IS THIS the end for INDIAN IDOL SHOW

after today ....II's TRP rating would plunge even further.

already SA RE GA MA has taken over II3 as the most watched show in INDIA with 2x as many viewers.

I do believe that Prashant would be ripped apart by AMANAT,ANEEK and RAJA.

II3 had just 2 good contestants who could match those 3 in SRGM but with Prashant's victory the whole credibility of the show is completely gone.

I dont think that anyone would be watching II from now on.

Prashant has not only destroyed II3 but the possibility of staging II4 as well.

i stared in disbelief as the worst contestant of II3 who cant even pronounce hindi words properly and has never sung well was awarded the KHITAB.

what a shame???

anu malik and udit narayan ---should be blamed for the debacle. they supported Prashant despite his subpar singing.

It is a high possibility that we might be seeing II for the last time

so would amit, nah? 😉...be crushed by the SRGMP contestants

i think the only one who could have tackled the SRGMP contestants was emon...he wouldve been the bomb in SRGMP!!! But he was in II where he was highly underapprecited 😭

Originally posted by: Mosammad

so would amit, nah? 😉...be crushed by the SRGMP contestants

i think the only one who could have tackled the SRGMP contestants was emon...he wouldve been the bomb in SRGMP!!! But he was in II where he was highly underapprecited 😭

Well, you have to keep in mind that people in SRGMP are given one on one training for each song by their Gharana leader. I don't know if Amit could compete with the SRGMP top 5, but I think he could've made it decently far. Emon, with training from someone like Vishal and Shekar, could've easily made it to the top 5.
It's sad that he was on II instead, where he was told he'll never make it, that he's overconfident, and that he sounds like Sonu

II ruined it's reputation even further. All the judges and producers from the other shows will be laughing at the II producers. Yes the producers made a lot of money from the 7 crores of votes, but it terms of quality they completely lost it.

Originally posted by: doctorwordsmith

Well, you have to keep in mind that people in SRGMP are given one on one training for each song by their Gharana leader. I don't know if Amit could compete with the SRGMP top 5, but I think he could've made it decently far. Emon, with training from someone like Vishal and Shekar, could've easily made it to the top 5.
It's sad that he was on II instead, where he was told he'll never make it, that he's overconfident, and that he sounds like Sonu

I think Emon is quick learner. A boy who sings well with just one year of trainging will do wonders by the time he hits his 20's and his voice matures. Even in the clip where Anu was teaching Deepali and him the song, he seemed to be picking up the song really quick.

I COMPLETELY AGREE THIS SHOW IS NOT WORTH WATCHING ITS A WASTE OF TIME BECUZ THE JANTA ALWAYS PICKS THE WRONG PERSON ITS PITIFUL!

Originally posted by: r_tvfan

I think Emon is quick learner. A boy who sings well with just one year of trainging will do wonders by the time he hits his 20's and his voice matures. Even in the clip where Anu was teaching Deepali and him the song, he seemed to be picking up the song really quick.

I know what you mean. In that clip, Deepali seemed like she was having a little trouble with it, but Emon sounded like he'd sung it a million times before!