Episode Review

Credit: Geet Kundra

I agree with ur points with regards to DD and Roshni but I believe Sid loves Roshni and not just claims to,there was a time this boy believe and trusted Roshni in Yash situation and even proved her innocence,probably he lacks clarity sometimes not all the time . Sid mess up by not trusting Roshni and that he himself has taken full responsibility for and he is human,I also don't believe he'll chose his mom over Roshni cause when he decided to divorce her he didn't chose Simran but DD and that's a fact .They will be problems in the future and that will come from a player 'Misha' .

Originally posted by: candacy

I agree with ur points with regards to DD and Roshni but I believe Sid loves Roshni and not just claims to,there was a time this boy believe and trusted Roshni in Yash situation and even proved her innocence,probably he lacks clarity sometimes not all the time . Sid mess up by not trusting Roshni and that he himself has taken full responsibility for and he is human,I also don't believe he'll chose his mom over Roshni cause when he decided to divorce her he didn't chose Simran but DD and that's a fact .They will be problems in the future and that will come from a player 'Misha' .

Sid screwed up and showed he is human and he is willing in to make his wrong rite I respect that . That's just my opinion.

Originally posted by: pree8714

Credit: Geet Kundra

I would like to question #Sid that on what grounds does he think that he is apt for Roshni..I mean he can neither give Roshni his utmost devotion nor heart felt love cos as soon as another situation would arise where he would need to choose between his mother and Roshni no matter what tall claims Sid makes now, the fact is that he would inadvertently end up choosing his mother again...so what can he really give Roshni...insults??? rebukes??? disillusionment?? Whatever might be the case I feel that Sid has no right to insult and demean Roshni like he did..I mean even she is a human being who feels pain and for her to get hurt like this again and again due to her so called husband's idea of being mahaan is totally unacceptable..Sid should give her a break..I mean how much more is Roshni supposed to tolerate just bcos she fell in love with Sid..and yes I agree that even Sid had to bear a lot while he was in DD's house but then no one had asked him to do so..his intention behind doing that was to unite Roshni with her mom but in every moment during that period Roshni stood with Sid as his support but can the same be said about Sid...well NO!! He was right in todays epi on one account though and that is the fact that he himself had killed the love..the relationship that he shared with Roshni with his own hands just to prove his love for his mother*and please do not get me started on that blackmailing crap...cos I feel Sid could have easily come up with some other way to get out of that if he wanted to*...talk about late realisation anyone

Ok. I agree with some points made but i beg to differ when it comes down to sid.
First of all sid is a human and has flaws. Second his character is very different from that of roshni's so expecting him to behave like roshni (like standing up to his mother like roshni used to) is not justified. He has had always seen his mothers love for him since childhood unlike roshni who used to feel deprived so for her to stand up against her mother is much an easier task than that for sid. Sid is an emotional guy from the starting of the series if u notice, so he deals with his mother in his own way. I agree that he divorced roshni without giving her any closure but he did not do it for simran. He did it for dd and to some extent roshni (which even i did not like btw), he saw that there was a way to give back the patels what they wanted right in front of him and without thinking twice he took that opportunity. Talking about him insulting roshni for the mango incident, yes it was harsh and he should have trusted her words. But just for a second if u look from his viewpoint, he saw his friend suffering from an allergic reaction and everyone blaming roshni. He saw her bringing the glass and agreeing to make the milkshake and like any normal person he blamed her in the heat of the moment. Apart from that he has already accepted all the mistakes he did post divorce so i think we have to see how he behaves now before judging him to such an extent as to say that he isnt right for roshni.
Another thing to tell about sid is that he loves roshni.. he doesnt claim to... he does... the entire story till the divorce has shown how much he loves her.. im sorry but i think the writer should have cut some slack for him.. :P bcoz he shouldnt be blamed entirely for everything.
They both love each other and both have some flaws or the other... i dont think so roshni deserves another guy other than sid.. nor does he deserve someone else other than her.. they are equals in their wrongdoings about how they handled their relationship but both are maturing and growing as time passes.

Anyway i like both of them so i just felt a need to comment as sid was being blamed a lil too much for my liking or else i would have not commented at all :P

no offense to u priyanka just my opinion

OMG!!! So, much hatred for Sid😲😲 I absolutely disagree with the things said😕 Roshni doesn't deserve Sid??😲 Why?? just b'coz he didn't trust her once and made a mistake😕 What about the numerous time Roshni didn't trust Sid like Nani's attack, MMS etc..?? Ok, now I don't don't want to start about who deserves whom, its not about deserving its about LOVE Roshni and Sid loves each other and that's a fact. And I would absolutely disagree with the contention that Sid doesn't love Roshni. Seriously, if what Sid has for Roshni is not love then I fail to understand what love is..😕

And I agree the way sid divorced her was wrong. But he never chose his mother, its Roshni's mother whom he chose. And just b'coz he loves Roshni, it doesn't mean he should only love her and hate his mother, sister etc (which he is doing now) and don't care about DD or her family😕 Its true Sid sometimes fail to maintain a balance of all relation, but never once have I felt that Sid's love for Roshni is bellitled

Loving ur wife doesn't mean u should not care about ur family. Simran is still his mother however bad she is. If Roshni can't hate Simran, how do u expect Sid to do that?? But still he is keeping Roshni and her family above his.. Always!!

Anyway each one has their own opinion and for me ROSHNI WOULD NEVER GET SOMEONE MORE LOVING AND TOLERANT THAN SID. Even Roshni knows that and that is why she won't let go of him😊

Originally posted by: madhuharini

I agree Sid did so may mistakes like giving divorce to Roshni, obeyed his mother's promise and all... But yesterday's epi is clearly shown Sid realized all his mistakes and owes to get Roshni back. Though gud or bad Misha also pointed out Sid's mistakes and he didn't refused that. What if the show title JAMAI RAJA means Sid should never do a mistake😕 Like he said yesterday, he is also a normal human being and obviously he too do mistakes like others. We can see Roshni undergoing insults and heart-break at present. But she is taking it calmly for Sid and her love on him. I want you to think once how much insults Sid underwent when he was a ghar Jamai in Roshni's home. Ofcourse he lied to Roshni abt his own identity and so he needed to take all those insults I knew well and not justifying his lies. But as a owner of Khurana empire, without any ego he took all happily just for his love on Roshni... Even thn, when he tried to prove his love to Roshni bcoz of his prev lies Roshni didn't trust him properly seeing the MMS and Sid also equally hurt that time bcoz of Roshni. Both r hurting each other and loving each other equally and even after the POINT OF SID'S REALIZATION, WITHOUT GIVING HIM A CHANCE WE CAN'T TOTALLY BLAME HIM. And Roshni is not an ordinally house wife type of girl. She is a unique character and never behave like a punch bag, she know her rights and she never failed to stand up for her own rights... So, just leave it and take it light heartedly and SidNi will handle their love and problems. We adore them and love them together as SidNi... THE MAGIC OF SIDNI is created by SIDNI together... We can never say it is Roshni alone or Sid alone responsible for our SidNi love😊

Originally posted by: skinnypal

Ok. I agree with some points made but i beg to differ when it comes down to sid.
First of all sid is a human and has flaws. Second his character is very different from that of roshni's so expecting him to behave like roshni (like standing up to his mother like roshni used to) is not justified. He has had always seen his mothers love for him since childhood unlike roshni who used to feel deprived so for her to stand up against her mother is much an easier task than that for sid. Sid is an emotional guy from the starting of the series if u notice, so he deals with his mother in his own way. I agree that he divorced roshni without giving her any closure but he did not do it for simran. He did it for dd and to some extent roshni (which even i did not like btw), he saw that there was a way to give back the patels what they wanted right in front of him and without thinking twice he took that opportunity. Talking about him insulting roshni for the mango incident, yes it was harsh and he should have trusted her words. But just for a second if u look from his viewpoint, he saw his friend suffering from an allergic reaction and everyone blaming roshni. He saw her bringing the glass and agreeing to make the milkshake and like any normal person he blamed her in the heat of the moment. Apart from that he has already accepted all the mistakes he did post divorce so i think we have to see how he behaves now before judging him to such an extent as to say that he isnt right for roshni.
Another thing to tell about sid is that he loves roshni.. he doesnt claim to... he does... the entire story till the divorce has shown how much he loves her.. im sorry but i think the writer should have cut some slack for him.. :P bcoz he shouldnt be blamed entirely for everything.
They both love each other and both have some flaws or the other... i dont think so roshni deserves another guy other than sid.. nor does he deserve someone else other than her.. they are equals in their wrongdoings about how they handled their relationship but both are maturing and growing as time passes.

Anyway i like both of them so i just felt a need to comment as sid was being blamed a lil too much for my liking or else i would have not commented at all :P

no offense to u priyanka just my opinion

Originally posted by: pree8714

I wont say he cant be wrong but his habit of lying to roshni should be changed as a better half she should know everything when roshni was made realize for 3 months why not sid coz its been really long he has taken roshni for granted but now that roshni loves him CVs ended up the patch up in 2 days i jus hope now we see sid as a good husband rather being mahan and again lying to roshni

im sure now the track will be of sid proving to be a good husband.. hence all those dialogues were used yesterday.. patch up in 2 days coz d track isnt of realizing love. they already love each other n there is no denial from both sides... we got to see how he woos her into marriage again i guess...

Originally posted by: zoopassion

OMG!!! So, much hatred for Sid😲😲 I absolutely disagree with the things said😕 Roshni doesn't deserve Sid??😲 Why?? just b'coz he didn't trust her once and made a mistake😕 What about the numerous time Roshni didn't trust Sid like Nani's attack, MMS etc..?? Ok, now I don't don't want to start about who deserves whom, its not about deserving its about LOVE Roshni and Sid loves each other and that's a fact. And I would absolutely disagree with the contention that Sid doesn't love Roshni. Seriously, if what Sid has for Roshni is not love then I fail to understand what love is..😕

And I agree the way sid divorced her was wrong. But he never chose his mother, its Roshni's mother whom he chose. And just b'coz he loves Roshni, it doesn't mean he should only love her and hate his mother, sister etc (which he is doing now) and don't care about DD or her family😕 Its true Sid sometimes fail to maintain a balance of all relation, but never once have I felt that Sid's love for Roshni is bellitled

Loving ur wife doesn't mean u should not care about ur family. Simran is still his mother however bad she is. If Roshni can't hate Simran, how do u expect Sid to do that?? But still he is keeping Roshni and her family above his.. Always!!

Anyway each one has their own opinion and for me ROSHNI WOULD NEVER GET SOMEONE MORE LOVING AND TOLERANT THAN SID. Even Roshni knows that and that is why she won't let go of him😊