Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki: Episode Discussion Thread - 25
BALH Naya Season EDT Week #10: Aug 18 - Aug 22
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai - 18 Aug 2025 EDT
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai - 19 Aug 2025 EDT
GAADI CHOOTH GAYI 18.8
DAHII HANDI 19.8
Shradhanjali to Mr Anshuman Raizada
Disaster Monday: War 2 falls 75% to Rs. 6 cr, shows cancelled
Back to the pavilion when??
KJO To Return In 2026 With Classic Hindi Cinema
Faissal Khan's Shocking Revelations
Param Sundari ..Yay or Nay ?
Rashmika Mandanna & Vijay Devarakonda India Day New York parade
Beautifully analysed and written AreYaar š
This "I need a hug...I just need it" made me comment. Reminded me of all the times Manan asked each other for a break in the middle of a fight. Maybe now it's time for 'I need a hug' š
I really like the role reversal being played out by Manan. Life really does come full circle. Everything that we give, we get back in spades.
I'd like to see the song 'Teri Meri Baatein' from Piku being played on Manan. It's been one awesome journey š
Leharon se hai
Saagar se gehri bhi hai
Ye teri meri baatein
Rulaati bhi hain
Gham mein hansati bhi hai
Ye teri meri baatein
Ye teri meri baatein..
Originally posted by: IFollower
I really wonder, if this is the 1st EVER for Manik, trying to make someone smile, so earnestly, talking nonsense!!! What LOVES makes a man do!!!In fact, I think he wants to SHOW HER OFF to the world as HIS and ONLY HIS!! He is so proud of his Nandini and just can't stop himself. He just can't wait for them to be TOGETHER- OUT in the open!! Remember, he said (a day or 2 before the FC), she better get used to him holding her hands in public.
Such lovely, tender scene!!! Yes, Manik does NEED that HUG. He cannot function, w/o Nandini's smile and touch!!! Poor chap, how hard he must have been coping the whole day. And as we all know, Nandini is the stronger one, compared to the 2. A well NEEDED HUG that was and once again, sincere appreciation to the CVs, for portraying such small but important gestures in day to day life, in such a beautiful way!!Beautiful Post, AY!!! All the great scenes in 1 post, and that too with gifs. I am sure most of these scenes would be watched repeatedly.And it wasn't rambling at all, let alone being long!!! Was such a treat to read and gush about it all over again.Have a lovely w/e... L
Originally posted by: Zaya.priyanka
Anu gushing !!!!!!... *stares in disbelief*...š...
Well, bang on post madamji... It was just unconditional love from manik for his shining star who was hiding behind the fog of sadness... He just need the tiny ray light to pass through it and he knows she will come out shine even more brightly ...
Indeed...haha and all thanks to MaNan...what other pair on TV can we say that for that their SLAPS/PUNCHES are the best thing about themš¤£
Good points on the other nuances too...yes, Nandini's fragmentation came bit by bit...she was still holding herself a bit together at the police station when Cabir hugged her but later on things started hitting home and yeah she jerked away from Navya too...the ghosts of her experience haunt her...and memories and nightmares never flow smoothly...you have no control over the when of them...they will haunt you as they please.
Yes Mukti's scene with Harshad was very good too...all characters were on point this week...
Thanks for the appreciation :) And lol glad you enjoyed the jeena jeena and jaise mera tu gushing...woh toh I'm up for anytimeeeš
Originally posted by: moonstonespirit
Anu š¤
Loved the post and the gifs Will be borrowing your gifs for my siggi!! This week MaNan were bliss!!
He has always been someone who communicated through touch and words have always been her forte. During the staircase scene he asked her to touch her heart when he spoke the words. During the shadow scene he had no qualms in placing his hands on her heart. But now he knows she lost and shattered and his touch will not be reciprocated the same way. Loved his understanding and their role reversal here.
He let her know that he understands her need for space, but staying away from and letting her go was not an option for him. He told her that he will wait for her to recover, let go of those haunting memories and he will stick around her so that she can reach out to him.
Also loved the pinky locking scene. She knew that he was doing all this for her. But she lost and exhausted to reach out him. But when she saw his smile dim, she pulled up the remains of her strength and made a promise to him. Told him in that she is still there and she will reach out to him soon. That little step she took towards him, gave him hope. All he has to do now is shine for her and let his light touch her, so that she can get back her shine.
The slap scene was ultimate!! Never thought that slaps would give me feels too. Loved how he told her that she is still there and not completely lost. Her strength, her spirit which made her so special are still a part of her and all she has to do is accept it and embrace it. When she sees her reflection in his eyes she will realize how truly beautiful and strong she is.
Hope we continue to get more Manik- Rishab and Manik- Chacha scenes too!!!
Lovely post. It is great to see you gushing.š š
All I could see in this week was growth in Manik individually and MaNan as a unit.
From my spot to being her shadow.
Ye pyaar nahi hai and it's not love only tender and care to I LOVE YOU. That declaration and reaffirming of his feelings. I prefer this over their confession. He is ready to shout his feeling to the whole world. Everything except Nandini ceases to exist for Manik. A Complete goner.
From her being his star to him the one pulling her out of darkness.
Oo how can I forgot the slap. I have been seeing it in loop. See why it was incorporated to snap Nandini out of darkness and to show Nandini's fighting spirit. These are the scenes which make MaNan and KY2 stand out.
Precap again ā¤ļø. Nandini will and always be Manik's strength, his shining star.
Anu all these scenes had substance and progression. That essence, earnestness and charm of MaNan are well in tact in these scenes. These scenes were adding to their journey, well blend with the story line making me fall for them all over again.
Again Parth and Niti being phenomenal. Their expression, those transitions, the nuances, the subtle changes were fabulous.š
3 week of great episodes hope they keep up the momentum.
Originally posted by: Silentsoul
Nur , I checked this post last night very late...I loved your gushing post last week So..I thought this week you were not happy with Manan therefore no post at tall...
But you made post with gif for entire week...It was such beautiful week for Manan..I always wanted to see Nandini break down and Manik bringing her out of it with love and patience...Amount of growth Manik in love...showed from two weeks is commendable...The guy who can loose at brink of second is just hiding his pain out of her every flinch when he tries to touch her...He is the guy who needed Nandu for everything, to hold him together in every crisis, and now he is behaving so patiently so that he shinninh star is not lost in darkness...
My favorite bit was That hand moment when Nandini who just couldn't see his disappointment, gathered all courage to fight her Fear and give him Hope...WAO moment
All I can say..I love Manan but main credit goes to both pani who actually live their character with such finesse that you sink with their pain too...And this director has really creative way of visualizing and depicting those subtle emotions through those hand moments..beautiful indeed
Originally posted by: nneeiill
fab post nur...š¤
one of the good things when we get nice episodes are we get to read ur wonderful take and also ur pretty gifs.šSo true even after the confession..MaNan scenes are still worth watching...infact even after the confession am still longing to see nandu's confession ..otherwise as u said in most of the shows..its downhill soon after the confession..due to kidnapping track we got to see some really good performances from MaNan.all the the scenes u listed out were superb...especially the SLAP one..ye tho MaNan ka signature style ho gaya hai..it was so natural..so real..š³..niti was brilliant in showcasing the terror..the way she was reacting to manik's touch ..we could actually feel what nandu is going thru..and yes uff i loved when manik said "that's my girl"..and i thoroughly enjoyed how manik was telling chacha abt his nandu...loved his confidence there...this is like manik in his true element... and not to forget "choosing the right path" š¤£dil PaNi PaNi ho gaya š¤£..and yea the head shake bit in the first scene u posted...it reminded me of his solo dance with jacket...šthe precap part..the sheer relief on his face wow..i dint see this in the vdo i watched..i have to see all these episodes now in HQ..pata nahi kab time milega..