AreYaar thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#1
Thank you MTV Gods for finally blessing us with HQ epis and allowing for a proper viewing of the epis...in a sense maybe I should be happy cuz I get to do a weekend marathon...lol


Sometimes MaNan are something to marvel about in terms of how far they've come...love stories toh there are many on TV, more angsty, more epic, more many things...but the amount of fulfillment that the writers have managed to put into MaNan's evolution touches the heart time and again...most love-hate stories post the confession phase degenerate into sappy everyday activities...with the hero becoming a mere shell of his former self as he descends into uber Majnu mode...or there are the umpteen misunderstandings that negate any 'growth' among the lead pair.

Now not saying that any of this is not eventually in MaNan's future too😆...but as of now, I commend the writers for maintaining a momentum in terms of their scenes...and not just establishing, but capitalizing on the depth in their relationship especially these past two weeks of the Pandit kidnapping track.


In no particular order, my fav. bits of the week:


1) Manik's helplessness in the face of watching Nandini withdraw from him...the way you see his heart break a little each time she flinches away from him...and yet the fact that he has the courage to fight for both of them this time...has to touch your heart...from the Manik who needed a Nandini to always pull him back from the brink, we have a Manik now pulling Nandini back from the brink...the determination in his voice when he tells her on the stairs that whether she likes herself or hates herself, he's not going to budge...he's always going to be around her so she can reach out to him whenever she needs to...the emotion in both their eyes in this bit...and then the way Manik steps back to allow her to walk away...beautiful stuff from PaNi...and the way he tells her he loves her...and she can take as much time as she needs...he'll WAIT...this was one of the most beautifully depicted scenes possible...without any melodrama, the earnestness that is the hallmark of MaNan scenes making you believe in them as always...







2) And somehow they find the balance b/w light and dark...and Manik Monster Malhotra of all people is going about showing sooo much patience and understanding as he gives her space...as much space as his heart will allow him to give...lol cuz he cannot stay further apart from her than this much...the fact that he's allowing for this much distance b/w them also is huge on Manik's part...the guy who's been obsessed with her and invading her personal space since day one...when he manages this feat, then that's a recipe for awww😆...the bit when he's following her...lol I love the silent communication...and how he's indulging her in a bemused fashion as he makes exaggerated gestures to convey that he's right there behind her...and then his smile when she turns to leave...he was even bobbing his head in the end to that "Agar main kahoon" tune it almost seemed...lol




The face he makes when he says "filter coffee nahin hai"😆...and then talking about his preference for Earl Grey tea😆...sab kuch try kar liya bechaare ne to get her to smile but didn't work...I did wonder if Nandu will procure Earl Grey in the future to make him smile😆





3)So desperately he wants to heal her and yet she is not in a state to allow him to touch her as he wants to...all of this yearning is so beautifully communicated through their eyes...

But what really touches your heart are those moments when both of them try to be BRAVE for EACH OTHER...like in this finger locking bit...Nandu makes this effort cuz she sees him looking sad about his attempts to make her smile not working...so she takes a deep breath, gathers some courage from somewhere inside her, struggles but still reaches out to him tentatively...and what a beautiful moment it makes for...anyways you can't go wrong when you focus on their hands😆...one more added to the list of their many lovely hand scenes...I loved the way Manik looked at her as she reached out to him like that...and then a smile slowly spreading on his face...he was trying to make her smile but she reached out to him to console him somehow even thought she isn't able to battle her demons properly...this moment of communication as if she's saying, "I'm trying, Manik"...and his smile has so much love and hope in it as he looks back at her.











4) Nandu being paralyzed by her trauma again was fantastically portrayed by Niti...the way the memories assault her...you feel like you're right there with her...sickened by the progressively increasing inappropriate behavior she was subjected to...

But ofcourse the slap scene was something else😆...In the midst of so much tension, terror in Nandini's eyes, we get MaNan circling back to their beginning...punch/slap😆...I love how in a sense a punch/slap always LEVELS them...especially this time toh there was that sense of "equality" if you will to it cuz they both slapped each other😆😆...Manik in frustration to get her to snap out of her fit of terror and Nandini in somehow finding her fighting spirit again...finding that Nandu who doesn't take crap lying down from anyone...love showe notwithstanding😆...this is kinda where the writers reminded me of why I invested in this story for this long😆...you just don't get such a range of reactions b/w a pair on TV...literally one epi before they were holding hands/fingers...and bam next epi they are slapping each other...what's not to love😆


All the flippancy aside, I LOVED this bit for the way Manik's reaction moved from the shock at getting slapped to a kind of satisfaction at having his spunky Nandini back in that moment...and then the pride and encouragement in his tone as he said, "That's my girl"...I was sold in that moment







And Nandini's reactions...ranging from a delayed sort of shock at having slapped him to responding to his "That's my girl...she never gives up" statement...you can see how this starts to calm her down...



5) Majnu Manik😆...I still am a little in disbelief watching how unabashed this guy has gotten in expressing his love for her...chacha-chachi, aadha college, koi bhi saamne khadaa ho😆...Manik has eyes only for his girl and now he's going about declaring his feelings too😆...despite the fact that Parth looked super sleepy in this scene😆...Manik's heartfelt words of pride and confidence as he spoke about what Nandu means to him...the way he said, "She's special"...and Nandini's reactions to all of this...bit by bit he got through to her...and it showed in that last scene...he managed to extract a ghost of a smile from her...for who could resist smiling in the face of such shining love in his eyes...Manik was like the personification of pyar mein beh jaana in that scene...ki duniya, jahaan, nothing else matters but her...and her smile...which he is so desperately craving.







6) Sorry for the long rambling already but I must mention the precap too...all day long this boy was brave for his girl...even as she literally crumbled before his eyes...the girl who's always been his rock...crumbled before his eyes all day...but he held on, didn't let go...gathered all the courage and hope that she's inculcated in him and kept trying all day to heal her somehow...and after yet another round of positive advice where it sounds like he's repeating her own words of advice back to her...lol...after a whole day of bravery, finally he has his moment of vulnerability and needs his dose of Nandini to keep going...what a lovely thought..."I need a hug...I just need it"...and when has Nandini ever denied him no matter what it costs her...the tender fragility of this moment is achingly beautiful...the tentative way in which she puts her head on his chest and the way he closes his eyes as if finally home for a bit.






Ok ho gaya😆...Had to blab.

Created

Last reply

Replies

29

Views

5k

Users

16

Likes

105

Frequent Posters

QueenOfHell thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#2
manik following nandu and his cute head dance and the casual tune and the way he ask her whether he should go and her cutiee sa no all this was just awesome i loved loved loved that scene it stole the whole episode
also the slaps were my favourite this weak
eventually slaps seem to be more romantic than the kiss 😆😆😆
and the joining of pinky finger by nandini was also very good and best part she had to close her eyes and collect strenght for doing that.
the secnd thing i liked was the cabini hug and the small details like nandini jerking even on navyas ...touch they never forget to show such small details i even liked manik and chacha or mancha bcoz manik was so proud and confident in his love and was reminding her the reasons why he fell for her that convo was love and chacha acted so naive😆😆😆
this week even after less screen time to manan i liked all episodes except sometimes during mukti scenes and kudos to navya for the first time i liked her
KY2 is coming back and how😳😳😳
i m proud to be its viewer
and ya i lve all your post and also ur love for jeena jeena and jaise mera tu
keep fangirling dear i love to read ur posts😊😊😊
SankiPagal thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#3
Hayyye maaar do tum mujhe ..


Itne saare pheeels Ufff wo bhi anu ki zubani...

Mashaallah Mashaallah!


LOvely post... DITTO to everything.. !
geet.a thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#4
AY: 🤗
GIFs and ur words..matlab. kya bolu main? I LOVED it all


I don't think I have a fitting reply to this post, but all I want to say except I agree is that the way this show has managed this kind of reversal and yet kept them as equals is amazing.
Manik, the epitome of impatience has been showing so much patience, so much understanding, that its a clear to all how far he's come, that inevitably, his growth is because of this almost shattered girl, who still manages to slap him post a panic attack🤣

I loved that scene so much, his helplessness in the face of her panic, as he could not get through to her, terrified him, and he HAD to make her snap out of it, by slapping her. And he did get through to her.
It was funny but so beautiful at the same time. such adorable bacchas!

That conversation with chacha and rishab: I LOVED how manik and rishab have this silent partnership and how manik called nandini chacha's daughter..it touched me...
His eyes and his words tried to remind her of all the reasons why she is so special as a person, as an individual, she has qualities no trauma can take away from her.
When she had said she does not like herself anymore, and feels lost, he stood up for her against this feeling of hers, and defended her, supported her, and as it were, threw some light over why he thinks this girl shines all the time. And he finally managed to get a first healing smile for her..
Without touching her or addressing her directly, he managed to comfort her...
These kids really do a number on me. haha

The precap was so beautiful, manik's energy source after all, needs to replenish his strength for the next day, so he can be strong again.
I loved that he simply stated he needed a hug, with so much haq, rather than just hugging her like he usually does by just pulling her to him.
Something about that vulnerability, and the way she saw it and gently just put her head on his chest, was so tender. When he closed his eyes, I thought, it's home for him. Some relief after a long, tiring day.

Again, sorry for the rambling, scattered thoughts..

GREAT post!


Rutu01 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#5
awesome Post loved what u have written
manan ...their love story...the journey is so beautiful ...and these moments just steal your heart ...you cant help but fall in love with them over n over again ...how true they are to their promise to be for each other humesha ...how when one gets tired or lost the other one picks up the battle to fight ...

and kudos to Pani to bring alive Manan on screen in full glory ...they are doing a fantastic job ⭐️

anamikamundon thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#6
Thank you 😃 thank you 👏 thank you 👍🏼
Mimi2609 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#7
a very lovely post and analysis of the best scenes for past week😃
i also loved all these scenes you wrote above and you wrote so beautifully about them😳
keep doing such analysis every week😉

and so true this is among the very rare love stories which doesnt lose its charm even after the ILU
and this is the real truth because love is only the beginning actually for a couple😳
Spero thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#8
Beautifully analysed and written AreYaar 😊

This "I need a hug...I just need it" made me comment. Reminded me of all the times Manan asked each other for a break in the middle of a fight. Maybe now it's time for 'I need a hug' 😊

I really like the role reversal being played out by Manan. Life really does come full circle. Everything that we give, we get back in spades.

I'd like to see the song 'Teri Meri Baatein' from Piku being played on Manan. It's been one awesome journey 😊

Leharon se hai
Saagar se gehri bhi hai
Ye teri meri baatein
Rulaati bhi hain
Gham mein hansati bhi hai
Ye teri meri baatein
Ye teri meri baatein..


IFollower thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: AreYaar

Thank you MTV Gods for finally blessing us with HQ epis and allowing for a proper viewing of the epis...in a sense maybe I should be happy cuz I get to do a weekend marathon...lol


Sometimes MaNan are something to marvel about in terms of how far they've come...love stories toh there are many on TV, more angsty, more epic, more many things...but the amount of fulfillment that the writers have managed to put into MaNan's evolution touches the heart time and again...most love-hate stories post the confession phase degenerate into sappy everyday activities...with the hero becoming a mere shell of his former self as he descends into uber Majnu mode...or there are the umpteen misunderstandings that negate any 'growth' among the lead pair.

Now not saying that any of this is not eventually in MaNan's future too😆...but as of now, I commend the writers for maintaining a momentum in terms of their scenes...and not just establishing, but capitalizing on the depth in their relationship especially these past two weeks of the Pandit kidnapping track.

Completely agree with you. Lets sincerely hope they continue with this consistency of theirs and not mess it up like others do.


In no particular order, my fav. bits of the week:


1) Manik's helplessness in the face of watching Nandini withdraw from him...the way you see his heart break a little each time she flinches away from him...and yet the fact that he has the courage to fight for both of them this time...has to touch your heart...from the Manik who needed a Nandini to always pull him back from the brink, we have a Manik now pulling Nandini back from the brink...the determination in his voice when he tells her on the stairs that whether she likes herself or hates herself, he's not going to budge...he's always going to be around her so she can reach out to him whenever she needs to...the emotion in both their eyes in this bit...and then the way Manik steps back to allow her to walk away...beautiful stuff from PaNi...and the way he tells her he loves her...and she can take as much time as she needs...he'll WAIT...this was one of the most beautifully depicted scenes possible...without any melodrama, the earnestness that is the hallmark of MaNan scenes making you believe in them as always...


2) And somehow they find the balance b/w light and dark...and Manik Monster Malhotra of all people is going about showing sooo much patience and understanding as he gives her space...as much space as his heart will allow him to give...lol cuz he cannot stay further apart from her than this much...the fact that he's allowing for this much distance b/w them also is huge on Manik's part...the guy who's been obsessed with her and invading her personal space since day one...when he manages this feat, then that's a recipe for awww😆...the bit when he's following her...lol I love the silent communication...and how he's indulging her in a bemused fashion as he makes exaggerated gestures to convey that he's right there behind her...and then his smile when she turns to leave...he was even bobbing his head in the end to that "Agar main kahoon" tune it almost seemed...lol
Yes.. absolutely true about Manik invading Nandini's personal space. Right from the day 1, when Manik noticed Nandini (after she stood up for Navya against HIM), he just couldn't keep his hands off her- albeit he named it hatred at that time (Yes, of course, HATRED, it is.. Mr Manik Malhotra 😛, WE know better than that!!). Now, poor chap, let alone NOT being able to touch her, can't even come anywhere within breathing space of her.

The face he makes when he says "filter coffee nahin hai"😆...and then talking about his preference for Earl Grey tea😆...sab kuch try kar liya bechaare ne to get her to smile but didn't work...I did wonder if Nandu will procure Earl Grey in the future to make him smile😆
I really wonder, if this is the 1st EVER for Manik, trying to make someone smile, so earnestly, talking nonsense!!! What LOVES makes a man do!!!


3)So desperately he wants to heal her and yet she is not in a state to allow him to touch her as he wants to...all of this yearning is so beautifully communicated through their eyes...

But what really touches your heart are those moments when both of them try to be BRAVE for EACH OTHER...like in this finger locking bit...Nandu makes this effort cuz she sees him looking sad about his attempts to make her smile not working...so she takes a deep breath, gathers some courage from somewhere inside her, struggles but still reaches out to him tentatively...and what a beautiful moment it makes for...anyways you can't go wrong when you focus on their hands😆...one more added to the list of their many lovely hand scenes...I loved the way Manik looked at her as she reached out to him like that...and then a smile slowly spreading on his face...he was trying to make her smile but she reached out to him to console him somehow even thought she isn't able to battle her demons properly...this moment of communication as if she's saying, "I'm trying, Manik"...and his smile has so much love and hope in it as he looks back at her.
One of the most beautiful scenes, that I've known. Who would have guessed that a small gentle "pinky hold" would create such magic!!! I have mentioned this 'pinky hold' in another post, that there is a lot of significance attached to it. In some customs/ cultures, bride and groom hold their little fingers together, before taking the wedding vows- a beautiful start of long-lasting LOVE and TOGETHERNESS. And hats off to CVs for giving us this beautiful scene and 👏👏👏 to Niti and Parth for emoting it so well.
A HUMAN TOUCH CAN SAY MORE THAN WORDS CAN EVER EXPRESS!! And how well enacted by Niti!!! 👏👏👏








4) Nandu being paralyzed by her trauma again was fantastically portrayed by Niti...the way the memories assault her...you feel like you're right there with her...sickened by the progressively increasing inappropriate behavior she was subjected to...

But ofcourse the slap scene was something else😆...In the midst of so much tension, terror in Nandini's eyes, we get MaNan circling back to their beginning...punch/slap😆...I love how in a sense a punch/slap always LEVELS them...especially this time toh there was that sense of "equality" if you will to it cuz they both slapped each other😆😆...Manik in frustration to get her to snap out of her fit of terror and Nandini in somehow finding her fighting spirit again...finding that Nandu who doesn't take crap lying down from anyone...love showe notwithstanding😆...this is kinda where the writers reminded me of why I invested in this story for this long😆...you just don't get such a range of reactions b/w a pair on TV...literally one epi before they were holding hands/fingers...and bam next epi they are slapping each other...what's not to love😆


All the flippancy aside, I LOVED this bit for the way Manik's reaction moved from the shock at getting slapped to a kind of satisfaction at having his spunky Nandini back in that moment...and then the pride and encouragement in his tone as he said, "That's my girl"...I was sold in that moment

And Nandini's reactions...ranging from a delayed sort of shock at having slapped him to responding to his "That's my girl...she never gives up" statement...you can see how this starts to calm her down...

5) Majnu Manik😆...I still am a little in disbelief watching how unabashed this guy has gotten in expressing his love for her...chacha-chachi, aadha college, koi bhi saamne khadaa ho😆...Manik has eyes only for his girl and now he's going about declaring his feelings too😆...despite the fact that Parth looked super sleepy in this scene😆...Manik's heartfelt words of pride and confidence as he spoke about what Nandu means to him...the way he said, "She's special"...and Nandini's reactions to all of this...bit by bit he got through to her...and it showed in that last scene...he managed to extract a ghost of a smile from her...for who could resist smiling in the face of such shining love in his eyes...Manik was like the personification of pyar mein beh jaana in that scene...ki duniya, jahaan, nothing else matters but her...and her smile...which he is so desperately craving.
In fact, I think he wants to SHOW HER OFF to the world as HIS and ONLY HIS!! He is so proud of his Nandini and just can't stop himself. He just can't wait for them to be TOGETHER- OUT in the open!! Remember, he said (a day or 2 before the FC), she better get used to him holding her hands in public.




6) Sorry for the long rambling already but I must mention the precap too...all day long this boy was brave for his girl...even as she literally crumbled before his eyes...the girl who's always been his rock...crumbled before his eyes all day...but he held on, didn't let go...gathered all the courage and hope that she's inculcated in him and kept trying all day to heal her somehow...and after yet another round of positive advice where it sounds like he's repeating her own words of advice back to her...lol...after a whole day of bravery, finally he has his moment of vulnerability and needs his dose of Nandini to keep going...what a lovely thought..."I need a hug...I just need it"...and when has Nandini ever denied him no matter what it costs her...the tender fragility of this moment is achingly beautiful...the tentative way in which she puts her head on his chest and the way he closes his eyes as if finally home for a bit.
Such lovely, tender scene!!! Yes, Manik does NEED that HUG. He cannot function, w/o Nandini's smile and touch!!! Poor chap, how hard he must have been coping the whole day. And as we all know, Nandini is the stronger one, compared to the 2. A well NEEDED HUG that was and once again, sincere appreciation to the CVs, for portraying such small but important gestures in day to day life, in such a beautiful way!!





Ok ho gaya😆...Had to blab.


Beautiful Post, AY!!! All the great scenes in 1 post, and that too with gifs. I am sure most of these scenes would be watched repeatedly.
And it wasn't rambling at all, let alone being long!!! Was such a treat to read and gush about it all over again.
Have a lovely w/e... L
-cherryblossom- thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#10
Anu gushing !!!!!!... *stares in disbelief*...😆...

Well, bang on post madamji... It was just unconditional love from manik for his shining star who was hiding behind the fog of sadness... He just need the tiny ray light to pass through it and he knows she will come out shine even more brightly ...

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".