Originally posted by: Tia.Saigal2002
That is why theyes are ending the serial in July, I think. For those who say that the leap of Qubool Hai and Sanam being played by same actor who played Zoya is similar, well then in this case the idea was also used in many serials before and thank God the comparisons end here. Unlike Madwhobala, The female lead's name in season 2 is not Zoya and just for the sake of fulfilling ppl's demand cv's did not bring back KSG or RV to play the male lead opposite Sanam. Unlike Madwhobala, Qubool Hai believes in women empowerment and not showing women as object or humiliating her in name of romance. Biggest example Tanveer is the queen of the serial, much to our dislike.
I just want to make myself clear. I never said it's similar. I just said that yes there are some influences. And I am not comparing Madhubala post leap to QH2. I am only talking about the short period of Madhubala post leap (about two months) before the script was changed drastically.
I have in other places said QH2 is not the same though some aspects are the same. in fact I said it here too. Sanam was more street smart than Junior Madhu. (When Sanam heard Khala-Khalu talking about ATM, she realized she better try to find another job because if something happens, it will fall on her head).
SaHil was not a romcom, which MaHay was. The dynamic between the two pairs were different. Aahil was attracted to Sanam from the start, which was not the case with Abhay. SaHil had a "hate" relationship, which was not the case with MaHay.
But, there are a few aspects which were taken from Madhubala. This doesn't mean it's a copy, but yes you can say there's some influence. Even if those aspects are not original it still doesn't mean the influence is not from the fact that the first show had used those aspects. The second show is influenced because the first show employed it.
SaHil was written pretty well actually, in their own way. Till they came to the standstill. After which I think the writing has been lacking, development hasn't happened properly and connectivity is not the same. And then, taking into account the earlier influences, the show once again uses a plot point from Madhubala. One can't ignore that.
Does this mean that they will go about it the same way? No. I don't agree it's a copy, but I can't deny that there's been some influences. But that's how the industry is. Everyone influences the other. It's nothing new nor will this be the last instance.
Personally, I was really into SaHil and how they were written and played out. When Tanveer came back, I wasn't upset. I thought it would be interesting to see how they would develop with Tanveer around. And there would be a story which was lacking for a week prior to Tanveer's release.
But then SaHil development came to a standstill. Only to be quickly jumpstarted again without proper development. I have thoughts on this, but will wait to see how it plays out before saying anything. In short, I was fine with Aahil saving Sanam. But after he saved her, everything else seems a bit off to me.
Edited by KhatamKahani - 11 years ago
Hindi TV Shows
Indian Mythology
Kabhi Neem Neem Kabhi Shahad Shahad
Marathi TV
Cricket
Arjun
