Created

Last reply

Replies

28

Views

2.3k

Users

19

Frequent Posters

287618 thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#21

Originally posted by: gucci.

oh please don't tell me that if someone is trained as classical dancer then they are going to have equally hard time as someone who has never danced before. All of the actresses in bollywood are classical dancer and guess what they are pretty good in all of the other dances as well.

Gucci dear,

Think of it in this way, I am electronics engineer, You get me your tv and tell me, come on you are an electronics engineer, fix it, woud it work, it wont, they are two different things. I might eventually learn it, but if you go with another person who has no training at all and train them only in repair tv, i would say he would perform better than me, becoz thats all he knows, and here i know so many things that most of the time i am 😕.

It is like giving a brush to a person and asking them to paint for the bachelors of arts degree they have got.

Music and dance are not like education, they have to be practised regularly if not you forget them. But then to understand the difficulty one should be trained in that field( no offence meant to anybody)

As for sympathy votes, well i dont think sudhaji will ever get symapthy votes. I would see it as increase in the standards for ppl's dancing. If a person with one leg can dance so well, I obviously will expect a little better than that from others and i think my expectation is fair enough.

ANyways

Sorry if i have offended any of you

Ram Ram

Basanthi

ovaltine thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#22
Sudhaji should serve as an inspiration for the others to better their performance and rise to the challenge.

In SRGMP little champs, Diwakar was blind and came in first runner up. In SRGMPC2007, Poonam played on the sympathy card (she comes from a very poor family and has no father).

When a participant chooses to dance for JDJ, he or she is aware of their potential and the ability of other contestants.

The show has to come dancers of some caliber to woo the audience to watch. Yes, experience does give you some advantage but without hard work and perseverance , you will not make it to the top.

I don't want the judges or show organizers or host to mention her disability again. It has been mentioned once. That is enough. I am sure she herself who not appreciate it being mentioned repeatedly.
gucci. thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#23

Originally posted by: basanthi

come on bhastani...don't be so silly. I am sure you will have better understanding than who has no knowledge of electoronic. You have given me silliest response that anyone can give me. If you know little bit about dancing then you will know movement of feet is very importatn. I took latin dancing classes and I have never danced in my life. There were people who hve taken belly dancing in the past and some had taken ball room dancing. Guess what it was alot easier for them to pick salsa then for someone like myself with no background at all. So my friend I am tlaking from my own experience. People with dancing experience regardless of what sort will always have advantage over some one with zero experience.

Antlers thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#24
it's possible. But I dont think Prachi will win. She's already huge star in small screen. she's getting many offers but let's just say hope she dances well. she did good in the bollywood round. she's only 18. She has almost 40years to earn her fame and she has done it already 👏
287618 thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#25

Originally posted by: gucci.

Well like I said, you have to trained in music or dance to know any of the intrinsic problems, so i rather not comment, a classical dancer is always scared that she might get her bharatham steps into the salsa, which will not only look stupid but also silly and by doing so she would be disrespecting the dance method. But the person with no training will not have any mixing problem, becoz they dont know anything. But then this only applies to ppl who think music and dance is sacred, and that is again matter of induvidual opinion and their notions about the sacred art.

About belly dance and latin dance I dont know nothing about them so its hard for me to comment, but i know bharatam and Carnatic music, we are taught these art by making us believe that they are godly so If i were a classical dancer i am pron to make more mistakes becoz i am always consicous as uncounsiously i am bound to take my origianl form of dance rather than salsa or any other dance form. So i dont think that its an advantage rather a disadvantage. Well then again all this takes a lot of understanding, so if you find it silly i understand 😃

Ram Ram

Basanthi 😛

Edited by basanthi - 17 years ago

Showbizz thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#26
I think shiamak should stop staying the word pity before he gives his comments . He keeps saying m not sying this out of pity ! but why use that word at all why cant he just treat her like the rest and give an opinion ! The more he says pity the more the word gets attached to Sudha's performance !
Connie thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 17 years ago
#27
I hate it when Shiamak keeps saying it every week it's cos of sympathy blah blah blah....I wonder what Sudha must be going through
sunny_G thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#28
well .........i compltely agree with others.......shamak shud stop saying pity b4 comments............as it is i think sudha is a very good performer..........she rocked both d episodes ...i 4m my side have given her 11 votes...... she really puts d stage on fire with every performance...... i dnt think people r damn fool to give her Sympathy votes.... wat matters is performance & not pity..& as far as performance is concerned she givs her BEST...........
BeingChevi thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 17 years ago
#29
I really think Sudha is getting sympathy votes especially from the judges who like Shiamak gave her 9/10 which is really hard to give in a dance show cos I think she knows nothing Mika is betta then her. Urmila 2 gave her 9 and Jeetu-ji gave her 8. I would give her 6 which is good but it was not a sizzling performance like Prachi's or Ronit's or Jay's. That's my opinion!
I think every1 agrees with me but nevertheless she is kinda good.
From:
Chevi

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".