Rajma idli daily rantings

BombayTroll thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago
#1
Today is the judgement night where

Les selecao will take on might of die mannschaft and we will have one team who will have about 50 PC chance of being world champions so will it be flair of brazil or efficiency of Germany we will know in few hours time

And tomorrow India begin a five match test series against England so lets see


Now coming to episode to me it was clear example of Jaana tha Japan pahunch Gaye chin or like they say banana tha upma ban Gaya halwa so in short I meant to say that whatever effort actors put in or however strong script is unless there is strong direction and good editing the things can go haywire and for me today did not cut much Ice and did not have much impact on me as much as an emotionally heavy duty charged episode needed to have

They unfortunately reduced Raman from a broken but confident guy to a bumbling emotionally bitten by majboori bug caricature who nowadays only likes to cry over spilt milk unlike earlier one who liked to take corrective actions and to be honest I also did not like karan drunk act much for the first time perhaps as he seemed too loud and unconvincing

I also was slightly amused by ishita sudden awakening of her Amma interest when she found out that Shagun did the accident unlike earlier when she was ready to withdraw case against pervert for simmi

I would like to say that I liked the dialogues and attitude of ishita in house which was kickass as she finally hit the nail on head and lost patience and told Raman to stay away as her patience has finally given way and can't tolerate Raman unilateral actions

Ishita breakdown scene was good when she returns from picnic spot though to have desired effect it was needed to have been longer to have slightly bigger impact though divyanka was good

Ashok once again showed he is not the one to be messed but Shagun is busy digging grave for her and Raman

Pervert was cool as cucumber

It was hilarious and slightly painful to see Raman on floor drunk while others carry on with their business

It is good to see family members support daughter in law over son

And I guess Raman ishita relation has ended even before it has started no idea how will they resurrect it

Created

Last reply

Replies

131

Views

10.7k

Users

32

Likes

222

Frequent Posters

alwaysaTVFan thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#2
Res Leo

***EDITED

Leo... after a LONG time, you and me disagree 😆 i was getting tired of agreeing with you every day for the last few days. remember the days when I used to say, i completely disagree 😉😆

Here goes my views :)

Paisa Vasool and Sukoon also.I think I got some satisfaction today. Both of them said the things I wanted them to say, almost. Let me do the paisa vasool and sukoon part first :)


Today was excellent dialogue writing, and acting!!!

This guy plays a drunk just too well... it doesn't look forced, it doesnt look over the top, and like everything else he does, it looks intense. Playing a drunk man is so much repeated and mimicked, it takes real talent to pull it off and not look like a clown. KP rocked that scene.
His helplessness was evident. His realisation almost looked like self-pity, but it was really anger. The man is really all alone now. He has alienated the one thing that held him together. All this for a son who doesnt even call him 'dad'. I do feel for Raman.

DT has been on a roll. SHe has been giving excellent performance episode after episode. Today, her dialogues were something we ALL wanted her to say. We wanted her to stand up straight and take no crap from Raman. SHe was neither selfish nor selfless. She was just matter of fact. "I don't deserve it and I dont need it". How many times have we written this in posts and OSes!!! I couldn't believe it when I heard it.



The thing I don't understand is , now that she knows everything, why is Raman not telling her that he is doing this for Adi? She said she doesn't want meaningless explanation, she just wants the truth. What truth??? According to spoilers Raman doesn't yet know that Adi is the culprit right? If he doesn't, then why does he not simply tell her that he wants Adi to grow up with a mother in the house, not in jail??? If he knew about Adi, then his behaviour and some of Ishita's dialogues would make sense. But thats for tomorrow... today was enough for me to calm down :)

Also, why call a lawyer when Ishita thinks Shagun is the culprit? They were OK to take the case back for the Perv no???😕

So the dhamaakedar confrontation is over, and I won't mind if I dont hear that sad BG music ever again... Man, it is still ringing in my ears.

BTW - lawyer kya sochegi yaar??? CEO of the year farsh pe soya hai, and his wife is talking to me. and his parents are idling around... bichara Raman 😆 I have a chronic back problem. SO I know how much that would have hurt the next day. Not to mention the hangover !!! seriously, bichara Raman. He would have emotional stress and physical pain...and legal problems ... Good Morning Raman 😆
Edited by always_a_TV_fan - 11 years ago
Nichuss thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#3
unres

My take on Epsd

Epsd wise in general it was dramtic...had all

masala for entertainment...

the defect found was everything seemed so rushed up

ishu-raman confrontation...start was so intensed..whr

raman was completely shut down by shattered ishu...

with no answer to her... 😛

then the scene touched me a lot is car scene...

wr ishu coming back home with ruhi rembring her

trust talks to raman...

and raman weeping with all guilt and suffocation..

ishu breaking down and toshiji controlling was

another gud part from Divyanka Di...

but effect on me was less...i cant find a reason...

may be sbs etc...they shown more nicely n i expected a

lot..and in epsd..it sounded rushed..up...😛

coming to drunk scene...

aftr breaking down to toshiji..promising he will

be the gud papa of ruhi..this drunk part was the best

of karan bhai...he just nailed..it...the unbalanced

walking...then falling down...shouting screaming..

everything perfect...here too i didnt get a effect

wht i expected...😔 acting wise dialogue wise...it marked

the episode..everything was overshadowed in this scene..

wen he screams "Adi papa loves u..." im sure...

hard rock heart would have melted...the pain f hurtful..

father...earning love frm his beloved son...

then

ishu-raman confrontation in bhalla house...

i found it so dramatic..yet meaningful in the current life...

in one word Super Melodramatic Episode..

10/10

(even i didnt felt any effect...or felt something

missing...acting n performance was superb..cant

reduce rank for that)
Edited by Nichuss - 11 years ago
BombayTroll thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago
#4
Today

Direction was pathetic

Editing was poor like always as to me it appeared they were in hurry to catch a train

Too much unnecessary drama
..Zainab.. thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#5
Alright, i actually might be in the minority but i liked todays episode. I thought that scene between Raman and Ishita was definitely needed. The bond that they share is actually stronger and deeper than they both think it is. Right one feels helpless and the other feels betrayed but when calm down and think they both can work together.
DT is splendid in such scenes, she brings out such emotions bang on! When she came on and just broke down with her MIL it was so perfect, i couldnt help but feel like helpless with her too. Ishita is going through so much but yet she has to remain strong for Ruhi mostly.

Great post, i am totally looking forward to tomorrows episode it was be hella interesting.
Edited by _Littles12_ - 11 years ago
ravankumar thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#6
I agree with you..this is exactly wat i was thinking..i couldnt connect emotionally today..something was wrong..
Nichuss thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#7
Dittooo even karan acting was gud...the effect was missing...
Was it dialogue...editinng or scene...

It didnt create needed pity ...
Ishu breakdoown lukd rishd up

gud nyt mi
BombayTroll thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: always_a_TV_fan

Res Leo

***EDITED

Leo... after a LONG time, you and me disagree 😆 i was getting tired of agreeing with you every day for the last few days. remember the days when I used to say, i completely disagree 😉😆

Here goes my views :)

Paisa Vasool and Sukoon also.I think I got some satisfaction today. Both of them said the things I wanted them to say, almost. Let me do the paisa vasool and sukoon part first :)


Today was excellent dialogue writing, and acting!!!

This guy plays a drunk just too well... it doesn't look forced, it doesnt look over the top, and like everything else he does, it looks intense. Playing a drunk man is so much repeated and mimicked, it takes real talent to pull it off and not look like a clown. KP rocked that scene.
His helplessness was evident. His realisation almost looked like self-pity, but it was really anger. The man is really all alone now. He has alienated the one thing that held him together. All this for a son who doesnt even call him 'dad'. I do feel for Raman.

DT has been on a roll. SHe has been giving excellent performance episode after episode. Today, her dialogues were something we ALL wanted her to say. We wanted her to stand up straight and take no crap from Raman. SHe was neither selfish nor selfless. She was just matter of fact. "I don't deserve it and I dont need it". How many times have we written this in posts and OSes!!! I couldn't believe it when I heard it.



The thing I don't understand is , now that she knows everything, why is Raman not telling her that he is doing this for Adi? She said she doesn't want meaningless explanation, she just wants the truth. What truth??? According to spoilers Raman doesn't yet know that Adi is the culprit right? If he doesn't, then why does he not simply tell her that he wants Adi to grow up with a mother in the house, not in jail??? If he knew about Adi, then his behaviour and some of Ishita's dialogues would make sense. But thats for tomorrow... today was enough for me to calm down :)

Also, why call a lawyer when Ishita thinks Shagun is the culprit? They were OK to take the case back for the Perv no???😕

So the dhamaakedar confrontation is over, and I won't mind if I dont hear that sad BG music ever again... Man, it is still ringing in my ears.

BTW - lawyer kya sochegi yaar??? CEO of the year farsh pe soya hai, and his wife is talking to me. and his parents are idling around... bichara Raman😆 I have a chronic back problem. SO I know how much that would have hurt the next day. Not to mention the hangover !!! seriously, bichara Raman. He would have emotional stress and physical pain...and legal problems ... Good Morning Raman 😆



Like you said it I disagree

Maybe I am distracted by World Cup madness

But today it did not cut ice for me

Remember the drunk scene where she carried him from Shagun house or in the initial episodes they were bang on today it did not have desired effect

I think editing and direction killed the episode for me

But I liked the house scene and ishita dialogue

Yes Raman thinks about only her happiness

Even if he is doing it for adi

It is for his own selfish reasons

He did not think what effect that would have on ishita and others in family

He indirectly said that ishita is important for him but what the point when train has left the station

It was unbelievable and painful to see him on the floor and others doing things as if nothing happened




posterity thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#9
agreed...xcpt for divyanka scene where she says i dun deserve this...the whole episode was def lacking something...karan's drunk scene somehow seemed pathetic but ineffective in touching me...
BombayTroll thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: Nichuss

Dittooo even karan acting was gud...the effect was missing...
Was it dialogue...editinng or scene...

It didnt create needed pity ...
Ishu breakdoown lukd rishd up

gud nyt mi

absolutely nichus something was missing and something did not seem right

Good night

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".