Could it be the age? - Page 2

Originally posted by: ~NehaKakkarLuv~

true...he didn't deserve...but mayb it has to do wid height😉...they were both the shortest contestants!

😆😆😆 wasnt neha the shortest tho?😆

in a way u can say its age becoz there a certain amount of maturity in a vioce and some get this early some late and for Richa is obviously nt here yet! I dnt think he voted her out becoz she was the worst but becoz her vioce isnt mature enough to suit a playback singer... but im sure in comming yrs she'll make it big!

Originally posted by: ~NehaKakkarLuv~

yeah but how can u compare II-2 youngest boys to II-3 youngest girls...so the votin has nuthin to do with age!

buttt.....wen sagar got out....remember it was onli the 6 boys performing....the girls didnt perform.....

den wen girl's performed.....yashashree got out....

and dennn...wen all of them performed 2gether...neha got out....

remember the first 2 gala's were seperate....boys seperate and girl's seperate....thas wen sagar got out....

Originally posted by: mini4frienz

I dont know.. but age could be the factor.. and due to her age or nature she is not evry confortable performing and dancing on stage.. So I think sony wanted her out..
She was focused only for wrong reasons.. never good things like other contestants.. so naturally she became unpopular quite early.. also providing them fodder for drama..
I think excluding jolly,richa performance before galas.. last week was deliberate.. atleast i cnat think of any other reason..
if at al she was highlighted it was to create negative reaction from audience..
anyway she is stil 16.. so i m glad she is out.. she can focus on things that r important rather than focus on peformance and stuff as required by indian idol and misplace her priorities...

Completely agree with you.
I'm glad she's out. At least it puts an end to the negative feedback regarding her personality, attitude (even her family)
Hopefully she will work on her shortcomings and come back strong in the future. If she's immature, I think this experience could have helped her become more mature and sensible.
There are plenty of other shows she can take part it.
Look at Saberi and Desh Gaurav. They only made it to the top 28 of II2 but are doing fairly well in SRGMP. Ritu took part in Fame X and even though the show wasn't too hyped or discussed, many people felt she was one of the better singers in the show. She won praise she wouldn't get in II2. She only got criticism from II2 for being an ardent and annoying Sonu fan.