Anandi Shiv and their approach to Pramila Natya Mandali - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

26

Views

3.2k

Users

9

Likes

56

Frequent Posters

Adr_Rush thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#21
As I said before Appy Shiv had to take immediate action because the residents were literally om his head and when they are fearing that their children might also get influenced by all this one would want to act as quick as possible and save the disease from spreading too far before it gets late.
I agree the video they showed was really bad and did not prove anything wrong but thats the way our cv's function 🤢
Anandi is trusting Pramila too much and that is something bad but usually the first impression of a person becomes the last impression atleast most of the times it is so. And apart from shiv's saying, Anandi hasn't heard or seen anything else tp even doubt Pramila. And she not trusting shiv is something which even I fail too understand..

Nevertheless loved Ansh voice out their different opinions to the matter 😳
Muktchand thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#22
I think reason behind Anandi not listening or trusting Shiv because Shiv did not seen anything wrong or illegal activity its neighbours who saw & complaints while Anandi herself witness all goody things going inside.
so Anandi beilieve her more than anyone becoz Shiv is not witness anything. So if Shiv claims he himself saw illegal things happening inside dancing school then Anandi might beilieve him.
Anandi is not beilieve neighborhood residents becoz as Promila already made her beilieve that people are against her unreasonably since she is single women in this harsh world
SPuja thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#23
The video clip did show only men coming and going out of Nritya mandal during night. What does this suggest? People will draw conclusion that it was like brothel, because a lady and some girls were living there. If the nritya mandal included some men or the people coming in and going out included both men and women - then it could be said that Shiv should not have taken decision on the basis of complaints and video. But raid during day time was futile (surprisingly, creatives did follow rules and show police women also).
Anandi trusted Pramila too soon - just by meeting her 2-3 times and seeing the dance performance twice, she came to conclusion that neighborur's complaints are baseless accusations? How can she say that she knows Pramila well? Even after Purabia's arrest, how can she be so confident that Pramila is not wrong, and why she is saying that she cannot accept it till she talks to Pramila? If Pramila is wrong, will she accept it before Anandi?
libsrocks thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#24

Originally posted by: aparnauma

Pramila is doing both legal and illegal work at the same time.

Anandi has only seen that part of Pramila's work which is completely legal.So on that belief she is standing up to the Govt officials on behalf of Pramila.So she was not wrong there.

Whether she suspected Pramila or not she should have paused to wonder why the police is after the lady.After all police and the system in our country do victimise innocent people too and unscrupulous politicians are known to use police and law to their advantage..

She was not wrong in protesting against the raid but she should not have taken it personally when Shiv did not listen to her .

Shiv should have gathered evidence before conducting the raid.It is wrong on his part to conduct a raid simply because the neighbours complained.He has a duty towards people but he should make sure that he got the facts right before acting.

Lastly I don't think the makers ever presented Anandi and Shiv as super man/superwoman who could do no wrong.

The makers only presented them as a couple of human beings who always strived hard to do the right thing against all odds and once in a while making mistakes while trying to do their best.

They are mahan in their intentions but they are as human as everyone else while trying to do what they believe is right.

It is a section of viewers who presume that Anandi and Shiv are mahans and get it right all the time😛



Anandi's helping nature towards Pramila would have looked better if she would have known her longer than few days...no one nowadays get so close to someone so quickly...everyone here might call it's Anandi's nature as social worker but i call it's stupidity...exactly how much does Anandi knows about Pramila and her academy?...She cannot make big claims when she has hardly scratched the surface...i am not saying Shiv and Anandi are mahaan...plz i have never seen any bigger fools than them who have been portrayed as intelligent people...anyone with common sense and knowledge of today's world would be more careful than Anandi
GoodDoc_2105 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#25

Originally posted by: libsrocks

Anandi's helping nature towards Pramila would have looked better if she would have known her longer than few days...no one nowadays get so close to someone so quickly...everyone here might call it's Anandi's nature as social worker but i call it's stupidity...exactly how much does Anandi knows about Pramila and her academy?...She cannot make big claims when she has hardly scratched the surface...i am not saying Shiv and Anandi are mahaan...plz i have never seen any bigger fools than them who have been portrayed as intelligent people...anyone with common sense and knowledge of today's world would be more careful than Anandi

It is not stupidity .It is about believeing in what you see.She was shown the girl's parents how happy they were.Pramila's legal activities are quite sound.She did not have basis to distrust Pramila based on the activities which she herself has seen.

The only thing she did not do was pause to think why the police is after this lady.Are they persecuting her for no reason if so she would have all the more reason to protest and if she found that police are being suspicious for a reason then she should have looked more closely.

It is not the question of intelligence or common sense.Nobody in real life suspects every person they come across.
Anandi has no reason to suspect this lady's actions from what she has seen while she had every reason to suspect police actions against this lady it should have made her think in the first place.

731627 thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#26
i like precap before taking action at least ansh talk to each other about promila
Edited by surabhi01 - 11 years ago
goofyCat thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#27

Originally posted by: aparnauma

It is not stupidity .It is about believeing in what you see.She was shown the girl's parents how happy they were.Pramila's legal activities are quite sound.She did not have basis to distrust Pramila based on the activities which she herself has seen.
The only thing she did not do was pause to think why the police is after this lady.Are they persecuting her for no reason if so she would have all the more reason to protest and if she found that police are being suspicious for a reason then she should have looked more closely.

It is not the question of intelligence or common sense.Nobody in real life suspects every person they come across.
Anandi has no reason to suspect this lady's actions from what she has seen while she had every reason to suspect police actions against this lady it should have made her think in the first place.

Perfectly explained.
It will be interesting to see what steps Anandi takes after getting doubt on Pramila..

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".