MaNan Storyline Consistency or the Inconsistency...explanation...

arathim thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#1
MaNan Storyline Consistency or the Inconsistency...explanation...

Hi Peepz..!!!

I know many of us are cribbing about the storyline being inconsistent especially for MaNan...

Many of us have these questions...

How come Manik is behaving normally at the Holi party with Nandhini...?

Where is his Anger..?

Did he forgive her ...? If so why does he bring it up.. inbetween...?

Is this normalcy for holi episodes only..?

etc.. etc...

So I will try to answer them using my limited understanding... any remaining questions please ask.. i will try to answer...

Explanation:

The Storyline is been consistent so far... but to understand that we have to understand Manik Malhotra... like Nandhini Murthy does... he is a coconut...

He is tough and hard outside.. inside its cool water...

On Valentine's day he was at the Peak of his Anger , Disappointment and Despair.
He was so fearful that Nandhini didnt consider him to be good enough to not kill someone whatever the circumstances...
His fear comes from the fact that inherently he doesnt consider himself deserving of a person like Nandhini... who is out and out Good.. strongly Moral...
He fears that one day she will realize that he is not Good enough for her and leave him...
It was the main reason he put in so much effort when they were together to force down his impulsive behaviour and become more Manik than the Monster... more kind than ruthless... more patient than arrogant... more calm than Angry...
He had tried to make himself deserving of her... become the Manik she deserved...!!!
His Anger towards her on Valentines day was more at himself than her...towards her it was only disappointment that she couldnt believe in him
He feared he failed to make her believe in his Goodness...
Thats why he says to Nyonica... I let you win... not Nandhini let you win...

But inspite of all this Anger, Fear and Despair ... his Love for nandhini did not diminish..
His "I will go back to darkness" was like a little boy breaking things and shutting himself in his room, in anger ,when his mom says by mistake without thinking... that he might not come first in his class...

The boy would be momentarily angry... but would cool down later and start throwing temper tantrums, and then slowly start talking , discussing , then proving to her that he can... and he will...
earning her trust back...

Similarly Manik was first in.. 'Everything is over .. finished' stage...
Then he started his Temper Tantrum stage... he is hurt... he wants her to feel his hurt too...
So he hurts her... but he loves her too.. so he stops...he cant bear to see her in pain...
Next stage discussing with her.. what he wants her to do ... to make it alright... to make his pain stop...
Once she agreed to it.. he will start working with her... indirectly helping her to do it...
Now his anger is at an stage where its been neutralised to the most extent by Hope of things becoming alright like before...
His Anger though still there , his fear still there... but the hope overpowers them...
When hope is there how can Love be far behind... his Love that he was hiding came to forefront the moment Hope overpowered his Despair and Fear...
Yes still you will see the flashes of his Anger and Fear now and then... but mostly you will see him fighting even more than Nandhini for their Hope... although indirectly... he has to take care of his Ego too right... 😆

Manik is sliding down the Hill of Hate .. right into the lake of Hope and Love... !!!😊




Edited by arathim - 10 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

56

Views

5.1k

Users

20

Likes

135

Frequent Posters

dushturain thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#2
Best post ever!! bang on post Aru...kisses from me muwah muwah muwah...

exactly exactly exactly...

few lines I want to point out...


He had tried to make himself deserving of her... become the Manik she deserved...!!!
His Anger towards her on Valentines day was more at himself than her...towards her it was only disappointment that she couldnt believe in him

But inspite of all this Anger, Fear and Despair ... his Love for nandhini did not diminish..
His "I will go back to darkness" was like a little boy breaking things and shutting himself in his room,

but mostly you will see him fighting even more than Nandhini for their Hope... although indirectly... he has to take care of his Ego too right... 😆


Now I want to say something too...which i shred with some in Manik AT...

I want to say, this is not a drastic change...this was bound to happen...

When Manik was being cruel to Nandini,he was still furious and angry like hell at her...

All Manik needed was some time to cool down and he will see sense...

I agreed with Mukti when she said these two needs to be kept apart...

All I felt is, Manik needs some time to calm down and come around...he knows he can't live without Nandini, he knows she is selfless and how much she loves him...

but he was acting like a jerk with her because that time he didn't hv time to calm down...


Now, few days have passed...he has calmed down a lot...

He saw Mukti- Abhi relationship..their true love...and had a heart to heart convo with Mukti which made him realize he is still hoping to get back with Nandu...not only that...he realized himself he can't stay away from her...

And then he had a conversation with nandu himself...all these things..bound to change his mind, affect him a little...

Manik and Nandini are lovers after all...they had a fight...he was angry...big deal...now he is calming down...

and the way he is behaving around Nandini yesterday is not sudden but it is quite logical and appropriate...he can't stay blistering angry at her forever can he???


I dont think Manik is planning something big to hurt her...he is just being playful and teasing her...

He already admitted defeat in the war/challenge he and Nandini pledged against each other..hope against hatred. So he is just playing along...

Edited by dushturain - 10 years ago
Chickee thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#3
Res... Dying at work on a saturday wala res ... Grrr
arathim thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: Chickee

Res... Dying at work on a saturday wala res ... Grrr

My poor baby.. cho chorry.. you are suffering.. here feel better...🤗
Serendipity2015 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#5
Simply..yet, beautifully put across Arathi. I think the cvs need to read whenever they forget what is it that they wanted to show or tell in their episodes. 😊
arathim thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: Serendipity2015

Simply..yet, beautifully put across Arathi. I think the cvs need to read whenever they forget what is it that they wanted to show or tell in their episodes. 😊


LOL !!!😆

Thanks !!!
priyanka3677 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#7
Well said Arathu. He is now fighting in favor of hope himself.

Like they accepted abhi for Mukti.

Indirectly he has worked on hope for true love on Nandu's insistence
fan145 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#8
The thing is ppl r nt getting who manik malhotra is ..even i donno still the guy is actually a huge book which only nandini had learned almost compltly ..we need to understand him and her to understand wat they r trying to show us ...i neevr felt the inconsistency in the show ...bcz gadha will always claim to hate her but we all knw how deep he loves her ..he broke the 12yr tradition of conducting holi party in clg just for her ..and then he claims its to make her angry ..lolz...he dont even care wat world thinks ..all he care is her being vth him during this happy festival...and then he claims he hates her ..lolz...this hate is just a facade ..
He is holding back bcz of the fear ..once he overcome that ..the he will never turn back ..
filter.coffee thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#9
oh arathi i love reading your posts.puts a smile on my face
aairahahmad thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#10
Wow...i dont have any question relating to this track...
i was happy and content...but then i read posts related to consistency n believe it when i am saying this then also no question was arising in my mind...i am so dumb sometimes...also my mind and heart both works in a sync and dont let me feel too many or say TWO MANY emotional aspects at once...so i was in my la..la..land.. happily enjoying whatever the cvs were showing us as atleast the manan scenes were awesome so i was being happy...

but look at you... it seems u know my mind better...amazing naa..u didnt get me...ok let me explain...
even though i feel one emotion at a time basically...it also leaves my mind pretty quickly...
so before my mind can come to these question...and starts its own theory of reasoning...BANG...
HERE COMES ARATHI WITH FULL EXPLANATION..WAH..WAH..WAH... 😛 ...even before the question...of mine...

And as usual ur explanation is very satisfying...so here a BIGG THANK YOU for saving my already messed up head from getting more messed up...by these questions...n also for saving my time...i was gonna waste in future over these...

SHABASHHH...GIRL...U ROCK...

P.S- I dont think anyone will want to have any question but even if they do...u r there naa... obviously to give them the satisfying answers...

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".