a omment on music shows......

no offence to any1, i think sa re ga ma n star voice of india has got talent which is far better than ii3. amit paul of ii3 is the only contestent whos in true sense of that standard the rest is all......

the contestents of sa re ga ma n star voice of india not only sings well but their performance on the song is very natural. the performances produced by ii3 contestants is more like forced or artificial, i dont even find ankita's performances that ntural n orignal. u can easily see the joy on the contestants of sa re ga ma n star voice of india faces while they r singing which clearly is absent in ii3 contestents... dont know the reason though. i guess ii3 contestnts r concentrating more on the other stuff rather then singing.

looking forward to more comments.........

Originally posted by: Preeti_285

I dunno why you're comparing 'coz Indian Idol 3 is a PACKAGE idol we are looking for.. not just a singer. This is a unique show.

thats wat i am trying to say that u can find the package singer in the other music shows more. here in ii3 amit is the only package singer that u can relate to. the rest is all fake.

i dont usually watch saregama...but the few episodes i dd watch...i can say, saregama doesnt have as many viewers because it really isnt too interesting....I mean it doesnt have any fun, any masti that indian idol does...I agree all the masti is for TRPs...but seriously, we like it...II ka mauhol hi bohot different aur kool 😎 hain

no ways...
saregamapa and voice of india
is too much boring,
atleast for me
and i am not comparing II3 to any other show
bcz i know II3 is the best,
in II3 every contestant have their own guts...
so i prefer to watch it!

Originally posted by: Mosammad

i dont usually watch saregama...but the few episodes i dd watch...i can say, saregama doesnt have as many viewers because it really isnt too interesting....I mean it doesnt have any fun, any masti that indian idol does...I agree all the masti is for TRPs...but seriously, we like it...II ka mauhol hi bohot different aur kool 😎 hain

yes the same thing what i feel...

Originally posted by: Desi rani

no ways...
saregamapa and voice of india
is too much boring,
atleast for me
and i am not comparing II3 to any other show
bcz i know II3 is the best,
in II3 every contestant have their own guts...
so i prefer to watch it!

guts for other thigs like creating drama n stuff in the program n not for singing m sure

Originally posted by: atfatfatf

guts for other thigs like creating drama n stuff in the program n not for singing m sure

not at all yaar,jo sony kahega wohi karenge nah

they are not the makers of ii3

and fun,drama is only in rubaroo

if u watch carefully then u may realise...

and i am talking abt guts of singing.

not at all yaar,jo sony kahega wohi karenge nah

they are not the makers of ii3

and fun,drama is only in rubaroo

if u watch carefully then u may realise...

and i am talking abt guts of singing.

if this fun, joy n masti with a touch of elligence n serious ness remains on the faces of contestaents which is clearly missing....... can improve their singing. wat i wanna say is that while watchin other music shows i 've found all these things in the contestents. even in ii2 n ii1 u could easily find the seriousness n dedication among the participent........ clearly lacking in ii3 perticipents except amit.