Judges Vs Judges - 6th Round

good luck to all contestants 😃

I have Pmd all debators to start debating.

Couldnt PM ronnie, his PM is full 😆

Hey butter I was wondering, is there like a record sheet of JvsJ where we can see which teamz winning, and everything?

yeah...u can check it here..its in da archives..

https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/indian-idol-6/617953/score-board-debaters-list-j-vs-j

omg alredy my time 2 debate lol
ok ill bak in like 45 mins 😃 😆 😆
need 2 get ready 😆

mostly i believe it dont...cuz u c judges praising singers n da next thing u kno, ther gone...for e.g aisha, bhavin...in the wildcard round they sang so good, u wud expect them 2 to be one of the who got chosen, the one hu wud get more votes n well next thing u kno ther gone 😕
howevar,u c JA constantly criticising suhit, esp since he came bak thru da wildcard...buh i dun think it had affected any suhit fans not 2 vote 4 him😕 infact im sure they'v voted 4 him more, dats y he got saved

Hello shello ppl!!😃

Dont think u'll will b knoin me. I'm Shina.

Okie... now to the topic.

I feel tat the judges comments/criticism does affect the votin and mind set of the audience. Ardent fans of tat particular judge will tend to blindly follow the judge's judgement be it justified or not. Another set of ppl, who might not b very much aware of music, will feel tat the judges kno btr as they r v accomplished in their fiel of music. This might fog their independent thinking/views, which might be correct at times.

This is both favourable and unfavourable. The judges might b right and fair in many places. But at the same time, they cud be partial to their favourites, which is wat creates the trouble and the janta might end up voting out the rong ppl. But more often than not, the judges favourites get thru to the next round and this way, we loose some v brilliant singers.

The judges have to b fair all the time, which i doubt is possible, coz every1 has his/her own favourites. But then, they ought to realize how their comments might affect the votin and the deserving candidates

go anu malik, apun tere liye pink silk shirt bhi laya hai, woh pehen kar debate karo 😆 😆 😆

Originally posted by: nsheena

Hello shello ppl!!😃

Dont think u'll will b knoin me. I'm Shina.

Okie... now to the topic.

I feel tat the judges comments/criticism does affect the votin and mind set of the audience. Ardent fans of tat particular judge will tend to blindly follow the judge's judgement be it justified or not. Another set of ppl, who might not b very much aware of music, will feel tat the judges kno btr as they r v accomplished in their fiel of music. This might fog their independent thinking/views, which might be correct at times.

This is both favourable and unfavourable. The judges might b right and fair in many places. But at the same time, they cud be partial to their favourites, which is wat creates the trouble and the janta might end up voting out the rong ppl. But more often than not, the judges favourites get thru to the next round and this way, we loose some v brilliant singers.

The judges have to b fair all the time, which i doubt is possible, coz every1 has his/her own favourites. But then, they ought to realize how their comments might affect the votin and the deserving candidates

manyy fans who wotch indian idol hav hardly ne undestanding of music..they usally go for da hottest gal or guy or mayb they jus go 4 da contestant wid a good voice, or by ther personality..ther r diff possibilities.

well i agree wid one bit ther...dat sum judeges are partial 2wards contestants... alisha likes suhit alot..n suhit has a big follow of fans mainly hu r girls n lil kids
i think wen ppl vote, they vote for their fav singers whether they sang good or bad,it doesnt matter 2 them.they jus want ther fav 2 win, even i admit that i vote 4 chang all the time whether he sings good or bad n i will vote 4 him...soo judges comments wont affect them