Do you think Alisha is a good judge? - Page 4

Originally posted by: buttercup

I think members are trying to say that alisha is unfair in the sense that when others find mistakes in Suhit she doesnt find it..thats why members find it biased..and its even possible coz everyone has different views and they are stating it here.

Originally posted by: atria

You know the funniest comment of hers yesterday was not about Suhit. It was about Emon. Hussain asked her if she would give Emon tips to improve and she said--- 'take off your spectacles' 😲 😲 😲

Originally posted by: Jhon1

ok, but just in the last episode, I didnt see her just praising him and finding no mistakes. She said some negative things about him. I just think its unfair to start blaming any of the judges or suhit himself, for still being there in the top 12, when it all depends on janta votes.

Originally posted by: Jhon1

ok, but just in the last episode, I didnt see her just praising him and finding no mistakes. She said some negative things about him. I just think its unfair to start blaming any of the judges or suhit himself, for still being there in the top 12, when it all depends on janta votes.

I really dont have any idea why you are so very much concerned about makeing others understand what is right and what is wrong...

but imagine if a learned, professional, skilled judge makes dumb decisions then what can anyone expect from janata?!

I was apalled when Hussain asked her abt tips to improve Emon's performance and she came up with " remove ur specs" , that was ridiculous and it made her look dumb I must say.

comparing her judgement , listen to this

to Suhit after his performance " Mr cool dude , ur performace was cool but there are better singers than u and u need to come to their level if u want to go ahead , all with smiles "

To prashant who was 100 times better than Suhit " aapne accha gaya lekin aapke sur flat gaye the , 2-3 times " with seriousness

Now why wasnt the same criticism given to Suhit , she didnt say anything to him except to buck up and do better , whereas to Prashant she points out his flaws clearly .........

this shows her bias, the same can be said abt her comments to Richa and Smita .

To richa " she is a gem of Indian idol, her nakhras are cute " huh hello , u are supposed to judge on singing and performance.

To Smita " ur singing was depressive and dull "

that was bias, where is the constructive criticism when speaking with Richa , her Nakhras are cute what happened to the sur, performance and singing as a whole .

anyway , her judging is completely biased and infact I think she herself is confused on what to say.

Originally posted by: tina59

I was apalled when Hussain asked her abt tips to improve Emon's performance and she came up with " remove ur specs" , that was ridiculous and it made her look dumb I must say.

comparing her judgement , listen to this

to Suhit after his performance " Mr cool dude , ur performace was cool but there are better singers than u and u need to come to their level if u want to go ahead , all with smiles "

To prashant who was 100 times better than Suhit " aapne accha gaya lekin aapke sur flat gaye the , 2-3 times " with seriousness

Now why wasnt the same criticism given to Suhit , she didnt say anything to him except to buck up and do better , whereas to Prashant she points out his flaws clearly .........

this shows her bias, the same can be said abt her comments to Richa and Smita .

To richa " she is a gem of Indian idol, her nakhras are cute " huh hello , u are supposed to judge on singing and performance.

To Smita " ur singing was depressive and dull "

that was bias, where is the constructive criticism when speaking with Richa , her Nakhras are cute what happened to the sur, performance and singing as a whole .

anyway , her judging is completely biased and infact I think she herself is confused on what to say.

exactly my thoughts😛😳.................Alisha ko to galli singing competition me judge banna bhi mana hai😉😆(remember her telling to contestants in the auditions,'aapko bathroom me gaana bhi manaa hai')

Originally posted by: mcm226

Alisha ko to galli singing competition me judge banna bhi mana hai😉😆(remember her telling to contestants in the auditions,'aapko bathroom me gaana bhi manaa hai')

🤣🤣jiski topi uske sarr... wow Mandy😆😆

Originally posted by: S a r a h

I really dont have any idea why you are so very much concerned about makeing others understand what is right and what is wrong...

but imagine if a learned, professional, skilled judge makes dumb decisions then what can anyone expect from janata?!