What prompted Robbie to change his stand?

Ryka thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#1
Meri Dimak ki bathi kuch zyada hi dheir se jalti hai... It is only now i am wondering what/which moment cause Robbie to change his stand so drastically? And those creatives dont bother to justify that 😡 😡

Here was Robbie on the wedding day saying he deserves this punishment to see the love of his life go away from him. At the party he told his mother 'Main yahan apne dard ka sath dene aaya hoon' and he told Ishita that It will be always Kasturi for him and he seemed quite prepared for the fact that it is going to be a lifelong wait. 😭

The next thing is Robbie sees Kasturi-Raunak together in the car park, he tries to get in touch with her desperately....may be he wanted to tell her something(But What?). The accident happened and the next thing we see is... Robbie is wants her back in life, It is not about Love anymore he says....It is about Life.

So what do you think was that defining moment that Robbie decided to win back his love? There has to be some explanation as to why Robbie changed over night? The creatives need a whack for not giving this explanation😕
Edited by Ryka - 18 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

21

Views

1.5k

Users

15

Frequent Posters

shruti thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Elite Thumbnail + 9
Posted: 18 years ago
#2
Thats the thing which is going on in my mind also. What is Creative doing with Ro's character.

When RaKa were getting married & Devika asked Ro 2 leave he said he didn't believe his luv & now this is hos punishment 2 c his luv becoming sum1 else & then at party he said Ishita he came 2 give saath of his bets frd & luv & then yesterday he is all out 2 win back Ka.
I donot understand what the creative heads are doing wid Ro's character as every next moment he changes his stand.

Shruti
Zuzana thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 18 years ago
#3
I think he was devastated to see Raunak carry Kasturi up the stairs and our dear Robbies imagination of their 1st night.... prompted him to change his stand?
beagleboy thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#4
or perhaps it was a 'near death experiance'which happened when his car hit that beautiful corner tree! 😆 or perhaps it was at the point when the script writers decided to go on holiday and borrow the kth script for just a while (over the summer only) 😆

He is probably confused and the more he sees kas with raunak the more he feels like he is being wronged. The closer kas and raunak get the angrier robbie gets. and i dont think anyone can be rational when they are so madly angry about something...so i dont think he is being rational now.



euphoric thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 18 years ago
#5
Ryka,

We r watching kasturi and not KTH(farak kya hai mat poochna )... its Ishita here dear and not Archie 😆 😆 😆 ... though the chances of her turning into Archie are high enuf are bright... go bachcha ur guru waiting for u in asylum!!!

okay Robbie wanted to punish himself and then changed his mind.... tell me one thing when was it that he wasn't confused?? Okay he mentioned he wanted to give himself that pain but did he mention he want to suffer for the rest of his life 😕 .... so I think now he thot he has suffered enuf and has finished his term so now should get back in action!!! 🤔

ok ok... I agree that I don't have any logical explaination to this either.... and u want to whack creatives for not giving any logical justification to this..... tell me aisa kya ho raha hai is show par jab humme creatives ko whack karne ka mann nahi karta?? 😕

Sonia
Edited by sonia_s11 - 18 years ago
-JC- thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 18 years ago
#6
I agree with you RK_Fan. I thought at the wedding he could not have done anything...altho he wanted to (remember the dream with the gun--lets assume it was Robbie's). But he held himself back at that time and good that he did because he deserved some heartbreak for what he did.
Then he continued to torture himself with the sight of Ronak-Kasturi entering married life and even having the dream of their first night together. I think that was the last straw for him. His mom comes and tells him to control himself and he realizes that he needs to get a hold of his life. So the next thing we see is at the breakfast table a determined RK. Altho he still doesn't share with us what hes thinking or feeling.
Then we see him meeting Kasturi on the street and that when we get an inkling of his intentions when he tell her that he can reach her whenever he wants.
Even tho hes made this determination or at least is on the road to that kind of stance...he still feels the pain of seeing Ronak-Kasturi. He has absolutely no one left that he can turn to and share his pain. His only companion is his pain and what else could he have done but show his pain to the one person that matters most to him -- Kasturi. So he came to their party and shared his heart with Kasturi and anyone else who asked. But Kasturi again pretends to have killed her feelings for him and have moved on in life...so he hurts himself because he knows she can't bare to see him hurt. But shes again cruel and tell him that she only came to him because his mom told her to. So now he feels that he needs to get her out of her denial and make her realize that she still loves him and is not capable of loving anyone else.

Most of the above is not explicitly shown but i have taken the liberty to induce this from Robbie's expressions and dialogs because i can't believe that people change their stance so irradically. I needed to make a bridge of thought process from one decision to another. Hope you all can accept this and lets c what Robbie does next. 😃
Edited by jinc118 - 18 years ago
ismita thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#7
Very good Ryka............You have raised this topic.
Even I am breaking my head to think as to what would be actual reason for his sudden change.All I can think is

Either the creatives are confused of Robbie's character(Which they are always) and trying to mess it up big time.

one more option is that ,there is something going behind.
On the wedding day he said ,it is his punishment and looked like he had accepted his fate.He was mad but he did not show the signs of winning her back.

Another thing is ,Did he know something about Raunak's past that would harm kasturi??Did he read the letter? These are the questions bothering me.Because in yesterdays episode,he said that if has to choose between love and friendship ,he would always choose friendship but here the question is about zindagi, which he is not ready to leave.

If he is doing everything for kasturi's welfare then,that would be a very cool twist.
Mehr-k thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#8
i guess they want to show how impulsive behavoiur and unstable mind makes a person ruin his or her life. on many occassions robbie has acted or made decisions on impulse without thinking about the consequences. right choice after all is everything and if a right choice is made at first it always brings great results. and now also he is actiing out of emotions and anger.
hey robbinhood what about taking anger management classes? 😆
Edited by kutcher - 18 years ago
-JC- thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 18 years ago
#9
Ismita yaar tere muh mein ghee shakkar. I love the way you think. 😆 That would be a really awesome twist. 😛
ismita thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: jinc118

Ismita yaar tere muh mein ghee shakkar. I love the way you think. 😆 That would be a really awesome twist. 😛



Hey I am trying to find some positiveness in the negativeness,I think I am still in the denial mode.If the creatives want to show us something different from KTH ,I think this would be the awesome twist.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".