Snape Killed Dumbuldore But Y

Page

Next Last

Farhan

@mfarhaniqbal33

Explorer

Posted: 19 years ago

Anyone remember when Hagrid tells Harry in sixth book that Snape and Dumbuldore were arguing, what was that about i bet u it was about his death or something cause if he really wanted to kill dumbuldore he wouldnt give that suspicious look at dumbuldore right before he killed him, anyone know what could it be make a wild guess

Quote

Frequent Posters

Alishah

@alishah

Inactive

Posted: 19 years ago

um...prolly snape helping draco??
i unno. i juss kno that i HATE snape!!! that stupid b*stard! he killed Dumbledore 😭

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Nishani Haripersadh

@Nishani

Inactive

Posted: 19 years ago

We will just have to wait for Book 7 to really know what transpired between Snape and Dumbledore.

Quote

Misha

@-misha

Rocker

+ 3

Posted: 19 years ago

Well snape worked for voldy . and he wanted to help draco too. tht's y he did it

Quote

Zerin

@uglyduckling2

Inactive

Posted: 19 years ago

I usually read the harry potter books twice and thrice and all that but this book.........

Since dumbledore is dying in it I didn't feel like opening the book again.

I think Snape is Evil!!!! 😡

Quote

*~Princess_K~*

@*~Princess_K~*

Inactive

Posted: 19 years ago

well, i actually like his character, really, but I don't think he had anything agains Dumbledore, alot of ppl here think that he did it for brainwashing Voldemort that he's on his side maybe...we'll have to see what happens in book 7.

Quote

shruti maharaj

@puppypower

Inactive

Posted: 19 years ago

i think he was really on voldermorts side or maybe he killed dumbledore because of the unbreakable curse he had made to dracos mother. and if he was on dumbledores side then dumbledore would not have made it part of his plan to die or how would he help harry find the horcruxes. unless dumbledore did that to make voldermort think that now nothing can come in his way of killing harryand then in the mean while snape will try and bring dumbledore back to life 😳

Quote

Freaky Genious

@albusdumbledore

Inactive

+ 2

Posted: 19 years ago

I still am not sure whether Snape has switched sides. (maybe he never did) but I think even if he's not switched sides, Dumby's dead coz it makes sense from Rowling's point of view.

The hero of a story can never grow up to face his problem if he's got a mentor to take care of him. With reference to this please read the last 2/3 chapters of HBP right after Dumby's death. U can still see a profound thinking change in Harry. He's already making decisions.... which was not the case earlier (he's decided to visit Godric's Hollow).

SO maybe dumby's dead but i still belive snape's on the good side.

regards,

freaky genious

Quote

sumant

@sumant

Inactive

Posted: 19 years ago

He did not kill dumbledore

DUMBLEDORE ORDERED HIM TO DO SO
Remember harry saw a pleadness in dumbledore's eyes when he said "Please Severus"

It was coz he wanted snape to do so...

He had som plan in his mind,like faking his death..(i hav relevant points to tell u he faked his death)so as to make voldy careless and then surprising him BIG TIME..