Discussion: Should judges be saying this?

Page

193980

Suspended

Posted: 18 years ago

Amit is no doubt one of the best on II stage and deserves all the praise but when judges say things like 'I don't know about the result but you are already my Indian Idol' then do you think it is justified or right?

Shouldn't judges encourage everyone rather than making such declarations and demoralizing other singers? This mostly comes from Anu Malik. Udit ji these days gives apt comments and always have something constructive to say.

Anu Malik's comments along with Sony's match making🤢 is bringing II standard down.

Quote

Frequent Posters

kggk_fan01

@kggk_fan01

Inactive

Posted: 18 years ago

Although I was happy when Anu said that because Amit is my favorite singer, I dont think he should have said that.

I mean if he said that, it will impact everyone. All the contestants might lose hope. and it will definitly encourage those who are Anu fans to vote for Amit.

Yes, I agree. Anu's comments are really annoying now. As im new to watching the show(meaning y first season) I thought my favorite judge was Anu, but seeing what he's been up to lately, my opinion on him is chaging 😳

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

-shehzaadi-

@-shehzaadi-

Rocker

Posted: 18 years ago

exactly! i thought the same thing when he said that too. sometimes he has good intentions and opinions but he needs to watch the words that come out of his mouth. he could have said anything like "if you become indian idol i will be very happy" or "you will be indian idol if you keep singing like this" but "you are already my indian idol" was too much. i felt bad for the other contestants even though i really like amit.

Quote

FGGfan

@FGGfan

Inactive

Posted: 18 years ago

well i think first of all they shouldnt be asking judges their favs since it makes the contestants moral down and anu for sure says the truth

Quote

Dayeeta

@-Dayeeta-

Inactive

+ 2

Posted: 18 years ago

exactly, i also think so!
i also felt this when JA said tht there is no better singer than amit in this show, we all agree tht amit deserve praises but not by doing disgrading others
this is my point of view! 😳

Quote

xxxxx

@~PuNk PrInCeSs~

Inactive

Posted: 18 years ago

i dont think tht anu malik should say these things as it discourages the other contestants..n its not up 2 him 2 decide who the next ii wil be..its only the junta's decision..his comments r really hurting the contestants n should think twice b4 he opens his big trap!
sorry 4 beimg offensive but this is how i feel.. 🤢

Quote

krishna

@glacious

Inactive

Posted: 18 years ago

i wud like to say one thing abt anumalik's comments
when smita and parLeen was in bottom 2.anu said that based on the last gala perfomance he wud like smita to stay.anD this saturday when he was asked to choose b/n parleen and deepali he chose deepali becoz her voice suits the mike.wat the hell.....the judgemEnt WAs suppOse to be on thE basIS Of the gala performance right???

Quote

Pooja

@cool_pooja

Inactive

Posted: 18 years ago

Anu shud have expressed his liking for a song in a different way. By supporting amit so much, he is effecting the pattern of voting which is not right. 😊

Quote

Sharmila

@spsharmila

Voyager

+ 3

Posted: 18 years ago

Too much praise, too much hype can do lot of damage.....
1) it can go to the contestents head and he can become careless thinking that no matter what he is the best and his performance can slip ( Actually I don't think this is true in Amits case, he seems to be a level-headed person.)
2)In last two seasons the contestent who was hyped by the judges never won. 😕
So for amits own sake I wish that anu or any other judges refrain from praising him too much ( which,I know that,amit's magical singing makes them do it 😳 )