Madhubala copy?

Page

Next Last

sia.sd

@sia.sd

Navigator

Posted: 11 years ago

Hi guys,

did you realize that Qubool Hai copies so much from Madhubala and season 1 of QH itself?
It is really sad that they don't have any original ideas anymore. The CV's are out of ideas.
First all the tracks and dialogues were copied from season 1 of Qubool Hai and now that 'the property is Aahil's if he gets married by the age of 30' is a copy of Abhay Kapoor's Madhubala track...
What do you think?

Edited by assiaksgian - 11 years ago

Quote

Frequent Posters

Tina Saigal

@TIA.Tia

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 11 years ago

Abhay Kapoor in Madhubala was a sick psychopath who was under the impression that Dead People killed his father and he was a male cougar who was robbing the cradle and romancing a girl much younger than him and his deadline of marriage was around 38 or 39, I suppose, but Aahil is much younger than him, his deadline is of 30 and in Madhubala, the step mom did not wanted Abhay Kapoor to get married so that the property could be divided among them equally. But here either the property will go to Aahil or it would go to trust and Billo Rani would get nothing , So Billo Rani would herself force Aahil to get married in order to attain the property and then shift the property to her name. So nothing is common between Madhubala and Qubool Hai. And regarding the scenes of Season 2 being copied from Season 1 well blame it on lack of ideas of cv's and taking creative advantage as they are recycling their own ideas. Old wine in new bottle. Done by almost every serial.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

pancakes527

@pancakes527

Voyager

Posted: 11 years ago

They may seem similar. But if you go In depth... The ideas are very very different

Quote

Kanika

@kankabhor

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 11 years ago

QH 2 is mixture of all previous Gul shows with horrible supporting cast minus good story

Quote

KhatamKahani

@KhatamKahani

Stunner

Posted: 11 years ago

Yes, there are similarities to Madhubala post leap--before the upheaval of the story which turned Abhay Kapoor into a psychopath.

Initially QH2 though it had the leap and the similarity of parents' killer's stepson, the dynamic between the two pairs were different. Madhubala post leap was more a romcom, while Aahil Sanam started off as more intense.

Then came the lack of development for Aahil-Sanam, their story at a standstill. Soon afterwards another similarity popped up: The banner. It is similar to the banner of Madhu and Abhay (even though as I said the dynamic was never the same).

Now they have chosen the same idea of marriage for inheritance. (Though I don't think the idea itself is original to Madhubala, I'm sure it's been used before.)

So yes, there have been some influences-- though not completely-- with the initial Madhubala story post leap prior to the upheaval.

Edited by KhatamKahani - 11 years ago