nandini-sb thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#1
Seriously I want the new promo to be total false
Bcoz if it come true it will show manik as a hypocrite
Manik is one of the most strongest n well written character on small screen n I don't want it to be ruined or turned into a hypocrite

Manik as I fell had fallen for nandini when she said that she trust him
Trust which is so imp to manik
During soha court case it was just one moment of mistrust from nandini
N manik called the relationship off so much anger
So many episode of manan breakup for that tryst issue till holi epi
N now manik is himself non trusting nandu for what one glance one performance
Does it mean that nandini should trust manik with closed eyes but manik need not to do so

Friendship a relation which no one can understand better than manik
Fab 5 a very imp part of his lyf his family
In new year eve epi manik said to nandini that fab 5 is his priority as they r his friends
Good enough every person in this world comes with a package
N u need to respect his package also if u truly love him
Now his friends contains his ex gf (alia) who had fellings for him for a very long tym
It also contains dhruv who had fellings for nandini become reason for manan separation also insulted manan
But manik was OK with it bcoz dhruv is his buddy???

Everyone in this forum want aryaman to leave why???
He has fellings for nandini, good for him
He is keeping his fellings to himself ,good for everyone
I don't know what will become of arya in near future but till now he has not done anything wrong
Manik had also been very close to his friend
Calls them priority nandini respect them
But when nandini has a friend manik is going all insecure why???
Does it mean that only manik can have friends
Whereas nandini should only befriends his friends
Aryaman is only friend in nandini's lyf
Of all the ppl manik should be the one to understand it best as he keep friendship as a very imp relation


I don't know what they r trying to show but this is not the manik I know
Actually he should be the one giving explanation to fab 5 ,nandini ,audience ...
Where was he for last 4 months
Creative r trying to gather sympathy for manik in a very wrong way from audience
Manik malhotra is one of the strongest n most lovable character on screen
I don't want him to be turned into a hypocrite or someone I don't recognise
Want thus promo to be turned out to be complete false

Created

Last reply

Replies

12

Views

3.5k

Users

9

Likes

30

Frequent Posters

priakachan thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 9 years ago
#2
Very interesting post...but yaar...U must not forget one thing. Manik never really liked Aryaman. Manik infact dislike Aryaman initially. Just one or two episodes prior to Manik's accident episode...Aryaman asks Manik for forgiveness and he forgives Aryaman and then the party to ask forgiveness and then Manik and Kabir accident. Manik never accepted Aryaman as a friend or trusted him.
One thing must be remembered. Manik is a character who always had trust issues. When his mother (whom he wanted to trust) gave him a horrible time throughout these years...he wanted someone to trust him and someone whom he can trust. But never forget that...at the start itself, Manik was a monster...he was somebody who didn't cringe from throwing eggs at the innocent Nandini and her friend Navya. Manik wanted to change himself..just for the sake of Nandini.

Alya also felt a bit disconnected with this new Manik. Manik was no longer the monster..he was unable to hurt people anymore. He was already protective of Fab 5 and now he is becoming a harmless character...who lost the monstrous actions. When Manik was upset with Nandini over the trust issue...he did try to act as if he was becoming the monster again...but he couldn't completely act like one. Manik changed...he changed from being a ruthless character into someone who couldn't harass anyone like he used to. When he pressed his fingers onto the shoulders of Nandini (in the episode where Nandini gets to know of Kabir being gay) he was the same old Manik...but then...when he noticed the marks on her hand...he was apologetic. This is the new Manik..who didn't want to hurt Nandini atleast physically.

MaNan evolved...but Nandini always knew that Manik will protect her...but at the same time Manik was like a baby...a baby who starts crying when the mother gives her to the hands of a stranger. It's not that the baby doesn't love or trust his mother...but its just that the baby needs time to completely trust his mom. He fears that he will get lost...he fears that the stranger may take him away from his mom. Manik was still in a phase where eventhough he loved Nandini to the core of his heart...but within...he had an insecure side. He wanted Nandini to reassure him always that she has eyes only for him and she needs only him and nobody else.


Manik didn't want to bring anybody else into his own space or the space of Fab 5. He opened up to Nandini...because he couldn't stay away from her and because he started trusting her as a girl who cannot harm anyone...as a girl who will stand for the right thing...to him she was a shining star who will remove the darkness in his life.

Manik was never shown as a guy who is fully sure of himself...as a guy who never had any insecurity. Manik was from the start a guy who wanted to trust those whom he loved and at the same time a guy who had his own little insecurities.

Aryaman getting closer to Nandini will affect him...not coz he doubts that Aryaman is her new love interest or coz he distrusts her. It is coz Nandini is too naive. She has trusted the wrong persons many times. Wrong persons as in Harshad, Aryaman, Pandit all of whom turned to have negative sides. Now Aryaman getting closer to Nandini won't be acceptable to him for sure.


Yes surely Nandini can have her own friends...it is not wrong. But Manik always wanted the best friend position reserved for himself. Dhruv was a good friend (but not touchy feely kind) and a silent lover of Nandini. Manik realized it on the night when he confessed to Nandini. Maybe at that point also Nandini being so close to Dhruv..made him sacrifice his love. But after that Manik had decided that he won't let go of Nandini again.

Now Aryaman even if he is a good friend...will create differences between Manik and Nandini...not because Manik is insecure...but because he will walk around behind Nandini even after Manik returns and I anticipated it...from the way Aryaman was getting all free around Nandini! Let us see what happens next!😆
nandini-sb thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: priakachan

Very interesting post...but yaar...U must not forget one thing. Manik never really liked Aryaman. Manik infact dislike Aryaman initially. Just one or two episodes prior to Manik's accident episode...Aryaman asks Manik for forgiveness and he forgives Aryaman and then the party to ask forgiveness and then Manik and Kabir accident. Manik never accepted Aryaman as a friend or trusted him.

One thing must be remembered. Manik is a character who always had trust issues. When his mother (whom he wanted to trust) gave him a horrible time throughout these years...he wanted someone to trust him and someone whom he can trust. But never forget that...at the start itself, Manik was a monster...he was somebody who didn't cringe from throwing eggs at the innocent Nandini and her friend Navya. Manik wanted to change himself..just for the sake of Nandini.

Alya also felt a bit disconnected with this new Manik. Manik was no longer the monster..he was unable to hurt people anymore. He was already protective of Fab 5 and now he is becoming a harmless character...who lost the monstrous actions. When Manik was upset with Nandini over the trust issue...he did try to act as if he was becoming the monster again...but he couldn't completely act like one. Manik changed...he changed from being a ruthless character into someone who couldn't harass anyone like he used to. When he pressed his fingers onto the shoulders of Nandini (in the episode where Nandini gets to know of Kabir being gay) he was the same old Manik...but then...when he noticed the marks on her hand...he was apologetic. This is the new Manik..who didn't want to hurt Nandini atleast physically.

MaNan evolved...but Nandini always knew that Manik will protect her...but at the same time Manik was like a baby...a baby who starts crying when the mother gives her to the hands of a stranger. It's not that the baby doesn't love or trust his mother...but its just that the baby needs time to completely trust his mom. He fears that he will get lost...he fears that the stranger may take him away from his mom. Manik was still in a phase where eventhough he loved Nandini to the core of his heart...but within...he had an insecure side. He wanted Nandini to reassure him always that she has eyes only for him and she needs only him and nobody else.


Manik didn't want to bring anybody else into his own space or the space of Fab 5. He opened up to Nandini...because he couldn't stay away from her and because he started trusting her as a girl who cannot harm anyone...as a girl who will stand for the right thing...to him she was a shining star who will remove the darkness in his life.

Manik was never shown as a guy who is fully sure of himself...as a guy who never had any insecurity. Manik was from the start a guy who wanted to trust those whom he loved and at the same time a guy who had his own little insecurities.

Aryaman getting closer to Nandini will affect him...not coz he doubts that Aryaman is her new love interest or coz he distrusts her. It is coz Nandini is too naive. She has trusted the wrong persons many times. Wrong persons as in Harshad, Aryaman, Pandit all of whom turned to have negative sides. Now Aryaman getting closer to Nandini won't be acceptable to him for sure.


Yes surely Nandini can have her own friends...it is not wrong. But Manik always wanted the best friend position reserved for himself. Dhruv was a good friend (but not touchy feely kind) and a silent lover of Nandini. Manik realized it on the night when he confessed to Nandini. Maybe at that point also Nandini being so close to Dhruv..made him sacrifice his love. But after that Manik had decided that he won't let go of Nandini again.

Now Aryaman even if he is a good friend...will create differences between Manik and Nandini...not because Manik is insecure...but because he will walk around behind Nandini even after Manik returns and I anticipated it...from the way Aryaman was getting all free around Nandini! Let us see what happens next!😆


I understand what u say but from this side manik should be worried for nandini n their relation
Not angry or misunderstanding him pushing nandini is not good sign at all
Manan is the perfect fairy tale n manik the prince charming
I don't want his character to be ruined
If they can't handle our pericious fairy tale better end it with a nice ending
Manik being this much angry us not justified
priakachan thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 9 years ago
#4


I understand what u say but from this side manik should be worried for nandini n their relation
Not angry or misunderstanding him pushing nandini is not good sign at all
Manan is the perfect fairy tale n manik the prince charming
I don't want his character to be ruined
If they can't handle our pericious fairy tale better end it with a nice ending
Manik being this much angry us not justified
I know yaar..that is why he is Manik! Manik has always had this unpredictable side in him. He is very reassuring when he is reassured. It is not that Manik will misunderstand...but he won't accept Fab 5 being adulterated by bringing in Aryaman in place of Kabir as drummer and bringing in Maddy in his place.

Fab 5 has always been Manik, Mukti, Kabir, Alya and Dhruv. He can accept Mukti, Alya and Dhruv doing a concert together without Manik and Kabir in it..and dedicating it to Fab 5...but he cannot accept their own song being performed on by Maddy and Kabir being replaced by Aryaman.

I mean sure...this is going to be a strong reason for Manik for being upset. More than Aryaman-Nandini proximity...it is going to be Aryaman taking Kabir's place in Fab 5 (as well as in Nandini's life as a closer friend than even Fab 3 members) and Maddy taking his place to perform with his buddy in place of leader of Fab 5.

Manik's place atleast is irreplacable. A similar voice replacing Manik Malhotra leader of Fab 5...where is Fab 5 then...if Manik and Kabir are replaced? Then if all 5 are replaced...will it be Fab 5? Even 1 member being replaced by another guy...I'm sure will be unacceptable for the leader Manik..who cares most for Fab 5.

Yaar...I don't think the CVs will be ruining Manik..because from the start, he was never created as a perfect character. He is angry, ruthless, full of attitude, insecure, believing the world around to be cruel, having his own ego issues. Manik has always been like that in Season 1 too. At that point, there was no Aryaman. It was only Manik and Nandini and their love.

Season 2 cannot be the continuation of Season 1...there surely will be changes. Perhaps...it is the reversal of Season 1.

Season 1 main...Nandini turned the monster Manik into a human being.
Season 2 main...perhaps...Nandini will turn the innocent, caring, trusting and loving Manik back into monster Manik!😆
Edited by priakachan - 9 years ago
sanjana thumbnail
21st Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#5
Nandhini very well written. After all it is not always the right of only Manik to feel insecure. When Alya mistrusted him he immediately called off the relationship. He didn't bother to explain or pacify her. Infact it didn't have a proper closure even. Manik pushing Nandhini is not acceptable without a proper confrontation and understanding of things.
shibz thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 9 years ago
#6
I don't get what is this 'trust' 'trust' the whole forum is chanting!!
Manik is hurt, disappointed, insecure after a distance of 4 months(we're yet to see what condition he was in n why) when he did not get the reaction from Nandini that he expected on her seeing him.

Did Manik say that Nandini has moved on with another guy? 4 months is too small to move on in anyway after all that they had been through together n apart.

Aryaman is creepy.. as creepy as Pandit! Ppl said Pandit hadn't crossed his line so it was ok. Same thing is happening with Arya now? What kind of a "friend" he is to Nandini who has feelings more than a friend for her? How can anybody be ok with that? Be it Manik or Nandini or the audience?

Manik has been a hypocrite in the past too! He's no saint. He learnt a few lessons with time n evolved as a better human being. But there comes a time when we unlearn and re-learn. I believe this is that phase for Manik. Considering the tragedy that happened 4 months back.

Apart from that I agree.
I don't like the promo much. Actually the part where he jerks her off(at least that is what it looked like from the promo) I don't like that bit.
vaanii078 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: shibz

<font color="#666666" face="Comic Sans MS, Times, serif">I don't get what is this 'trust' 'trust' the whole forum is chanting!!
Manik is hurt, disappointed, insecure after a distance of 4 months(we're yet to see what condition he was in n why) when he did not get the reaction from Nandini that he expected on her seeing him.

Did Manik say that Nandini has moved on with another guy? 4 months is too small to move on in anyway after all that they had been through together n apart.

Aryaman is creepy.. as creepy as Pandit! Ppl said Pandit hadn't crossed his line so it was ok. Same thing is happening with Arya now? What kind of a "friend" he is to Nandini who has feelings more than a friend for her? How can anybody be ok with that? Be it Manik or Nandini or the audience?

Manik has been a hypocrite in the past too! He's no saint. He learnt a few lessons with time n evolved as a better human being. But there comes a time when we unlearn and re-learn. I believe this is that phase for Manik. Considering the tragedy that happened 4 months back.

Apart from that I agree.
I don't like the promo much. Actually the part where he jerks her off(at least that is what it looked like from the promo) I don't like that bit.
</font>

agree with your each words .and manik is still the same.
nandini-sb thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: shibz

I don't get what is this 'trust' 'trust' the whole forum is chanting!!
Manik is hurt, disappointed, insecure after a distance of 4 months(we're yet to see what condition he was in n why) when he did not get the reaction from Nandini that he expected on her seeing him.

Did Manik say that Nandini has moved on with another guy? 4 months is too small to move on in anyway after all that they had been through together n apart.

Aryaman is creepy.. as creepy as Pandit! Ppl said Pandit hadn't crossed his line so it was ok. Same thing is happening with Arya now? What kind of a "friend" he is to Nandini who has feelings more than a friend for her? How can anybody be ok with that? Be it Manik or Nandini or the audience?

Manik has been a hypocrite in the past too! He's no saint. He learnt a few lessons with time n evolved as a better human being. But there comes a time when we unlearn and re-learn. I believe this is that phase for Manik. Considering the tragedy that happened 4 months back.

Apart from that I agree.
I don't like the promo much. Actually the part where he jerks her off(at least that is what it looked like from the promo) I don't like that bit.


Trust issue come bcoz manik is a person who want trust
For him trust is a essential part of realtionship
This is shown many times in past ( breakup with alya, breakup with nandini on valentine)
He is insecure hurt agreed
But is he the only one who has the right to be hurt???
A relation is a bond between two ppl
Manik n nandini both makes manan
If he is hurt nandini is also not all fine n happy

shibz thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 9 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: nandini-sb


Trust issue come bcoz manik is a person who want trust
For him trust is a essential part of realtionship
This is shown many times in past ( breakup with alya, breakup with nandini on valentine)
He is insecure hurt agreed
But is he the only one who has the right to be hurt???
A relation is a bond between two ppl
Manik n nandini both makes manan
If he is hurt nandini is also not all fine n happy

I don't get you.. Sorry😕 n perhaps you didn't get my point either!


MuratHayat thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: nandini-sb


Trust issue come bcoz manik is a person who want trust
For him trust is a essential part of realtionship
This is shown many times in past ( breakup with alya, breakup with nandini on valentine)
He is insecure hurt agreed
But is he the only one who has the right to be hurt???
A relation is a bond between two ppl
Manik n nandini both makes manan
If he is hurt nandini is also not all fine n happy


The first manan scene after manik entered audi AS viewers we know that nandini thought she was hallucinating...as viewers v knw she never moved on from him. But from manik's pov all he could register is on seeing him nandu didn't smile back or came running towards him instead she looked away. That moment all manik could comprehend is nandini has moved on.
Now in all this where does trust enter. Think from a person's POV who was thought dead/missing by his family members and one fine day he returns expecting an happy emotional reunion but all he gets is his love turned away from him.

so here neither nandu is wrong nor manik. And there is no point making it manik vs nandini as to who is more right and who is at fault.
Edited by mishaarshi - 9 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".