Circus of Confused Judges !

Do they really disagree or they agree to disagree to create a scene out there for more TRP?

I am shocked when all but Udit commended Smita's performance which to me was not only lackluster (too serious for a soft romantic song) but she was off key and besuri at more than 5 places. Plus, the note she started that song on was different (low) than the original. She struggled in the high pitch during antara. I really thought Udit had a point, but he was taken over and to some extent ridiculed (which was kinda mean) by the other three judges.😕

Why is Javed Akhtar, who seemed like the most sensible of the judges until piano, acting otherwise today? Seems like he's given it all to Annu Malik. 😆

I also don't think Charu was all that bad as Annu was telling. Annu is too extreme most of the time. 😡

PS Looks like we need voting to chose judge of our choice as well. 😃

Ye sab TRP ka khel hai...

Anu Malik & all 3 judges are practicing their actng skills..

Never mind if they may come staring in a movie next year..

I could clearly read faces of all 4 judges..

They already decided what to say to whom, even before their preformance..

It was like remembering the lines from given script and..

delivering the dialouges at right time with right expressions on face.. 🤢

so true i mean only at abhisheks's and ankita's performance was liked by all jugdes

and charu was not bad at all she was perfectly in sur the song was suiting her i thinl neraly every body enjoyed her perormance]

and smita i think her voice was trembling in the start and she was not that good she even went flat at few places

emon was damn good i was tottaly lost inthe song and him..
wat has happened to all judges ...alisha i think was reading some funny comic coz she was laughing allthe time...anu was like to criticizing and same was udit.. javed was ok

Originally posted by: ssuser

I am shocked when all but Udit commended Smita's performance which to me was not only lackluster (too serious for a soft romantic song) but she was off key and besuri at more than 5 places. Plus, the note she started that song on was different (low) than the original. She struggled in the high pitch during antara. I really thought Udit had a point, but he was taken over and to some extent ridiculed (which was kinda mean) by the other three judges.😕

Completely Agree!! Javed akhtar was very rude to udit because udit rightly criticised smita..
javed ji was completely biased bcos he has always liked smita.. smita was very bad in that song..
It wa stotally uncalled for javed ji to say to udit.. "aap pehle jo sabki tareef karte the wahi kiya kijiye" why shoudlnt he speak his mind? Udit was spot on abt smita.. javed ji was the one who was biased.. savariya is such a melodious and beautiful song.. and smita spoilt it compeltely..
such unreasonable behavior from these esteemed judges? And here we blame conetstants ranging from 16 to 20 abt immaturity..