concept or dance form?? - Page 4

Originally posted by: rits08

I dont think it is fair to chose between dance or concept... Both are important at their own levels...dance without any concept seems directionless and concept without dance is useless!!

I am not a fan of Mouni, but I really loved Punit's choreography yesterday...it had deep meaning within...

As for Shakti is concerned, she is a brilliant performer, but somehow i think Tushar does not bring up some new innovative ideas, like Punit does... Look at previous year's Lauren's performances...Each of them had the best dances and the best concepts...they were so unique...

Similarly, i dont like Akshat's performances, but his concept was really touching...

And Remo has already seen this much of Shakti so maybe he is expecting more... Her performances in the beginning were amazing...her concept of Arjun-Krishna was brilliant...so cant really say that concept does not matter bco if it was so, Shakti wud not have got full marks for it! Nonetheless, i think it is lack of effort on part of Tushar and not Shakti. He needs to be more creative with concepts!

Originally posted by: kirti31096

Well i never said that concept is not imp but u cant allways do the same dance style yes yesterdays concept was superb but what about dance form ,why punit is allways sticking to freestyle and all concept based on love stories and in shakti s case i know tushar should work on concept but its not fair that remo isnt evenmentioning about it to punit about he doing same dance form again and again...but if shakti will do he will crtisize her

And plzz mouni is also trained in Indian forms and she has experiences of other dance forms as its not as if she is trying all this for first time ,she was in znd also so she has some experience, so punit really do something otherthan freestyle and remo should be the one sayin this to him to try new forms

Originally posted by: rits08

Shakti has got great marks so many times...Mouni got it once...so why do you worry? everyone has its day...it was Mouni's day this time...and whether you agree or not, her performance and concept was way better... she maybe a trained classical dancer but this is way different than classical dance! Moreover, she is primarily an actor.

As for Shakti, she is not only a trained dancer, but has also been a trainer and choreographer. She has been performing and practicing for past so many yrs...so obviously expectations from her would be higher... And as i said, I think Tushar is lacking in concepts...his Arjun one was amazing..m not blaming Shakti for that...its not her fault that he is not choreographing well!

As for Punit sticking to same dancing styles, they also barely get full scores...only when they do something really different they get good scores...i have not liked previous performances as such, but his concepts have always been amazing...and whatever style was given to him he has done that...how would i know why Remo is not criticizing Punit? Maybe he has and it has not been shown on TV...or maybe he has liked all their performances till date and not found anything missing! Whatever be the case, Mouni's performance was brilliant today and nobody can take that away from them!

Originally posted by: akankshaArsha

u r taking it slightly wrong...nowhere TM is saying that mouni punit werent good..they were way too great...its jst that wen punit can stick to one dance form..y nt tushar...simple