Talented singers? What about the terrible performances that both Chang and Parleen gave in some galas? They were good before they were eliminated. But Smita was eliminated in the gala in which Parleen gave a terrible performance. Was that fair? Not really. Likewise, Parleen is eliminated when he sang well. Same happened to other contestants too. If they were still in the show, would they want the same? Its great they're supporting who they like but they're out now so they have that liberty unlike current contestants.
People who like NEHA KAKKAR who was more a performer than singer now think best singer should win. But there are people now who think the best performer should win. Everyone has different opinions, what can we do? And was II3 ever about music? I had sadly believed it would before it started. I was brainwashed by mid-day, Mumbai mirror, times of india articles.
P.S. I hope Amit wins despite not being a formally trained singer. Good voice/tonal quality, given good performances in the past (he sounds flat in some of his lesser performances but voice quality sometimes covers it up) Since II3 is not just about sur and taal, he has the "personality" for II3 title. He would make a good II3.
Edited by sonyaee - 18 years ago