Judges Vs Judges - Round 7 (Final Round) - Page 4

where is everyone?? how come this debate hasnt moved 😕

Viewbie's Note:

Debate will end after about 24 hours of this post. Friday afternoon in India, Friday morning in UK, and Thursday mid-night for USA/Canada.

Originally posted by: ~Ouma*n*Eijaz~

Hi all,😃

So if she came back to Indian Idol 3 gala's she would have a greater chance of winning.

If people knew her better then of course it would be better for Jolly ....but this is not the question of winning or losing ..this is about fairness .Jolly obviously is fine with the decision because judges wouldn't force her to participate ( I know Anu Malik wouldn't)😆.. she might lose out in the 1st round but she was given a chance that was fair enough ...

~ The other reason is the fairness in all this, its not very fair one the contestants who are taking part in Indian Idol 3 to suddenly find out that a old contestant from Indian 2 is going to compete with them. Also for Jolly she must feel a little bit uncomfrotable to be part of a totally different Indian Idol season.

I don't think any of them is feeling uncomfortable ..look at it in this way if jolly wasn't there whoever would have gone out 1st would have gone out but due to jolly she/he might have 1 more week to practice 😆

Overal I don't think it will not work for Jolly to be back in the gala's yes it is a good thing to do to bring her back as Sony promised her but I don't think it will work for Jolly. She maybe one of the first out. So i don't think its fair on her and the contestants.

Luv ya..

Ouma

So u r more worried about Jolly and how she is going to fair ....well this is not about how she is going to do in the gala ....it's about whether it's fair that she got the chance , judges felt that she deserves to go to the gala this year and so did I ..after that how she is going to do whether she is going to be out 1st , is not judges' headache ,neither is mine 😆

cute_zee17 wrote: for kabhie neem neem she should never have been picked after that song but the reason she was picked was out of pity...because of sonuji's harsh words. Do u know what Sonuji's harsh words mean???? It means ouster of Monali although according to me she sang piya tose naina beautifully that day ..it means ouster of antara who otherwise was never in bottom 3 except the week before ...janta voted Jolly for some some other reason but they def not paid attention to sonuji's comments .... ..... It is unfair to both jolly and the contestants...why for the contestants?? Well i did mention that already but you never really touched on my last point: Okay here i know i am kinda contradicting myself but i am only exploring another side to my arguement so bare with me 😛 . Jolly has had over a year practice and learn her music well whereas whether they are confident or not the contestants this year have had a lot less practice and have had to work really hard. Putting someone so much more experienced such as jolly who has already been through the proccess amongst contestants who do not have such and advantage give jolly a greater advantage!! This is EXTREMELY uinfair to the contestants this year. How would you feel if you were in a contest working really hard trying your best and then all of sudden someone who has already been in the such a contest who is so much more experienced is suddenly put in to compete with you...the first thing that would come to your mind is that it is not fair!!! Therefore it is unfair to the contestants as well!! She may have fallen sick...but it would have only been fair if she would have competed in the piano rounds in the last 2 sahi and since there were 5 this time she would have had to make a tougher stand. I still strongly feel it was unfair to let jolly go straight to the galas!! Well...now as zaara(myself) I must say bruno4...you had some excellent arguments there 👏 it was extremely hard to rebutt those....i have tried my best!!! Hope not to dissappoint udit fans!! As u said that u r contradicting urself ..u said she was a weak singer and now u are saying she is stronger singer than others ..what I am saying is, the people who r making decisions have to go by some guidelines and follow those ..they can't be confused like u and me ...so they made this decision ..I still think Jolly is a weak singer yet I think the decision they had taken was fair under the cicunstances ....😛 thanks for those nice words ..u did pretty good job too....

.

- Overall, i think if we look at this ethically it was the RIGHT decision taken by the idol people. But if you think it morally, it isnt fair for this year II3 contestants.

datz it😃

Tabu

So u kind of agree on one hand and kind of don't agree ....but Sony and the judges can't stay in such confusion ..they have to make a decision , right??? ...so they did what is right ...that jolly should get chance to perform in the gala this year and so she did ....😃

lAST but not the least , i want to point it out that , all of u said the same thing that Jolly is a weak singer ..o.k may be ..but does that mean had she been a stronger singer and was in a similar situation she should have got in?????? how fair is that? when a rule is set it should be equal for everybody ..we didn't hear much of jolly last year except that blunder in piano round ..If she was that weak , do u think Sonuji would have chosen her to be in top 28??? Moreover janta chose her too discarding 3 other singers ...so she was as much capable as any other singer in the gala .....

Hence Jolly's direct entry into II 3 was made consciously by the Sony and the judges and I support that decision ....😃😃😃

Take care ....

QUOTE]

Hi Guys I really enjoyed participating with u all in this debate ..Zara ( that's a lovely name ) thanks for the complement buddy...u did pretty good job for urself too 😃 ......

thanks to the IF dev team to host such a wonderful event ..this last topic was indeed interesting because it was not hypothetical but a real situation and though I had a very busy week I loved interacting with the other debaters even if it's for a shortwhile ... 😃

good night and sweet dreams ... 😛

Good job everyone! Good debate! 👏

Topic Closed