JDJ8 Contestants: Review Week 2.

.Jane.. thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 10 years ago
#1
I wasn't planning a review beyond the first week (which was also a very spontaneous, on-the-spot decision) but BeingBlunt very sweetly asked me to make this a weekly feature. I don't know how much I'll be able to keep that up but I could do it this week, albeit a little late. Dedicated to you, BeingBlunt, strictly my thoughts on this week's performances!

Sanaya: I know last week wasn't her highest potential but she has arguably shown the most remarkable improvement between her two performances. Only speaking of today, hers wasn't my favourite I'm afraid, and I think that was more to do with the choreography. It made her look gorgeous but gave her very little to do. Maybe her injury is still bothering her so I'll be patient. Her moves didn't have the awkwardness they had last week though and flowed more gracefully. That was her biggest drawback and it's nice to see progress on that front.

Scarlett: A notch lower than last week, I feel. The dance was brilliant and so was the choreography but after last week's fiery performance, this fell a little short of expectations. I need more spunk from these two because they're the strongest couple on the show with the correct mix of dancing talent, choreography talent, chemistry and mutual understanding as performers. And going by Lauren's word of Scarlett not being a trained dancer, I would definitely root even harder for her. Despite everything, it was still one of the best this week.

Shamita: That was a bloody difficult choreography to carry off! It was fast and energetic and even a little bit of a drop could've made the act fall flat. Shamita has a very strong stage presence and she draws attention to herself, which isn't easy when with a better performer. She has a very expressive face and the body language of a dancer comes naturally to her. But there is no substitute for hard work. My first instructor always used to tell us that a hardworking dancer will always excel way more than a natural (but lazy) dancer. So I really want to see her push herself and try different dance forms. I can see her excelling in so many, specially couple dances like Jive, Tango, Salsa, etc.

Mohit: Last week I had made a comment saying Marischa is a wonder-woman when it comes to making non-dancers perform. And it wasn't without a reason. More than a smart choreographer, she is a very competent teacher. That coupled with the fact that Mohit is extremely sincere and focussed can actually make his Jhalak journey the most impressive this year. I loved his performance this week, definitely a step up from the last in terms of the fact that he seemed so much more at ease on stage. He needs to work on certain postures though. Sometimes the man in a couple's performance is more of a supporting factor to his partner but that is also a part of the dance. That stance needs to be as powerful and as engaging as any other step. I thought he looked a little 'dheela' there.

Faisal: It was outstanding as it should be! Last week i was a little underwhelmed considering his background but this week it deserved all the applauses it got. It was energetic, well-coordinated and well choreographed. And the best part, I loved how much the two kids were enjoying themselves!

Radhika: The choreography was atrocious but Radhika's movements were much better and sharper. But honestly, dancing is not just about doing your steps. Unless Radhika starts 'feeling' it more and giving her 100%, I doubt I will like her performance. I will refrain from saying much more because she has probably been criticised the most from me. But that's only because I expected the most from her and fair or not, that does colour my perception of one's performance.

Vivian: Robotics is a more difficult dance form than we give it credit for and the way Vivian did some of those isolations specially at the beginning was quite impressive. His overall dancing is still awkward and the performance was weak compared to the rest. But for someone who was more nervous than a school kid before exams before/during/after his last performance, the fact that he picked up after forgetting those steps is, I feel, very commendable.

Ashish: I feel the form of dance Vrushali chose this time was familiar hence he felt more comfortable. Being an actor, the body language required in a Bollywood dance came naturally to him and the inferiority complex about being the weakest he had last week was definitely not evident this time.
But of course, there is only so much I can bury the lead. He seemed visibly shaken after Vrushali's accident and I can understand why. Professional dancers are conditioned to have a go-getter attitude. Spontaneity to handle whatever goes wrong on stage is in-built as a part of their training. So for her to actually leave the performance incomplete means it's very serious! On that note, I hope she gets well soon. Brilliant dancer and brilliant choreographer, I am sure she'll be back with a bang. And all the luck to Ashish as well! Of all the sympathy drama that happens on these 'reality' shows, the first time my heart sank was at how heavy his voice sounded when he asked for prayers for Vrushali before votes for himself.

Subhreet: Performance-wise, much better than last week's. It was better choreographed, had way more energy and was a lot more engaging as an act. Honestly, no matter what, that she is missing a leg will factor in when we judge her performances, not out of sympathy but out of the sheer fact that there are limitations to what she can do and how her steps would look because she is dancing on one foot. I don't vouch for unnecessary drama but there are certain things we should overlook and so will the judges. So despite the fact that it wasn't otherwise the best performance of the week, I still feel it was among the top. Perhaps those of you who have seen her in IGT, etc can judge her potential better.

Kavita: I am quite amused (in an endearing way) by how 'at home' Kavita looked in that police uniform. And it reflected in how natural she was in her performance; I am convinced that she pretended she was on the sets of FIR. But Rajit needs to up his game in terms of choreography. The performance was entertaining but had very little substance. Unlike last time, he's got a celeb with a lot of spark but so do other (more talented) choreographers and beyond a point, weak choreography might be this couple's undoing.

Dipika: I hadn't seen much of Vaibhav's choreography in the past but I can see he'll do wonders in his career. As for Dipika, I am yet to get impressed over her dancing but I am glad I was wrong about her being another Pratyusha. If she keeps up whatever happened between her last performance and this, I see her going very far.

Raftaar: I don't have much to add to what the judges said actually. Ganesh's point about a powerful start, Lauren's point about hip-hop hiding his flaws as a dancer, Shahid's point about being too heavy-footed, KJo's about great energy level, it's exactly how I felt about Raftaar's performance. Biggest grievance I felt was heavy-footed. It really took away the grace from his dance. Biggest strength is how his body moves naturally to the rhythm of the music, it's how we start grooving when a peppy song is played at a disc. I felt last week's was better but truthfully I was prepared for that. I had mentioned hip-hop couldn't judge his overall dancing ability. Let's see his progress here onwards.

Overall, I respectfully disagree with those who are not liking this season. It is still early but I feel this might be my favourite on Colors so far. The growth between the first and the second performances is usually the biggest because they have more days as compared to the subsequent weeks but I still didn't expect the improvements I saw in some of these contestants. I will not compare further back because that's just useless.

P.S. I am pretty sure Lauren was not very thrilled at Shahid imitating her accent. Even if momentarily, she let her displeasure slip. And I can understand why tbh. It might be a part of the script and she might've been prepared for it but it is still offensive. Blame it on my poor sense of humour but I never got this concept which finds amusement at another person's expense. I am sure there are no evil intentions but it's distasteful nevertheless.

Created

Last reply

Replies

41

Views

5.9k

Users

24

Likes

157

Frequent Posters

MrsAkyurek thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#2
A neatly presented comprehensive analysis on the latest performances. JDJ hasn't aired yet in my part of the world, so I'll reserve for now and come back with my take.
ps: Finally a post that discusses dancing on this forum!
Chaandaniya thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#3
Good review Jane

Shamita, Scarlett and Faisal were all fabulous 👏

I give Vivian credit for the face he atleast tried those steps seems very hard to do and the fact he tried deserves a applause.

Mohit was abit clumsy this week. He was much better last week but the guy have so much potential of a dancer. His attitude remains me alot of Hrithik Roshan. I like the fact his choreographer make him dance with power.

Subhreet: I liked her performance more this week than last week.

Given the fact Sanaya isn't a trained dancer but she have given some good performances in awards shows. She have shown great improvement between this and last week performance, looking forward to see more dances from her.


LiveLifeInBliss thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#4
I love your comments about each contestant; they totally mirror my own.😊
And I agree with you, I actually like this season. For me, last year's season was the biggest disaster I have ever seen. Certainly, there are still a few things that bothers me like the unnecessary games in between such as the towel game 😳, or the lame gay jokes which is about high time they drop it.

I like that Shahid brought in a new vibe but I wish he would stick more to judging and be a little more strict. Otherwise, I love the new judges especially Lauren and Ganesh; their comments were more on point this week. I hope they keep living up to their title as dance gurus. And I am actually glad that only Manish is hosting as he is amazing on his own.

I just want to add that to me the performances that left the biggest impression on me was Shamita's, Faizal's and Vivian's. I know Vivian's performance wasn't as spectacular as the rest of them and clearly he has to work harder as the other contestants are really setting the bar higher with their improvements every week. However, I felt that his performance still left an impression on me. It was well choreographed, and anyone can see that he tried his best. I wish that one of the judge gave him a 9 to cheer him up like they do for other contestants. Because I honestly thought that Vivian's performance was more entertaining to watch compared to Radhika's performace. She is clearly a fantastic dancer but that choreography was just simply terrible. I agree with all the judges comments regarding her performance. Oh and I agree about Vaishnavi, she is definitely a good dancer and I agree about Ganesh's comments about her clean flips but somehow I feel that she quite can't keep up with Faizal. Their coordination was much better this week compared to last week but they still need to work on it.

And yeah that's it. As I said earlier, I agree with your comments. Please do keep reviewing every week.😃


Edited by -Saheba- - 10 years ago
Manavi_kesari thumbnail
IPL 2024 Participants Thumbnail IPL 2023 Participants Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 10 years ago
#5
based on week 2 performances

choreography of most of d acts r not impressive.so d dance performances r mediocre itself 😆.judges scoring is better than last week but still improvement is needed there.

shamita,faisal,scarlet executed well d given choreography to them n r good.

subhreet simple n nice.

kavita act is entertaining n her expressions r nice n her choreo has to identify her potential n bring out her potential.she is potential n want to see her some more dance n if she stays n if choreography of d acts clicked has to see her opening up n dance,she has to open up n dance according to her bindas attitude.she has bindas attitude n she has to tranform tat bindas in to her dance by opening up by working on her.

deepika has grace n expressions.she didn't forget her steps n danced by opening up than before.she too has potential n want to see her some more dance.her choreo has to work on her potential n bring out her potential n she can dance.

raftaar too has potential n as ganesh said he has tat music n rythm in his body n he knows one dance form n he can dance n choreo n he has to work more to bring out d potential.i want to see him dancing some more,he can bring live on stage while dancing he has tat spark in him.

sanaya,radhika were avg n long way to go.radhika choreography was not nice for d act.choreo n radhika has to work very hard.
sanaya act is simple.seems she n choreo didn't connect yet it seems.

mohit very avg ,how much choreo can push by showing some gymnastics of mohit n all.poor choreographer.

vivian act - has to say choreo done clever choreography n seems interesting but d performance depends on d performer.if tat given to good performer r avg performer tat performance might looked good r decent.forgot steps.mistakes happens ok.ya he doesn't know dance but knowing he came to d show to learn dance knowing tat it is competition n all.seems he needs push n motivation always.poor wifey😆.ya to learn abcd of dance tat too in a dance show n take money is not easy task man,pressure will be double.see subhreet n lift ur spirits man urself.having limitations n knowing her limitations subhreet is showing true spirit.very very long way to go.

ashish- didn't able to complete d act becos of choreo's injury.don't know it's real injury r not to change choreo r choreo wants to quit r watever d reason i think eventhough completed d act may be it is bollywood so might be entertaining for 1 act but dance wise didn't make much difference.
.SmokeySilence. thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 10 years ago
#6
Hi Neethz,

amazing review again. I mostly agree with you.
I liked Sanayas performance. donno if it's because she was very graceful or because she just fit into the princess/cinderella role so well. but her steps and movement of hands were better than last week and I really think she is going to improve more in coming eps.
Shamitas performance is my absolute fav this week. she was simply amazing. her steps, expressions and energy was so good. i liked Scarlets and Faisals performance too and i donno that much about dance as you do. but yea agree Scarlets last week performance was a bit better. she is still very good and i didn't expect she is not a trained dancer. IMO just as a viewer, if she get votes she will go a long way.
you said about vivian correctly. he is so scared 😆 but i actually liked his performance this week better than last one and the choreography i think was more difficult than last week. he forgot some steps but honestly i didn't even expect this much from him. he must be working very hard.
rest radhikas could have been better. i said in another thread too this show got much better performances on ghost theme earlier in that comparison the choreography wasnt that good probably. and she can do better. i was surprised seeing deepikas dance too. she was good this week. rest i agree with you about everyone else. i really hope Ashish's choreographer gets well soon. judging has got better and i like how Lauren is giving marks now. nobody got full marks till now. thats unusual and i like this strict judging, hope they continue this.😆

forgot to mention about mohit. his was pretty good except i donno it felt a bit disconnected from his choreographer thats it 😕

p.s: please make give reviews when you get time. its good to see atleast someone gives unbiased true views on dancing in this forum. hope to ca soon 🤗
Edited by .SmokeySilence. - 10 years ago
Julie_Star thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#7
Finally a thread that discuss actually dancing on the forum.
First of all I fell the scoring was better this week and all contestants got what they deserved, last week scores were giving away to contestants like Laddoos...Lauren needs more improvement on her judging skill the only contestants so far she have given good advice to is "Sanaya" she needs to be equally with the rest too as they all have flaws that they need to work on.

Sanaya shown growth and improvement this week. She was good and dance gracefully, I can't be harsh on her due to the fact she's injured I saw her holding her ribs after her performance today.

Shamita and Faisal were the best of the week, I am really liking Faisal a lot this season. I hope he goes far and also Scarlett was amazing.

Vivian performance was great fun I was laughing the whole time lol... Can't call him bad since he provided good entertainment in this act.

Deepika was good and huge improvement from last week.
Edited by Julie_Star - 10 years ago
Anisha_anitan thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#8
Haven't seen all the performances but I must say dipika has improved a lot she seemed much better this week

Even sanaya was great
.Jane.. thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 10 years ago
#9
So many posts starting/ending with 'finally a thread that discusses dancing'. Toh aur kya discuss karenge dance show mein? Itni kya buri haalat ho gayi forum ki do din mein?😲

But anyway, thank you everyone for your views! I really enjoyed reading them. I'll get back to everyone tomorrow, it's almost half past 1 and I need my sleep more than I need air to breathe right now. Thanks once again🤗
AreYaar thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#10
So far I'm finding this to be a much better season than the last few in terms of overall dancing and content...last few seasons were cookie cutter in nature in that there was one strong/trained dancer and the usual 2-3 TV actors attempting to dance their way through mediocre choreographies.


So far this season I see a marked improvement in terms of choreography as well as the kind of contestants there are this time around...barring the usual TV "non dancers", I feel like the rest of the bunch is genuinely hard working, sincere and INTO the show this time...that's making a difference...



I quite enjoyed most of the performances...even Radhika did a good job I felt...unlike most of the TV actresses sticking to a typical acting-based formula, I still see her dancing and having some style to her dancing.


Faisal is outstanding as I expect him to be...poor kiddo has really gained some weight though...lol he should grow his hair and try to achieve his DID days weight again.


Raftaar is fantastic...he has that natural swag as Lauren rightly pointed out and is charming with what he speaks too...Sneha and him are a good match...she can get something out of him.


Deepak is also doing a good job with Shamita...Kavita stands out for how much she enjoys herself during her performances...


I think the only insipid character right now for me is Dipika...total washout...doesn't have personality while dancing.


As for the judging...Shahid is fun when he's not jumping over to the stage and trying to play host...I like his comments otherwise...they feel genuine and not so put on...Lauren is adorable too in the way she's trying and she gives good/clear points.


I am surprisingly enjoying the season more than I expected to so far...lol...depends on how long the interesting contestants are allowed to stay as the popular TV personalities squeeze them out of the way in terms of votes.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".