and if we get chance to visit home most of stays indoor with our family..think like this..

I accept if she whould have behaved like this after 2-3 days..but not now..its like you just got to know your soulmate was alive ..and man you just can't take that normally and worry about your so called bff not answering your call!!!

its just not like nandani..remember in past 2 times manik was hospitalized ..once toh rishabh was hospitalized too..but nandu was always there..she kept visiting him regardless of anything..

now how can they except that we will accept this shit!!

Quote

1 2 3 4

PAAP !!!! - Page 4

Related Topics

Explore Topics