Do you think Alisha is a good judge?

Mods Please dont close this thread I mean I know there are threads to dicuss Alisha but we can not discuss everything in one single thread.I like Alisha as singer but as a Indian Idol judge she is comlete letdown in totality ( her own word)😆
I am not attacking alisha here but tell me what good she did for Indian Idol?She replaced Farah Khan and except her totality and all praising for non singers she is good for nothing as Indian Idol judge.She judges by looking at contestant first and then listening .

Do you think Alisha is good judge ? Do you think she is adding in value to the show ?I wish Sony sends her home and I am sure after going back what she gonna do , Vote for suhit 24/7 😛 I know she has every right to like any person she wanna I don't have problem but if she is Judging Indian Idol then she should do it in a right way .

hi Ajju ..... i gotto agree with you on this one 😉
Alisha is doing an awful job as a judge and so is Udit Narayan.....the only person who is doing a tarrific job as a judge is JAVED AKHTAR 👏 👏

i can't belive it Suhit is still in the show.....i dont want to say this but it seems like another Qazi is around the block 😳 😛 (i really do like Qazi but singing wise NAAAHHHHH) 😆

You know the funniest comment of hers yesterday was not about Suhit. It was about Emon. Hussain asked her if she would give Emon tips to improve and she said--- 'take off your spectacles' 😲 😲 😲

Here is a well-known singer, asked for her opinion on how a newcomer can improve, and she comments on his glasses? So his singing is now so perfect that it needs no polishing? She cannot think of one technical comment to make? Just shows where her priorities are. Next thing you know, she'll tell someone-- 'take off your shirt'. 😆 😆 😆

Please someone send her home. Let her take Suhit with her. 😡

Xactly...I completely agree wid u Ajju...
Wht Emon said in the mimicry are the only words she sayz abt each n evry contestant...Farah was much better than her...shez like learnt 5 6 comments n keeps on repeating them on the contestants they suit more....lol...I m waiting for Anu Ji...I guess he'll be fixing her head....
No offence to Alisha's fanz...!

I think they should immediately remove Alisha as judge.

Because of her we see this kind of results!!! Can you belive?? Suhit is still in and Bhavin and Amit are out?? It' is just a terrible terrible shock for all music lovers....Even during audition rounds I also felt felt that ethere are many other singers who could have gotten a chance instead of Suhit. He can not sing anything other than hard rock. What happened to our music sense???? It is just nor ACCEPTABLE...THEY SHOULD DO SOMETHING ABOUT IT.

Originally posted by: shahrukh fan

hi Ajju ..... i gotto agree with you on this one 😉
Alisha is doing an awful job as a judge and so is Udit Narayan.....the only person who is doing a tarrific job as a judge is JAVED AKHTAR 👏 👏

i can't belive it Suhit is still in the show.....i dont want to say this but it seems like another Qazi is around the block 😳 😛 (i really do like Qazi but singing wise NAAAHHHHH) 😆

Yes Suhit is another Qazi guy in making ....He was patethic yesterday and not at all fit for Indian Idol stage in Javed Ji's words.

Originally posted by: atria

You know the funniest comment of hers yesterday was not about Suhit. It was about Emon. Hussain asked her if she would give Emon tips to improve and she said--- 'take off your spectacles' 😲 😲 😲

Here is a well-known singer, asked for her opinion on how a newcomer can improve, and she comments on his glasses? So his singing is now so perfect that it needs no polishing? She cannot think of one technical comment to make? Just shows where her priorities are. Next thing you know, she'll tell someone-- 'take off your shirt'. 😆 😆 😆

Please someone send her home. Let her take Suhit with her. 😡

For that she will have to understand the technicalities herself na... and sadly she has none of that understanding!!😕

well i dun like the way she just use adjectives for evryone..n praise the bad performances instead of criticizing them..which is sad...

dunno why she does this..
but may be she is right at her plc..i dunno..

she just sits there like a queen 😭

Originally posted by: *Jaya*

For that she will have to understand the technicalities herself na... and sadly she has none of that understanding!!😕

Yeah that is what surprises me. She has sung a number of songs. She should have minimum sense, yaar. Uditjee is way too polite to be a judge, but he does come up with technical points sometimes. Javed Akhtar is on a different level alltogether. But Alisha--- she just goes 'hot, cool'. Thermometer kahinki.😡

this thread is opened only because she supported suhit that day. I bet you any money if she said someone elses name this thread would never open!

also i dont think farah khan was better she doesnt sing and she no right to judge contestants.