Chetan Bhagat- Good as an Author bt not a judge

If he is there on he judges panel he surely is entitled to have his OWN opinion. And he need not agree with Marzi and Preity(who herself isnt a great dancer) and we must respect his opinion.

Originally posted by: Rhea_401

If he is there on he judges panel he surely is entitled to have his OWN opinion. And he need not agree with Marzi and Preity(who herself isnt a great dancer) and we must respect his opinion.

I agread with your post TM..
I respect chetan sir's comment but this time he was wrong...
Nd about marzi nd preity so just for info marzi is well known chreographer nd has 21 year of experience nd preity was last 20 years in bollywood nd doing good dance so they both known more dance knowledge ..

Totally agree with TM. Worst judging ever. Giving 7 for such a performance showed his biasness. He has given 8 or 9 previously to otherseven he said the dance was okay but 7. When other judges have given 10 giving only 7 clearly shows his biasness

I feel the opposite. Terrible as an author but good as a judge.

Originally posted by: lovely2511

NB being a dance reality show the main thing to be judged is dance... I would have respected his opinion if he wasn't biased towards any of the contestants...

The other judges are not mad enough to give 10... If u think he is not biased then why did he give 7 to sharad and mrunal... If UpMa's performance deserved only 7 then sharad and mrunal also doesnt deserve 7

Again that's ur opinion about both the performances weren't at Par. If he doesn't feel that way we can't point fingers at him. N my sole point here is that we may not agree with someone but that doesn't mean the he is wrong N we are right!

Agree. Chetan wasnt hired as the judge to give his uninformed opinion on dance. Upen Karishma did one of the hardest dance forms popping & locking and their isolations were perfect. It requires immense amount of muscle control to attempt this, he obviously hasnt even heard the name. I have no idea what he was expecting in this, does he see Michael Jackson enacting saas bahu storylines in his dance? Upen Karishma displayed pure dancing skills & he just came across as uninformed and biased.

Preity was absolutely right in giving it back to him for questioning the skills of the actual choreographer judge with that "bhedchaal" comment. Chetan isnt even a good author by any means.

I just felt that pretty zinta was out of order the way she spoke to chentan your don't have to dance to judge dance show and upan was challenging the judge we have seen many time when sajid Khan use to not agree with shilpa Terence but never did they behave in this manner.

Agree with u 👍🏼